Drumcondra 1, Everton 7
August 10, 1958
Friendly Match
Tolka Park (Dublin)
Goals; Harris (10), Duffy (13), Thomas (49) (83), Harburn (58) (63), Ashworth (77) (85)
Teams
Drumcondra (2-3-5); Swan; Fullam, Kavanagh;Cosgrove, Girvan, Healy, Cross, White, Duffy, Coleman, Campebll. 
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders(a), Tansey (j), Rea (k), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m), Harris (j), Thomas (e), Harburn (p), Ashworth (a), O’Hara (e). Manager Committee
Att 8,000

Cork Hibernains 2  Everton 3
August 13, 1958
Friendly Match
Tolka Park (Dublin)
Goals; Harris (J) (25) (43), Thomas (28), O’Connor (62), Morley (Penalty 65)
Teams
Cork Hibernian (2-3-5); O’Brien; Doolan, Scanlon; Leavy (Goggins 45), Dorgan, Morley; Jefreys (O’Donovan 45), Redmond, O’Connorr, Hargan, Lych
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Jones (te) (captain), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Labone (b), Meagan (m); Harris (J), Thomas (e), Harbourn (p), Fielding (w), O’Hara (e).  Manager Committee

Shelbourne 3, Everton 2
August 15, 1958
Friendly Match
Tolka Park (Dublin)
Goals; Conroy (15), Ashworth (40) (77), Wilson (75), Hennessey (82)
Missed penalty; Shelborne missed in first half
Teams
Shelborne (2-3-5) Farmer; Burke, Caerns; Watson, Fitzpatrick (j), Hennessey (j), Wilson, Wardley, Hmailton, Hennessey (c), Conroy
Everton (2-3-5); O’Neill; Sanders (a), Griffiths (b); Rea (k), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Harburn (p), Ashworth (a), O’Hara (e)., manager John Carey
Att 9,000

Leicester City 2, Everton 0
August 23, 1958
League Division One
Filbert Street
Referee; Mr. F. Coultas
Goals; Leek (28), Riley (87)
Teams
Leicester City (2-3-5); Maclaren; Cunningham, Ballie; Newman, King, Keyworth (debut); Riley, Walsh, Hines, Leek (Debut), Calder (Debut), manager Dave Halliday
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Harburn (p),(Debut signed from Brighton) Ashworth (a), O’Hara (e), (Debut, signed from Falkirk), manager Committee
Att 34,446

Everton 1 Preston North End 4
August 27, 1958
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. F. Cowan
Goals; Hartsell (1) (8), Harburn (4), Baxter (11), Finney (88)
Missed Penalty (75) Finney blast over bar after he was grassed by Alan Saunders
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Rea (k), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Harburn (p), Ashworthy (a) (Retired 87), O’Hara (e), manager Committee
Preston North End (2-3-5); Else; Cunningham, Walton; Milne, Dunn, O’ Farrell; Mayers (d) (ex-blue), Farrell (a) (ex-blue) (Retired 75),Hatsell, Baxter, Finney, Manager Cliff Britton (ex-blue)
Att 52,405

Everton 0, Newcastle United 2
August 30, 1958
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. D.R Blues
Goals; McGuigan (49), Wright (59)
Teams
Everton; O’Neill (j); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); King (j), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Harburn (p), Fielding (w), Williams (g), manager Committee
Newcastle United (2-3-5); Mitchell (s); Keith , McMicheal; Scoular (captain), Scott, Bell; Hughes, Davies, Wright, Eastham, McGuigan (Debut), Manager Charle Mitten
Att 36,602

Preston North End 3, Everton 1
September 1, 1958
League Division One
Deepdale
Referee; Mr. L.J. Hamer
Goals; Hatsell (25), Maters (37), Hickson (68) (Assist Harburn), Baxter (1-3)
Teams
Preston North End (2-3-5); Else; Cunningham, Walton; Milne, Dunn, O’Farrell; Mayers (d) (ex-blue), Thompson, Hatsell, Baxter, Finney, manager Cliff Britton (ex-blue)
Everton (2-3-5); O’Neill (j); Sanders (a), Griffiths (b)(Debut, Junior Blue); King (j), Jones (te) (captain)(300 League apps), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Hickson (d), Harburn (p)(Last apps, signed for Scunthorpe), Fielding (w), O’Hara (e), manager Committee
Att 28,399

Everton 1, Arsenal 6
September 6, 1959
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. G. McCabe
Goals; Groves (2), Herd (22) (48) (61) (74), Bloomfield (46), Temple (85) (assist J Harris)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); O’Neill (j); Sanders (a), Griffiths (b)(Last apps, signed for Southport); Harris (b), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), O’Hara (e), Manager Committee
Arsenal (2-3-5); Kelsey; Willis, Evans; Ward, Dodgin, Docherty; Clayton, Groves (captain), Herd, Bloomfield, Nutt, Manager George Swindon

Burnley 3, Everton 1
September 9, 1958
League Division One
Turf Moor
Referee; Mr. E.S. Oxley
Goals; Shackleton (24) (32), Hickson (47) (assist J Harris), Pilkington (88)
Teams
Burnley (2-3-5); McDonald; Smith, Winton; Seith, Cummins, Shannon; Connelly, McIlroy, Shackleton, Robson, Pilkington, Manager Harry Potts (ex-Blue)
Everton (2-3-5); O’Neill (j); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j)(Debut, sign from Wigan); King (j), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j)(100 Lge apps), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), O’Hara (e), Manager Committee
Bookings; Hickson (Dissent), Sanders (foul 85)
Att 23,053

Manchester City 1 Everton 3
September 13, 1958
League Division One
Maine Road
Referee; Mr. L.N. Peake
Goals; Barlow (21), Harris (j) (53) (assist Fielding), Fielding (81), Collins (88) (assist Fielding)
Teams
Manchester City (2-3-5) Trauntmann; Leivers, Sear; Barnes, Ewing, Warhurst; Fagan, Barlow, McAdams, Hayes, Sambrook
Everton (2-3-5); O’Neill (j); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); King (j), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j), Collins (r) (Debut, signed from Celtic), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), O’Hara (e), Manager Committee
Att 35,437

Everton 1, Burnley 2
September 17, 1958
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. K. Dagnall
Goals; Harris (j) (25) (assist Hickson), McIlroy (penalty 31), Pilkington (1-2)
Teams
Everton  (2-3-5); O’Neill (j); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); King (j), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j), Collins (r), Hickson (d), Fielding (w), O’Hara (e), Manager Committee
Burnley (2-3-5); McDonald; Smith, Minton; Seith, Cummins, Adamson; Newlands, Robson, Pointer, McIlroy, Pilkington, Manager Harry Potts (ex-Blue)
Att 50,557
Additional-Penalty J. King grassed Pilkington

Everton 3, Leeds United 2
September 20, 1958
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. F. Collinge
Goals; King (23) (assist O’Hara), Jones (penalty 40) (Assist J. Harris), Crowe (55), Cush (60), O’Brien (own goal 90) (Assist O’Hara)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); O’Neill (j); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); King (j), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b), half-backs; Fielding (w), Harris (j), Hickson (d), Ashworth (a), O’Hara (e), Manager Committee
Leeds United (2-3-5); Wood; Ashall, Hair; Gibson, Marsden, Cush (captain); Meek, Crowe, Forrest, O’Brien, Overfield, Chief Coach Bill Lambton
Att 31,105
Additional; Penalty Ashall handling J. Harris cross

West Bromwich Albion 2, Everton 3
September 27, 1958
League Division One
Hawthorns
Referee; C.A.R Woan
Goals; Campball (27), Burnside (37), Hickson (39) (assist J Harris) (88) (Assist Thomas), Fielding (49) (Assist O’Hara)
Teams
West Bromwich Albion (2-3-5); Jackson; Howe, Williams (s); Dudley, Barlow, Setters; Campbell, Burnsides, Allen, Kevan, Hogg
Everton (2-3-5); O’Neill (j); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); King (j), Jones (te), Harris (b); Fielding (w), Harris (j), Hickson (d), Thomas (e), O’Hara (e), Manager Committee
Att 30,598

Liverpool 2, Everton 1
October 1, 1958
Liverpool Floodlight Cup First Leg
Anfield
Referee; Mr. F.V. Stringer
Goals; Hickson (12), Arnell (21), Melia (1-2)
Teams
Liverpool (2-3-5); Younger; Molyneux, Moran; Wheeler, White, Saunders; Morris, Melia, Arnell, Harrower, Morrissey (j) (future Blue), Manager PH Taylor
Everton (2-3-5); O’Neill (j); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); King (j), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Penman (a), Harris (j), Hickson (d), Thomas (e), O’Hara (e), Manager Committee
Att 33,975

Everton 3, Birmingham City 1
October 4, 1958
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. AW Luty
Goals; Harris (j) (Assist Fielding), Hickson (55) (Assist B Harris), (61) (Assist J Harris), Murphy (60)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); O’Neill (j); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); King (j), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Fielding (w), Harris (j), Hickson (d), Collins (j), O’Hara (e), Manager Committee
Birmingham City (2-3-5); Merrick; Hall, Green; Watts, Sisson, Neal; Hellawell, Gordon, Brown, Murphy, Astall
Att 38,408

Everton 7, South Africa 4
October 8, 1958
Friendly Match
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. J. Mitchell
Goals; Collins (3), Hickson (19) (6-1) (80), O’Hara (   ), Jones (penalty 4-0), Salton (58), Harris (j) (5-1), Peterson (penalty 81), Rufus (83), Salton (88)
Teams
Everton 2-3-5); O’Neill (j) (Retired 34) (A Dunlop 42); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); King (j), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b)(Went in goal 11 mins); Penman (a), Harris (j), Hickson (d), Collins (r), O’Hara (e), manager Committee
South Africa (2-3-5); Gething; Martin, Denyssihen; Hauser, Peterson, Rufus; Hurley, Warren, Salton, Deetlings, Barratt
Att 13,331
Additional Penalty Deetling grassed by O’Hara

Tottenham Hotspur 10, Everton 4
October 11, 1958
League Division One
White Hart Lane
Referee; Mr. GW Pullen
Goals; Stokes (2)(34), Harris (j) (10) (assist Hickson) (52) (assist Fielding) (83) (Assist Hickson), Smith (14) (31) (62) (85), Robb (30), Medwin (43), Hamer (82), Collins (87) , Ryden (88)
Teams
Tottenham Hotspur (2-3-5); Hollowbread; Baker, Hopkins; Blanchflower, Ryden, Iley; Medwin, Harmer, Smith (captain), Stokes, Robb, Manager Bill Nicholson
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b), Fielding (w)(Last apps, sign for Southport), Harris (j), Hickson (d), Collins (j), O’Hara (e), Manager Committee
Att 37,794

Everton 3, Manchester United 2
October 18, 1958
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. PJ Smyth
Goals; Thomas (19) (Assist Bramwell) (37) (Assist J. Harris), Harris (j) (Assist Hickson), Cope (72) (82)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); King (j), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Ashworth (a), O’Hara (e), Manager Committee
Manchester United (2-3-5); Gregg; Foulkes, Greaves; Goodwin, Cope, McGuiness; Volett, Quixall, Charlton, Taylor, Scanlon, Manager Matt Busby
Att 64,074

Blackpool 1, Everton 1
October 25, 1958
League Division One
Bloomfield Road
Referee; Mr. JH Clough
Goals; O’Hara (74) (assist Thomas), Perry (87)
Teams
Blackpool (2-3-5); Farm; Armfield, Garrett; Kelly (j), Gratrix, Kelly (h); Matthews (s), Mudie, Snowden, Durie, Perry, Manager Ronnie Suart
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); King (j), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), O’Hara (e), manager John Carey (Denut)
Att 19,426

Everton 2, Liverpool 3 (Agg 3-5)
October 29, 1958
Liverpool Floodlight Cup Second Leg
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. J. MIcthell
Goals; Harrower (12), Thomas (31), Harris (j) (36), Bimpson (52), Melia (53)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Bbramwell (j); King (j), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), O’Hara (e), manager John Carey
Liverpool (2-3-5); Younger; Molyneux, Moran; Wheeler, White, Twentyman; Morris, Melia, Bimpson, Harrower, Morrissey (j) (future Blue), Manager PH Taylor
Att 41,610

Everton 2 Blackburn Rovers 2
November 1, 1958.
League Division One
Goodison Park Referee; Mr. HJ Husband
Goals Hickson (25) (assist B Harris), Douglas (55), Harris (j) (64) (Assist Thomas), Vernon (80)
Missed Penalty (78) TE Jones shot wide after Wood pulled down Hickson
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); King (j), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), O’Hara (e), Manager John Carey
Blackburn Rovers (2-3-5) Leyland (h) (ex-Blue); Taylor, Eckersley; Clayton, Woods (m) (ex-Blue), McGrath;  Douglas, Dobing, Johnston, Vernon (r) (future Blue), McLeod.
Att 52,833

Aston Villa 2, Everton 4
November 8, 1958
League Division One
Villa Park
Referee; Mr. AE Moore
Goals; Jones (Penalty 10) (Assist Hickson), (43 penalty) (Assist Hickson), Thomas (16) (J Harris), Sewell (69), McParland (71), O’Hara (84) (Assist O’Hara)
Teams
Aston Villa (2-3-5); Sims; Lynn, Sharples; Lee, Dugdale, Crowe; Smith, Hitchen, Myersclough, Sewell, McPrland.
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Parker (a) (Debut sign from Falkirk), Bramwell (j); King (j), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), O’Hara (e), Manager John Carey
Att 27,649
Additional; Penalty (1) – Hickson grassed by Sims; Penalty (2) – Lynn Punched Hickson header
Additional McParland was in goal for second penalty

Everton 2, West Ham United 2
November 15, 1958
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. Arthur Ellis
Goals; Dick (8), Thomas (22) (Assist Dunlop), Bond (penalty 43), Harris (J) (62) (Assist Hickson)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Parker (a), Bramwell (j); King (j), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (B); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), O’Hara (e), manager John Carey
West Ham United (2-3-5); Gregory; Bond, Cantwell; Malcolm, Brown, Nelson; Grice, Woosnam, Keebie, Dick (captain), Nusgroves, Manager Tom Fenton
Att 40,919
Additional- Penalty –Parker handled Grice goal bound shot

Nottingham Forest 2 Everton 1
November 22, 1958
League Division One
City Ground
Referee; Mr. LS Tirebuck
Goals; Collins (8) (Assist O’Hara), Dwlight (1-1), Barrett (49)
Teams
Notts Forest (2-3-5); Thomson; Whare, McDonald; Whitefoot, McKinlay, Burkitt; Dwlight, Bailey, Wilson, Barrett, Grey, Manager Billy Walker
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Parker (a), Bramwell (j); King (j), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), O’Hara (e), Manager John Carey
Att 26,280

Everton 3 Chelsea 1
November 29, 1958
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. WE Bradbury
Goals; Collins (38) (Assist B Harris), Tindall (62), Hickson (82) (Assist J Harris) (84) (Assist O’Hara)
Teams
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Parker (a), Bramwell (j); King (j), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), O’Hara (e), Manager John Carey
Chelsea (2-3-5); Matthews; Whittaker, Bellett; Huxford, Scott, Casey; Tindall, Brabrook, Gibbs, Greaves, Blunstone (captain), Manager Ted Drake
Att 30,638

Wolverhampton Wanderers 1 Everton 0
December 6, 1958
League Division One
Molineux
Referee; A Murdock
Goal; Broadbent (80)
Teams
Wolverhampton Wanderers (2-3-5); Finlayson; Stuart, Harris (g); Slater, Wright, Flowers; Deeley, Broadbent, Murray, Mason, Mullen, Manager Stanley Cullis
Everton (2-3-5) Dunlop (a); Parker (a), Bramwell (j); King (j), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j). Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), O’Hara (e), manager John Carey
Att 37,074

Army 0 Everton  1
December 8, 1958
Friendly Match
Centre Command Ground
Referee; Mr. ACM SW Pearce (RCME)
Goal; Collins (88)
Teams
Army (2-3-5); Titchie (G Rangers); Parker (a) (Everton), McTurk (St Mirren); Williams  (Plymouth), Plenderletch (Hibs), Petts (Arsenal); Plenderleith (Man City), Smith (West Ham), Hitchen (Aston Villa), Bainwell (Arsenal), Ewig (Patrick Thistle)
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Tansey (j); Meagan (m), Jones (je) (Captain), Bramwell (j); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), Harris (b), manager John Carey

Everton 2, Portsmouth 1
December 13,1958
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. H. Webb
Goals; Thomas (25) (Assist Williams) (35) (Assist Hickson), Harris (44)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); Meagan (m), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), Williams (g), Manager John Carey
Portsmouth (2-3-5) Uprichard; McGhee, Wilson; Dickinson , Hayward, Casey; Barnard, Newman, Saunders (r) (ex-Blue) (Captain), Harris, Cater
Booked Casey (Dissent)
Att 23,728

Everton 0, Leicester City 1
December 20, 1958.
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. JK Taylor
Goals; Hines (70)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); Parker (a), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), Williams (g), Manager John Carey
Leicester City (2-3-5); MacLaren; Cunningham, Ballie; Newman; King, Keyworth; Riley, Kelly, Hines, Walsh, Leek, Manager Dave Halliday
Att 27,703

Everton 1, Bolton Wanderers 0
December 26, 1958
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. A. Jobling
Goal; Hickson (40)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); Parker (a), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), Williams (g), Manager John Carey
Bolton Wanderers (2-3-5); Hopkinson; Hartle, Banks; Hannin, Higgins, Edwards; Birch, Hill, Lofthouse (captain), Parry, Holden. Manager Billy Riddle
Att 61,593

Bolton Wanderers 0 Everton 3
December 27, 1958
League Division One
Burden Park
Referee Arthur Ellis
Goals; Williams (35) (Assist Collins), Hickson (71) (Assist Collins), Harris (j) (Assist Hickson)
Teams
Bolton Wanderers (2-3-5) Hopkinson; Hartle, Banks; Hennin, Higgins, Edwards; Birch, Hill, Lifthouse (captain), Parry, Holden, manager Billy Ridding
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); Parker (a), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), Williams (g), Manager John Carey
Bookings; Banks (Foul)
Att 37,263

Newcastle United 4, Everton 0
January 3, 1959
League Division One
St. James’s Park Referee; G. McCabe
Goals; White (21) (32), Allchurch (31) (66)
Teams
Newcastle United (2-3-5); Harvey; Keith, McMicheal; Scoular, Stokoe, Franks; Hughes, Allchurch (i), White, McGrrigan, Eastham, Manager Charles Mitten
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); Parker (a), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), Williams (g), Manager John Carey
Att 42,400

Everton 4, Sunderland 0
January 10, 1959
F.A Cup Round Three
Goodison Park
Referee Arthur Ellis
Goals; Hickson (22) (Assist Williams) (27) (Assist Solo), Harris (j) (42)(Assist Hickson), Thomas (70) (Assist Collins)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); Parker (a), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), Williams (g), Manager John Carey
Sunderland (2-3-5); Wakeham; Nelson, Ashurst; Anderson (captain), Hurley, Pearce; Malty, Goodchild, Kirkenbrand, Taylor, Grainger, Manager Alan Brown
Att 58,778

Arsenal 3, Everton 1
January 17, 1959
League Division One
Highbury
Referee J. Barradell
Goals; Groves (11) (68), Bloomfield (31), Collins (74) (Assist Hickson)
Teams
Arsenal (2-3-5); Standen; Willis, Evans; Ward, Docherty; Bowen (captain), Clapton, Groves, Herd, Bloomfield, Henderson, Manager George Swindon
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); Parker (a), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Collins (r), Williams (g), manager John Carey
Att 39,474

Charlton Athletic 2 Everton 2
January 24, 1959
F.A Cup Round Fourth
The Valley
Referee Mr. JW Hunt
Goals; Sumer (19), Lawrie (57), Thomas (77) (Assist Hickson), Collins (86)
Teams
Charlton Athletic (2-3-5) Duff; Sewell, Townsend; Lucas, Jago, Kiernan; White, Hewie, Leary, Summers, Lawerie, Manager Jimmy Trotter
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); Parker (a), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j), Thomas (d), Collins (r), Williams (g)(Last apps, signed for Swansea), Manager John Carey
Sent Off (89) Willie Duff for punching Dave Hickson, John Lawrie went in goal. 
Att 44,094

Everton 4, Charlton Athletic 1 (AET)
January 28, 1959
F.A Cup Round Four Replay
Goodison Park
Referee JW Hunt
Goals; Hickson (41) (Assist J Harris) (110), Lawrie (88), Collins (97) (Assist J Harris) (119)
Missed Penalty (73) Sam Lawrie shot wide after Sanders grassed Hewie
Teams
Everton (2-3-5) Dunlop(a); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); Parker (a), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), O’Hara (e), Manager John Carey
Charlton Athletic (2-3-5); Duff; Sewell, Townsend; Lucas, Jago, Kiernan, White, Hewie, Leary, Summers, Lawrie, manager Jimmy Trotter
Att 74,482

Everton 3, Manchester City 1
January 31, 1959
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee S.H. Gerrard
Goals; Harris (j) (25), (Assist Solo), Hickson (56) (Assist J Harris), Jones (Penalty 75) (Assist J Harris), Barlow (86)
Missed Penalty (86), penalty saved after Sanders handled Sambrooks centre, Barlow scored from rebound
Teams
Everton (2-3-5) Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); Parker (a), Jones (te), Harris (b); Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), O’Hara (e), Manager John Carey
Manchester City (2-3-5); Trauntmann; Leivers, Horridge; Phoenix, Ewing, Barnes; Hannah, Johnstone, McAdams,. Barlow, Sambrook, manager Leslie McDowell
Att 43,360
Additional; Penalty J.Harris grassed by Horridge

Leeds United 1 Everton 0
February 7, 1959
League Division One
Ellan Road
Referee RM Jordan
Goal; Shackleton (8)
Teams
Leeds United (2-3-5); Burgin; Mitchell, Hair; Kerfoot, Charlton, Cush; Humphreuys, Crowe, Shackleton (a) (future Blue), Revie (captain), Overfield
Everton (2-3-5);  Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); Parker (a), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), O’Hara (e), Manager John Carey
Att 18,000

Everton 1, Aston Villa 4
February 14, 1959
F.A Cup Round Five
Goodison Park
Referee AW Luty
Goals; Wylie (9) (35) (63), McParland (40), Hickson (49) (Assist Hickson)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); Parker (a), Jones (te) (captain), Harris (b); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), O’Hara (e), Manager John Carey
Aston Villa (2-3-5); Sims; Aldis, Winton (Debut); Dixon, Dugdale, Crowe; Myerscough, Sewell, Hitchen, Wylie, McParland, Manager Joe Mercer (Ex-Blue)
Att 60,255

Everton 3, West Bromwich Albion 3
February 18, 1959
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. L. Howarth
Goals; Setter (26), Temple (34) (Assist Hickson), Kevan (59), Hickson (65) (Assist J Harris), Laverick (70) (Assist Collins), Allen (85)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a)(50th Lge apps), Bramwell (j); Parker (a), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Meagan (m), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Collins (r), Laverick (r) (Debut sign from Chelsea), Manager John Carey
West Bromwich Albion (2-3-5); Potter; Howe, Williams (s); Setter, Barlow, Brury; Griffin, Burnside, Kevan, Jackson, Allen, Manager Vic Buckingham
Att 32,629

Birmingham City 2, Everton 1
February 21, 1959
League Division One
St. Andrews
Referee RH Windle
Goals; Harris (j) (11) (Assist Hickson), Hopper (40), Larkin (53)
Teams
Birmingham City (2-3-5); Scholfield; Hall, Allen; Watts, Smith, Neal; Astall, Gordon, Butt, Larkin, Hooper
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Sanders (a), Bramwell (j); Parker (a), Labone (b), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Temple (d), Hickson (d), Collins (r) (captain), Laverick (r), Manager John Carey
Att 22,750

Everton 2, Tottenham Hotspur 1
February 28, 1959
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. R. Ryall
Goals; Collins (12) (Assist Thomas), Jones (34), Thomas(49) (Assist Laverick)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Parker (a), Bramwell (j); Harris (b), Jones (te)(captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), Laverick (r), Manager John Carey
Tottenham Hotspuur (2-3-5); Hollowbread; Baker, Hopkins; Blanchflower, Norman, Shaples (Last apps); Medwin, Harmer, Smith, Clayton, Jones, Manager Bill Nicholson
Att 36,782

Manchester United 2, Everton 1
March 7, 1959
League Division One
Old Trafford
Referee; Mr. FB Coultas
Goals; Goodwin (20), Coultas (63), Cope (Own goal 68) (Assist J Harris)
Missed Penalty (61) Tom Jones shot saved after Gregg collided with Jimmy Harris
Teams
Manchester United (2-3-5); Gregg; Greaves, Carolan; Goodwin, Cope, McGunness; Bradley, Quixall, Violett, Charlton, Scanlon, Manager Matt Busby
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Parker (a), Bramwell (j); Harris (b), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), Laverick (r), Manager John Carey
Att 51,044

Everton 3, Blackpool 1
March 14, 1959
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. DH Howell
Goals; Hickson (36) (Assist B Harris), Thomas (42) (Assist Collins), Charnley (51), Laverick (57) (Assist Hickson)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Parker (a), Bramwell (j); Harris (b), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m)(50th Lge apps); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), Laverick (r), Manager John Carey
Blackpool (2-3-5); Farm; Armfield (captain), Garrett; Hauser, Gratrix, Kelly (h), Paterson. Mudie, Kelly (j), Charnley, Durie
Att 34,562

Blackburn Rovers 2, Everton 1
March 21, 1959
League Division One
Ewood Park
Referee; Mr. Les Tirebuck
Goals; Harris (b) (21) (Assist Collins), Dobing (63)(Penalty 80)
Teams
Blackburn Rovers (2-3-5); Leyland (h) (ex-Blue); Taylor, Whelan;Clayton (Captain), Woods (m) (ex-Blue)(100 Lge apps), McGrath; Douglas, Cairn, Dobing, Vernon (r) (future Blue), Isherwood, Manager Dally Duncan
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a)(100 Lge apps); Parker (a), Bramwell (j); Rea (k), Jones(te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), Harris (b), Manager John Carey
Booking Bramwell (foul)
Sent off (88) Matt Woods fouling Dave Hickson
Att 26,900
Additional; Penalty Meagan grassed Ronnie Cairns

Luton Town 0, Everton 1
March 27, 1959
League Division One
Kenilworth Road
Referee TW Dawes
Goals; Baynham (own goal 89) (Assist Collins)
Teams
Luton Town (2-3-5); Baynham; McNally, Hawkes; Groves, Owen, Pacey; Bingham (w) (future Blues), Turner, Morton, Cummins (g) (ex-Blue), Gregory.
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Parker (a), Bramwell (j); Rea (k)(Last apps sign for Runcorn), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), Harris (b), Manager John Carey
Att 22,948

Everton 2, Aston Villa 1
March 28, 1959
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. ES Oxley
Goals; McParland (23), Hickson (44) (Assist Collins), Parker (Penalty 47) (Assist Hickson)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Parker (a), Bramwell (j); Harris (b), Labone (b), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r) (captain), Ashworth (a), Manager John Carey
Aston Vailla (2-3-5); Sims; Aldis, Winton; Dixon, Dugdale, Crowe; Smith, Sewell, Hitchins, Wylie, McParland, Manager Joe Mercer (ex-Blue).
Att 34,946
Additional Penalty –Dave Hickson sandwich

Everton 3, Luton Town 1
March 30 1959
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee Mr. Ken Howley
Gaols; Harris (j) (34) (Assist B Harris) (78) (Assist Hickson), Morton (48), Thomas (74) (Assist J Harris)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5) Dunlop (a); Parker (a), Bramwell (j); Harris (b), Labone (b), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r) (captain), Laverick (r), Manager John Carey
Luton Town (2-3-5) Collier; Dunne, Hawkes; Morton, Kelly, Groves; Whitley, Turner, Brown, Cummins (g) (ex-Blue), Gregory. 
Att 32,620

West ham United 3 Everton 2
April 4, 1959
League Division One
Upton Park
Referee; W Clements
Goals; Bond (25), Hickson (38) (assist J Harris). Dick (75), Grice (84), Laverick (86) (Assist J Harris)
Teams
West Ham United (2-3-5); Dwyer; Kirkup, Cantwell; Malcolm, Brown, Smith; Grice, Obeney, Bond, Dick (captain), Musgroves, Manager Tom Fenton
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Parker (a), Bramwell (j); Harris (b), Labone (b), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas(e), Hickson (d), Collins (r) (captain), Laverick (r), Manager John Carey
Att 28,500

Crystal Palace 2 Everton 2
April 6, 1959.
Friendly Match
Selhurst Park
Goals; McNichol (15), Parker (penalty 20), Colsar (1-2), Thomas (57)
Teams
Crystal Palace (2-3-5); Rouse; Howe, Noakes; McNichol, Chorley, Long; Priestley, Summersky, Barnett, Byrner, Colsar
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Parker (a), Bramwell (j); Harris (b), Jones (te) (captain), Rea (k); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Meagan (m), Laverick (r), Manager John Carey
Addition- Penalty –Thomas pushed in box

Everton 1 Nottingham Forest 3
April 11, 1959
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; CH Dennis
Goals; Wilson (6), Gray (19), Wilson (42), Hickson (89) (Assist Bramwell)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Parker (a), Bramwell (j); Harris (b), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); HHarris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Ashworth (a), Laverick (r), Manager John Carey
Nottingham Forest (2-3-5); Thomson; Whare, McDonald; Whitefoot, McKinlay, Burkitt; Dwight, Quigley, Wilson, Gray, Imlach, Manager Bill Walker
Booking Quigley (foul), Bramwell (foul), Hickson (foul)
Att 26,208

Portsmouth 2, Everton 3
April 15, 1959
League Division One
Fratton Park
Referee; RE Smith
Goals; Harris (h) (9) (65), Collins (35) (Assist Laverick), Thomas (66) (Assist Hickson), Laverick (77) (Assist Collins)
Teams
Portsmouth (2-3-5); Brown; Rutter, Wilson; Howells, Gunter, Dickinson; Harris (p), White (j), Saunders (r) (ex-Blue), Harris (h), Cutler
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Parker (a), Bramwell (j); Harris (b), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), Laverick (r), Manager John Carey
Att 12,714

Chelsea 3, Everton 1
April 18, 1959
League Division One
Stamford Bridge
Referee JW Hunt
Goals; Laverick (3) (Assist Thomas), Allen (62) (83), Greaves (Penalty 76)
Teams
Chelsea (2-3-5); Robertson; Shellito, Whittaker; Anderson, Mortimer, Crowther; Brabrook, Greaves (j), Allen, Blunestone, Harrison, manager Ted Drake
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Parker (a), Bramwell (j); Harris (b), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), Laverick (r), Manager John Carey
Bookings; Bramwell (foul), Collins (fighting), Blunstone (fighting)
Sent off (50); J Bramwell after a tackle on Blunstone
Att 24,366
Additional; Penalty Meagan grassed Jimmy Greaves

Everton 0 Wolverhampton Wanderers 1
April 25, 1959
League Division One
Goodison Park
Referee; Mr. NN Hough
Goal; Murray (60)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Parker (a), Bramwell (j); Harris (b), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Collins (r), Laverick (r) , Manager John Carey
Wolverhampton Wanderers (2-3-5); Finlayson; Stuart, Harris (g); Slater, Snowell, Flowers; Lill (m) (future Blue), Booth, Murray, Broadbent, Deeley
Att 29,414

Valencia 1 Everton 0
April 30 1959
Friendly Match
Goal-Not Known (Penalty)

Barcelona v Everton PP
May 1 1959
Friendly Match

Liverpool 1, Everton 0
May 5, 1959
Lancashire Senior Cup Final
Anfield
Referee; Mr. W Hickson
Goal; Liddell (34)
Teams
Liverpool (2-3-5); Younger; Molineux, Moran; Wheeler, White, Wilkinson; Morris, Melia, Liddell, Arnell, A’Court
Everton (2-3-5) Dunlop (a); Parker (a), Bramwell (j); Harris (b), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Harris (j), Thomas (e), Hickson (d), Wignall (f), Laverick (r), Manager John Carey
Att 22,198

Everton 8 Tranmere Rovers 5
May 11 ,1959
Liverpool Senior Cup
Anfield
Referee Mr. FV Stringer
Goals; Laverick (4) (7), Eglington (Penalty 26) (Penalty 84), Thomas (27) (48), Williamson (35) (36) (81), Wignall (39), Hickson (51) (54), Harris (j) (77)
Teams
Everton (2-3-5); Dunlop (a); Parker (a), Bramwell (j); Harris (b), Jones (te) (captain), Meagan (m); Thomas (e), Wignall (f), Harris (j), Hickson (d), Laverick (r), Manager John Carey
Tranmere Rovers (2-3-5); Payne; Bell, Frith; Farrell (p) (ex-Blue), Millington, Charlton;  Finney, Williams, Rowley, McDonald, Eglington (t) (ex-Blue), Player Manager Peter Farrell (ex-Blue)
Att 14,474
Additional- 1st penalty Farrell grassed in area