Everton Independent Research Data


Belfast Telegraph - Monday 02 November 1908
Willie Scott's popularity amongst the proud Evertonians was never more pronounced than it is at the present moment.  It is of a character unparalleled in the history of the Mersey Club, and probably not even excelled by Nick Ross and Johnnie Holt, two of the most popular Taffies who ever donned the Royal Blue for the great Liverpool club.  And Everton's proud position shows that it is all thoroughly deserved, too.

November 5, 1908. The Liverpool Daily Post and Mercury
The Lancashire Football association council have before it at Blackburn last night, the replies of the Everton, Liverpool, Manchester united, and Bury clubs to their demands for explanations of the weak teams played by the clubs in the Lancashire Senior cup-ties. After a long consideration, the council decided to accept the explanations of Bury and Liverpool. Everton were fined £25, and the Manchester United verdict was postponed for further inquiry.

Cricket and Football Field- Saturday 07 November 1908
By Richard Samuel.
Surely Everton on Saturday set the seal on their fame as champion “away” performers by winning at the Nottingham Forest ground, and thereby triumphing for the sixth match in succession on foreign soil this season. It is an achievement of which the men are reasonably proud, and as far as I have been able to make out, it is achievement with only a single parallel in League history of Division 1., either ancient or modern, for any one season. I have been at some pains this week in wading through the League records, and find that Preston North End in the League’s opening season 1888-9 won the championship without losing a match, yet never won more than thrice in succession away, nor the following season, when they again won the League. When Everton won the championship from Preston the following year, each club only totaled five "away" wins for the full eight months.
Preston’s Six Successive Away Wins.
The next season (1891-92) the League was for the first time enlarged, and it was therein that Everton’s present record was set for the first and only time prior to this year. Sunderland were a great side that winter, and won the Championship with a return of 42 points out of possible 52, and curiously enough, they did not play a single drawn game. But it was not Sunderland who achieved the great feat of winning six times off the reel on foreign territory, albeit they went precious near it, for between November 28th and March 19th they won five away games in succession, Notts County then spoiling the sequence winning I—0. Sunderland chipping in with two more away wins to close a great season. It was "Proud ’’ Preston who gained the six successive away wins medal, yet strange say, those six wins were Preston North End only away victories that season! They opened the campaign disastrously losing thrice away in September, and losing therein seven goals to nil.  In October their first away match was drawn, and then began their splendid sequence of wins opponents’ rounds, viz. October 24th v Blackburn Rovers, won 4—2; November v.’ Stoke, won 1—0; November 21st v. West Bromwich Albion, won 2-1; December 5th v. Derby County, won 2—l; January 1st v. Darwen, won 4—0; and January 2nd v. Accrington, won 3—l. Preston, as I have said, won no other "away" matches that season, and the most remarkable feature their record-run, to my mind, distinctly lies in the wonderful fact that the six clubs defeated and enumerated above filled absolutely the last six places on the League table at the close of that 1891-92 season! Such fact is significant, to say the least of it, and surely tends to take away from Preston little the usual glamour.
Everton’s Greater Performance.
With all due respect to the famous Ribble-siders, Everton’s run must be accounted a finer one seeing that League clubs are now much more a standard quality. As far I have been able to trace, the nearest approaches to a six successive “away” set of triumphs in one season stand opposite the names of Aston Villa and Liverpool. The Villa had a splendid season in 1896-7, when they won the League championship and defeated Everton in that great final for the Cup. I find that the Clarets wound up that champagne—l mean campaign—in irrepressible fashion, not only as cup fighters but also in the League. They actually closed their away programme reeling off five successive wins thus—February 6th, beat Bury 2—0; February 6th, beat Burnley 4—3; March 6th, beat Notts Forest 4—2: March 27th beat Bolton Wanderers 2—l; and April 26th, beat Preston North End I—0. And as the Villa's opening away match the following season was won 3 —2 v. Notts County, at Trent Bridge, they too, strictly speaking, can, like Everton and Preston, claim to have won six away games in succession, but not in the same season, however, Everton’s Skill. Taking Liverpool’s case, I find that in season 1898-99 the Reds, between December 24th and March 11th, decided seven away matches, five of which were won and two drawn—a very fine achievement although not “successive.” It was about this particular period, by the way, that the Beds achieved wonderful defensive set of performances in First League football by deciding seven successive matches (home ‘and away) without being debited with a single goal! But enough of the past. Let us to the present. Everton have delighted all and sundry with their skill in foreign parts. As home missioners, however, and they know—to our mutual regrets—that the Blues have more than once strayed. Despite this their fine work beyond Goodison has earned for the Everton men a rightful position at the head of the table, for this morning they held a clear (is that the right word?) two ‘points lead over their greatest rivals, thanks to Liverpool’s "good offices of a week ago, and Manchester United’s dire Wearside misfortunes. Everton’s position has been rightly won on merit alone. The Forest ground-there was doubting the fact that they were the better side—they played the better football, and the more finished football, whilst they stayed the course better than did the men in red.
Young’s Recovery.
It was only natural to look for a goal from Freeman, and hoodwinked the goalkeepers as usual. Indeed, Freeman came twice within ace of two further goals ere the end after tricking the defence, Maltby on one instance effecting a sensational race-back and clearance with Linacre otherwise well beaten. I must congratulate “Sandy” Young on a return to his best form. He was the cleverest forward on the field, and a much different man from the jaded-looking inside left the Villa match, when he was however, suffering through indisposition. The other forwards did their work well on the whole, as did the half hacks, whilst nothing could have been finer than the full back displays of Macconnachie and Bob Balmer. Scott, too, gave nothing away.

Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 07 November 1908

Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 07 November 1908

November 9, 1908. The Liverpool Courier.
Everton made no mistakes in their match with Sunderland at Goodison-park. They gained the day by the decisive margin of four goals to nil. This was more than their most ardent admirers anticipated. It was generally felt that the contest would be close and that whichever side, prevailed there would be "little in it," Having been regruited by one English and two Scottish internationals, the idea was that the Wearsiders would make Everton go all the way, even if they did not snatch a victory. Everton were of quite another way of thinking. They had fought their way to the proud position of League leaders, largely owing to their unrivailed record of six successive "away" victories, and they did not mean to thrown away any chances of success in the competition. Right worthily did they justify all the praise, which has been bestowed upon them. Once again they proved that they possess the finest set of forwards in the League, while Freeman added to his reputation of champion goal getter of the season by accomplished the "hat-trick." It was in occasion, pleasurable indeed, to all supporters of the good old Everton club. At the same time the game was more even than the score suggests. Everton thoroughly deserved their victory, especially on their exhibition in the second half, but Sunderland were worthy formen, and if the fates, had been kinder they would not have been beaten pointless.

It was during the earlier stages of the game when Sunderland had the benefit of a cross breeze, that they were seen to best advantage. As a matter of fact, despite the excellence of the Everton defence, they had two glorious chances of scoring when Hogg and Bridgett had no one to beat, but the goalkeeper. Bridgett was obviously disgusted with his failure, and as for Hogg, he was simply bewildered at the successful daring of Scott, who took the ball literally from his toes. Meanwhile the Everton forwards had been by no means inactive. To this the versatile L. R. Roose would be most willing to testify. Freeman, Young, and Sharp, and Taylor gave him plenty to do, and once after he had saved a terrific drive from marvellous Jack Taylor, Sandy Young feebly shot at the custodian instead of utilising a splendid opportunity of finding the net. It was only about five minutes before the interval when the first goal of the match arrived. Forster, Sunderland's left back, who had been playing a quiet but effective game, was accidentally injured, and had to be carried off the field. From the throw down, Sharp placed the ball nicely to Freeman, who promptly netted, quite out of the reach of even such a custodian as the Welsh international. How far Forster's absentee affected the situation is at matter of conjecture. However, he was on the field during the whole of the second half, and it was in this period that Everton filled the picture. Sharp paved the way for Coleman to score. After this a tremendous shot from Thomson rebounded from the upright, and this piece of bad luck seemed to dishearten the Sunderland men. On the other hand, the Everton forwards and halves indulged in some remarkably pretty, and effective play, which was a treat to witness. Thanks largely to sharp, another couple of goals fell to Freeman, and although the opponents never gave up, they could make no impression on Scott, the end coming with a splendid victory for the Blues by four goals to nothing.

The match produced as fine display of Association football you could wish to see. In view of the number of internationals on the field, this was what might have been expressed. The first half did not compare either in play and cleverness with the second half. For the Everton boys covered themselves with glory. In every position the visitors were gradually served. Scott had not so much work as L.R. Roose, but for all that, only a goalkeeper of his resource would have kept his charge intact. As for the amateur custodian, the shots, which beat him, were absolutely unstoppable. Balmer was the most effective back, although MaConnachie's coolness was a great service to his side. The half-back line was really brilliant, and it is pleasing to see that Harris seems to improve each game. Although Freeman credited himself with the hat-trick, Jack Sharp was the best of the forward line. His centres, were remarkably accurate, and it was no wonder that a centre of the capabilities of Freeman should have been so successful. Tim Coleman was in happy mood, and though Barlow and Young were not so prominent, it his old ability, as the pivot of the attack, the best of the forwards being Bridgett and Hogg. Teams: - Everton: - Scott, goal, R. Balmer, and MaConnachie, backs, Harris, Taylor, and Makepeace, half-backs, Sharp (Captain), Coleman, Freeman, Young, and Barlow, forwards. Sunderland: - Roose, goal, Agnew, and Forster, backs, Low, Thomson, and Jarvie, half-backs, Murdue, Hogg, Brown, Holley, and Bridgett, forwards. Referee J.T. Howcroft.

November 9, 1908. The Liverpool Courier.
Lancashire Combination Division One
Everton on Saturday sustained their first defeat since September 9. Carlisle United just getting home by the only goal of the game. On the run of the play Everton did not deserved to lose, but the Cumberland men presented a sound defence, particularly in the closing stages, when the visitors did a lot of pressing. Carlise's goal was scored in the first half, Stewart heading through after a shot from Campbell had been opened, and afterwards the home backs, and goalkeeper did so well that Everton could not get on level terms, though Lacey shot well. Everton: - Berry, goal, Stevenson, and Strettell, backs, Rafferty, Borthwick, and Adamson, half-backs, Buck, Lacey, Couper, Bolton, and Dawson, forwards.

Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 14 November 1908
Darwen were the visitors at Goodison Park, this afternoon.  There was a moderate attendance when Everton started.  Murray kicked a centre from Cox away to the Darwen forwards, and some exciting play was seen in front of the Darwen goal.  The home team forced a corner, but Woods sent behind.  Murray saved well from Smith at the other end.  Couper scored twice in quick succession, and Lacey put in a third goal a minute later.  Shortly afterwards, Couper obtained the fourth and Buck the fifth for Everton.  Murray saved well from Lacey and Couper finished a fine run with a weak pass, which McLaughlin intercepted and cleared.  Stephenson played very well, kicking the ball off a player’s toe on one occasion.  Rafferty was the best of the halves, whilst Couper was far and away the best forward on the field.  Derbyshire was hurt, Hollis falling back and taking his place, whilst Batey went half-back.  On the Darwen side Mockett played very well at half-back.  Interval; Everton Res 5, Darwen 0.
Final; Everton Reserve 7, Darwen 1.

(League.- First Division.)
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 14 November 1908
There was great interest taken in the visit of the victorious Everton team to Chelsea this afternoon, and the attendance must have reached nearly 35,000.  The weather was dull.  Teams;- Whitley, goal; Cameron, Right-back; and Miller, Left-back; Warren, Right half-back, Warren, Centre half-back and Humphreys, Centre half-back; Birnie, Left half-back; Brawn, Outside-right, Rouse, Inside-right, Hilsdon, Centre, Windridge, Inside-left, and Fairgrey, Outside-left.   Everton; Scott, goal; Balmer (R.), Right-back and Macconnachie, Left-back; Harris, Right half-back, Taylor, Centre half-back, and Makepeace Left half-back; Sharp (captain), Outside-right, Coleman, Inside-right, Freeman, Centre, Young, Inside-left and G.H. Barlow, Outside-left.  Referee; A.J. Barker, Stoke.  
An Early Goal
Everton won the toss.  Hilsdon commenced proceedings, and sent out to Brawn.  The long winger raced away and centred, Hilsdon scoring with a fine shot.  From the restart Everton went away, and Freeman tested Whitley with a very weak shot.  Sharp then was very prominent with a splendid run, beating Miller and working his way into goal, but Birnie robbed him just in time.  At the other end Hilsdon tried hard to head a beautiful centre of Brawn’s into goal, but just missed.  A fine pass from Taylor set Sharp going, and after beating Miller and Birnie he ended up with a brilliant centre which Freeman headed into goal, but Whitley saved.  A foul against Everton very nearly caused the downfall of their citadel, for the free kick was splendidly placed by Rouse, and with both Brawn and Hilsdon in close attendance Scott saved brilliantly.  The latter’s kick came out to Freeman, who at once made tracks for goal.  He passed out to Barlow, who returned it, Freeman then testing Whitley with a ground shot which, however, did not have much power behind it.  A tussle come off best, and passing to Hilsdon the centre forward shot wide of the post.  Chelsea came again, and Balmer miskicked, Scott only just happening to be in position to prevent the ball entering the net.  Some splendid combination was seen on the Chelsea left, the effort ending in a fine shot by Windridge.  Hilsdon then delighted the enormous crowd with one of his individual runs, beating all the defence, but he was hampered in the rear by Macconnachie, consequently hi shot, which was travelling at a terrific speed struck the outside net and lodged in between the iron stanchions.  The goal kick was obtained by Taylor, who set Sharp going with a well-timed pass.  The forward line came away in a line, Sharp and Freeman indulging in some pretty combination, Freeman concluding with a fine pass to Coleman, who dribbled right into goal and scored for Everton after about 40 minutes’ play.  This equalizer infused more spirit into the play, Sharp trying hard to get a lead with a shot.  Half-time; Chelsea 1, Everton 1.
More Goals
When the game was resumed the crowd was quite 45,000.  Freeman started, but Chelsea were the first to attack through Rouse, but Makepeace relived and gave to Sharp, who, serving the ball well into goal, Whitley rushed out to save, but Cameron headed the ball straight up.  It came down just in front of the goal to Freeman, who had nothing else to do but score.  From the restart Chelsea went away and Humphreys gave a fine pass to Hilsdon, who ran in and beat Balmer, finishing up with a shot that beat Scott all ends up.  Matters were again equal, but did not remain so long, for Freeman, after a fine individual effort, placed Everton ahead again with an unstoppable shot.  This was quick work-three goals in nine minutes.  But still they were to come, for during an attack by Chelsea one of the Everton defence handled amid great excitement, Mr. Barker awarded a penalty from which Hilsdon scored.  Warren was then responsible for robbing Barlow.  His pass set Brawn going, but Makepeace put out of touch.  Both ends were now playing a very safe game, Chelsea forced an abortive corner.  Scott saved splendidly a shot from Hilsdon.  The light now was very bad, and a draw fairly represented the play.  Final; Chelsea 3, Everton 3.

November 16, 1908. The Liverpool Courier.
Everton went to Chelsea on Saturday with an unbeaten record away from home. They drew at gate of 30,000 spectators, who witnessed one of the most sensational games ever played on the famous Stamford Bridge enclosure. The Lancashirians still charish their record; but they came precious near leaving it behind, and although the result of the game was a draw of three goals each. I must certainly award the Londoners the certificate of merit as being the best team. They could not claim much superiority, however, but there was undoubtedly more sting in their football, especially in the first half.

The game opened in a truly remarkable manner, for barely half a minute had elapsed when Chelsea had scored their first goal . Straight from Hilsdon's kick-off the ball was swung out to Brawn, who made a dash down the touchline, and sending his centre crashed against the upright and before the defence could clear Hilsdon scored, before the game had mean played for a minute and continued right up to the close, when both sides were struggling just as grimly for as winning goal. The exchanges always sparkled with brilliant movements, and incidents followed incident with regularity. Freeman was not as conspicuous as the Chelsea centre, but he came and he added to his fame by scoring two further goals. Chelsea did so much attacking in the first half that it is still a mystery to me now they failed to increase their lead before the interval. Balmer was none too safe, and seemed miskicking often in the Everton defence in a tangle, but somehow they managed to recover themselves and get the ball away. Only once did Chelsea appear to throw away a chance. Hilsdon had just failed to get his head to a centre from brawn, and the ball dropped at the feet of Windridge, who with only Scott facing him, shot yards wide. The Everton forwards had seldom been in the picture during the first half hour's play, but eight minutes later they started on a movement which not only protruded a goal, but served as a splendid tonic to them, for the remained of the game. Sharp slipped the ball onto Freeman, who worked through, but, being tackled, the transferred to Coleman, and the latter finished a characteristic fashion by scoring a great goal.

Everton had hardly deserved to be level with their opponents, but there was no mistaking their intentions when the second half was commenced. Their swarmed round the Chelsea goal at once, and Whitley made a glorious save from Barlow. Then followed a series of sensational incidents that almost baffle description, and three goals were scored in twice as many minutes. Everton were the successful team to obtain the first, but the goal was one of the many surprise incidents of the game. Whitley had come out of goal to meet a dangerous centre from Sharp, but Cameron got his head to the ball first, and it went straight to Freeman, who stood right under the crossbar thinking it go over, but to everyone surprise it dropped right in front of goal, so Freeman had only to touch the ball to score. From the kick off Windridge dribbled through, and passing at the exact moment to Hilsdon, saw that drive beat Scott with a splendid shot. Away went Everton again, and Freeman taking a pass from Taylor, was tackled three times. He managed to recover the ball each time, however, and eventually found an opening to score with a cross shot. The excitement ran high after this, and in a fierce attack on the Everton goal, one of the defenders handled the ball in the penalty area. Hilsdon took the penalty kick , and with a beautiful low shot he brought the scores level again. The remaining play was desperate fought out, but both sides failed to press home any advantage, so the game was left drawn as stated.

The football at times reached a high standard and if Everton were somewhat disappointing in the first half they made up for it with then brilliance in the later stages of the game. Scott gave a splendid display between the posts, and in a plain straight forward way, saved many threatening situations. The Everton backs were unsteady in the start, no doubt Chelsea early goal unnerved them –and Balmer made several blunders, which might have pressed fatal, and he has to thank the sterling efforts of Harris for a lot of his recoveries. MaConnachie was much safer in his methods. He kept a cool head under pressure, tackled resolutely, and kicked with great accuracy on a greasy surface. All the Everton half-back did well, and they played most untirely throughout. It was hot until the latter stages of the game that they were of much assistance to their forwards, there mostly occupied in looking after Hilsdon and Co, but once they settled down and saw distinct cleverness line- Harris and Makepeace, and find vigour in Taylor. The left wing of the visitors were the most movement, especially in the second half. Barlow them held the ball more to himself and he generally worked into advantage for his side. Young made some neat passes, but he did not get many opportunities in front of goal. Freeman still adopts, the same brisk methods, that characterised his play when a member of the Arsenal team, but he has improved immensely with his juggling with the ball, and I should say he is now one of the cleverest forwards in the League. Coleman played a rather erratic sort of game, and his feeding to Sharp left room for improvement. He is still the same deadly player in front of goal, however, Sharp did many smart things, but he found the close attentions of Birnie rather troublesome at times. Taken all round it was a bright display played by clever performers, and watched by thousands of keen critical people. Teams: - Chelsea: - Whitley, goal, Cameron, and Miller, backs. warren Humphreys, and Birnie, half-backs, Brawn, Rouse, Hildson, Windridge, and Fairgrey, forwards. Everton: - Scott, goals, R. Balmer, and McConnachie, backs, Harris, Taylor, and Makepeace, half-backs, Sharp (Captain), Coleman Freeman, Young, and Barlow, forwards. Referee A.J. Barker.

November 16, 1908. The Liverpool Courier.
Lancashire Combination Division One
Everton defeated Darwen at Goodison-Park on Saturday by seven goals to one. As the score indicates it was quite a one-sided affair, and it was only through a mistake by the home backs that the visitors scored. Couper was early in evidence, and scored two goals in the first few minutes. Lacey was responsible for the third goal, Couper the fourth, and Buck the fifth, which completed the scoring up to breathing time. After the interval, Smith scored for Darwen, and Lacey and Buck added further goals, for the Blues. Both fore and after the home side displayed excellence understanding, and the forwards never missed an opportunity to shoot. Independent of his hat track, Couper played a magnificent game in the centre, and his accurate marksmanship was quite a feature of the match. Lacey and Buck were also prominent, while in the defence Adamson was conspicuous for clever tackling and judicious feeding. Although beaten seven times Murray the visitors custodian did well, saving shots innumerable in a cool and clever manner. Everton: - Berry, goal, Stevenson, and Strettell, backs, Rafferty, Borthwick, and Adamson, half-backs, Buck, lacey, Couper, Bolton, and Woods, forwards .

Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 21 November 1908
Olympian’s Corner.
If any league club has reason to be thankful for the penalty kick surely it is the Chelsea F.C.  It pulled them through on the occasion of the recent visit to the home of the champions, and it served them in their engagement with Everton on Saturday afternoon.  Hilsdon, who is said to be anything but enraptured with this drastic rule, was the scoring artist in each case.  The feeling in the great city on the Mersey is well reflected in the following short outburst, which reached me early in the week;-
Liverpool, 16/11/08.- Dear Sir, -Talking about “Penalties,” what do think of the one awarded to Chelsea against Everton last Saturday?  Hard lines, is it not (on Everton) to have their record spoiled by such a decision?  Still, it is all over now.  Wishing every success to your popular paper, which will always be read by yours respectively, LIVERPOOL, FIELDITE.
This penalty given against Everton by Mr. Barker fairly roused the ire of the visitors, and it will go down amongst the many that have been sharply criticized in the matter of justice.  The great crowd were kept in a high state of excitement right through an interesting contest, and well they might be seeing that as many as half a dozen goals were netted, three being crowded into the short space of eight or nine minutes at one stage.  How the goals were registered will be gathered from the following;-
First Goal for Chelsea by Hilsdon
Second Goal for Everton by Coleman
Third Goal for Everton by Freeman
Fourth Goal for Chelsea by Hilsdon
Fifth Goal for Everton by Freeman
Sixth Goal for Chelsea by Hilsdon.
It was when defeat threatened to befall the pensioners, time rapidly slipping away, that the penalty incident occurred, and a rare lively time it was.  It was variously described by the southern critics, several of whom admitted that there was a strong element of doubt about the affair.  My Everton readers will be interested in appended selections;-
There was an extraordinary scene when the ball was knocked down one of the Everton defenders. Both teams rushed after the referee. And that official was actually chased all over the ground by 22 players, who looked, as if they wanted to tear him to pieces. It reminded me of nothing so much as a "weisher" being chased on Epson Downs on Derby Day. The Everton players led by Sharp, indignantly protested against the granting of a penalty kick by the referee.  Mr. Barker was surrounded with an unseemly demonstration by the visiting players, the majority of whom no doubt were sincere in their belief that only Scott had handled the ball from Fairgray’s centre, but the referee was quite right in his decision, even though a big proportion of the huge crowd did not see what happened I distinctly saw Harris strike the ball with his arm before Scott got possession of it.  Possibly the Irishman had no winful intent, but his action was so apparently deliberate that the referee was fully justified in his decision.  I believe it is Everton's intention to report Mr. Barker upon the penalty decision, but there were F.A. Councillors present who agree with me that his ruling was perfectly sound.  In a sustained attack by the Chelsea forwards right in front of their opponents' goal, someone deliberately handled the ball as it was apparently going into the net.  The referee whistled, and pointed to the penalty kick mark.  He was immediately surrounded by the Everton players, who emphasized their protests by shaking and pulling at the official's coat as he dodged here and there to escape their attentions. The crowd watched these maneuvers with breathless interest and only when the referee erect and resolute, stood apart from the mass of players with his right foot meaningly placed on the penalty kick mark, did the cheering ring out again.  Then Hilsdon, stepped out to take the kick, and a silence that could be felt came over all as he stopped and placed the ball to his liking, the while Scott, the Everton goalkeeper, faced him watchfully.  The next second saw him drive it into the right-hand corner of the goal, at an irresistible velocity which left Scott blinking and which sent the crowd into a delirium of delight. 
It will be noticed that all the three writers of the quotations I have given agree that the ball was knocked down, but only one says it was an act of deliberation.  If Mr. Barker held the same view he had no option but to put the penalty law into force.  Here is his explanation after all was over;-
The ball came across from the left.  Harris was well in the penalty area, not far from the goal, and he deliberately handled the ball, Scott rushed out to clear the centre, and actually did so, but not until after Harris had handled.  That is what took place under my very nose, and I was bound to give a penalty.  Scott was evidently under the impression that I had mistaken him for another player, but I had not, because he was not in any way concerned in the penalty.
Had Hilsdon failed with his shot it is not easy to imagine what would have happened.  It is only fair to say that Chelsea had two goals disallowed for technical offences.  Whilst dealing with penalty kicks it is worthwhile to note that one saved Newcastle United from defeat at Bramell-lane-and against Ernest Needham, of all men in the world!- and that another gave the Rovers their only goal against Manchester United, Glossop having a like experience at Blackpool. 

Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 21 November 1908
By Richard Samuel
Everton’s opportunity to build up an absolute best on record set triumphs of triumphs on foreign soil was destroyed on Saturday at Chelsea in a manner not thoroughly satisfactory to the friends of the Blues.  But, amid the general disappointment, there was at least one consoling feature, aye, two: Everton succeeded in retaining their unbeaten visiting ticket, whilst they surely demonstrated their greatness by the way in which they fought a tremendous uphill battle: They had to begin climbing after less than 30 seconds’ play.  Then, when the crest of the hill had been reached and the Goodison Pedipulators had even begun to free wheel— having taken the lead-came that debatable penalty infliction, which by the way, seems to have been in everybody s mouth locally this week. Was it, or was it not, a penalty?  The Everton players to an man emphatic that it wasn’t; likewise some of those who, holding impartial views, critically watched the match.  The referee, however, said it was a Penalty —and, as you know a referee against a side is more than all who can be for a side.
A Double Injustice to "Ireland".
It was in the second stage, when Everton were leading 3-2, that Chelsea put in a big effort to equalize, and it was during this period of pressure  upon the visiting goal that Scott rushed out into a crowd of struggling players to hand the ball clear. Instanter the referee (and referees are but human after all, despite what some of them imagine!) signalled a penalty with the result that the whole Everton team-even the imperturbable MacConnaehie joining in-formed themselves into a sort of readymade court appeal. No “All Black", ever tackled his men more strenuously than those eleven "All Blues” tackled Mr. Barker.  "It was I alone’ declared Scott, "who did the job," whereas Mr. Referee was inexorable and voted for Harris, with the result that Hilsdon equalised the scores. This was nothing less than double injustice to young Ireland, if Everton's emphatic and unanimous declaration re their non - breaking of the penalty rule is true—and their sincerity I, of course, have no reason to doubt.  Here was Harris, one of Everton’s two Irishmen, wrongfully saddled—so he and so all Everton assert-with illegally understudying Scott, whilst his fellow countryman was subsequently saddled with a goal, when the ball should have been lengths away in some other part of the field –a double injustice to “Young” Ireland, I repeat.
Penalty Prominence.
By the way, is not Stamford Bridge becoming somewhat notorious in connection with penalty kicks?  You will all recall (Boltonians doubly so!) how in April last Notts County were saved from drowning at Chelsea when about to sink for the third and last time, through the aid of a penalty kick, which will ever remain warmly talked about, and I suppose debated upon by those whom it most concerned –Bolton Wanderers, to wit.  In this case Whitley, the Chelsea custodian, was mulcted in a penalty that took the shape of a lifebuoy, which Dodds, the Notts left winger (all credit to his presence of mind), managed to clutch.  This I do know –as knowing the man – that Mr. McQueen, the referee that day ruled according as his eyes, judgment, and conscience dictated, and doubtless as Referee Barker is now just as emphatic that it was a penalty and nothing but a penalty on Saturday.  But it would have been a gracious act on his part of this Hanley official, and an act in no wise undignified had he, in deference to the unanimous appeals and the protracted appeals of the whole Everton team, consulted his linesmen –which he didn’t.  Apart from the foregoing considerations I hold the view (I may be wrong, however) that to consult one’s linesmen in circumstances of this kind strengthens rather than weakens a referee’s ruling (when confirmed, of course), just as on the Bench when the assisting Judges concur; whereas, if the linesmen disagree, does not this go to show the referee (backed up as said disagreement is with the players’ protests) that a mistake has been made?
How Should a Goalkeeper Be Clothed?
This case of Barker v. Scott or Harris, I think, calls for some further legislation on the subject of a goalkeeper’s outfit.  Scott, as we all know, is garded a wee bit differently from his fellows in that his sleeves have a dark ring around them.  But I would like to see goalkeepers still more distinctly attired than is at present sometimes the case.  It would help referees and prove a capital cure for heartburn.  Of the match itself at Chelsea it was worthy the occasion, being simply “great” throughout.  As the scoring indicates, the forwards (given rare half-back assistance) were a trifle more than the defenders could manage.  On all counts perhaps a draw was an equitable finding, yet I cannot be charged with partiality when I say that the side which scores within half a minute of the start and gets another goal from a tremendously disputed penalty is a trifle lucky.  Everton are to be complimented for bringing back a point from such a hotbed of roses (to Chelsea!) They strove valiantly and cleverly to veer the wind-round, and it was surely galling that just when they had succeeded, a momentary untoward gust should have gone to assist Chelsea’s craft to cross the line level and claim a dead-heat.
In Brief, &c.
Where all did so well, and with my Everton space already exhausted, I can only indulge the lads in an all-round compliment.  Scott effected many champion saves, particularly in the closing stages; he made one save too many, however, Everton assert –this in the case of the penalty infringement, Balmer was the best back on the field, and that was because Rouse and Brawn denied Macconnachie such a distinguishing mark.  At half-back Val Harris gave another sterling display.  Taylor was Makepeace was always up to concert pitch.  It goes without saying that Freeman scored; twice he did the trick-in the one other shining individually.  Coleman’s goal was a beauty, and he showed that Freeman was not the only Everton artist capable of drawing goalkeepers.  Young and Barlow put in a capital afternoon’s work; but the most solidly dangerous Everton forward was Jack Sharp, who worked with power and telling effect.  Sharp is having a great season.

Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 21 November 1908

(Lancashire Combination.- Division 1.)
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 21 November 1908
Played at Blackburn, before a good gate. The Rovers played Kirby, their latest acquisition from Atherton.  The opening was sensational, Aitkenhead scoring in the first minute.  The visitors retaliated, and when things looked dangerous the Rovers’ left full-back intervened.  After Kirby had distinguished himself, Bracegirdle put in a lovely centre, but no one was ready to meet it.  The Rovers pressed to the interval.  Half-time; Rovers 1, Everton 0.
On the resumption the visitors were the first to exert pressure, Griffiths returning.  The visitors continued to press, but Lacey shot over.  The Rovers returned, but Bracegirdle was given offside.  Still keeping up the attack, Crompton was all but through when he slipped at the critical moment.  From a capital centre by Kirby, Aitkenhead put the Rovers two ahead, and in the next minute Hindle had to run out to clear his charge.  Final; Blackburn Rovers Reserve 2, Everton Reserve 2.

Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 21 November 1908
To-day’s meeting between Everton and Blackburn rovers, at Goodison Park, was rendered more than usually interesting because of the position of the one club as League leaders, and of the other sharing with Everton an unbeaten “away" certificate.  Both clubs were fully represented and paraded the same teams as for three weeks past; Everton, of course, having out what may be termed their "invincible" eleven.  Much interest centred in the appearance of such stalwarts as Crompton and Ashcroft whilst Chapman—son of a former Liverpool trainer —would doubtless be a much scanned youth, who was now called upon to check if possible, Freeman’s scoring propensities The teams lined thus:—Everton; Scott, goal; Balmer (R.), Right-back and Macconnachie, Left-back; Harris, Right half-back, Taylor, Centre half-back and Makepeace, Left half-back; Sharp (Captain), Outside-right, Coleman, Inside-right, Freeman, Centre, Young, Inside-left and G.H. Barlow, Outside-left.  Blackburnburn Rovers;- Ashcroft, goal; Crompton, Right-back, and Suttle, Left-back; Houlker, Right half-back, Chapman, Centre half-back, and Bradshaw, Left half-back; Garbutt, Outside-right, Latheron, Inside-right, Davies, Centre, Kylie, Inside-left, and Anthony, Outside-left.  Referee; Mr. J. Mason, Burslem.
Home Forwards In Deadly Earnest
The weather was mild and though distinctly dull, the rain kept off, as it has done every Saturday afternoon throughout the season.  The early start is detrimental to attendances in Liverpool, but there would doubtless be close upon 20,000 present when the game opened, Freeman having set the ball rolling.  By the way, there was an eleventh hour change in the Blackburn team, the veteran Houlker making his first League team appearance of the season on a once famous hunting ground, Ferguson being an absentee.  The Rovers endeavoured to force an attack on the right wing, but Makepeace's capital tackling came in handy.  The Blues were awarded a free-kick on the half-way line, but this was cleared by Suttie with a capital overhead kick. Then a clever passing movement between Young and Barlow roused the crowd's enthusiasm, until Chapman nicked in. The ball went into touch, and from the throw in Freeman darted between the visiting backs, and with glorious cross-shot lowered the visitors' colours, the ball flying into the net at a great pace, and leaving Ashcroft helpless, game was less than "Three Minutes Old" when this goal accrued. The Rovers responded with a dash on the right, but Makepeace and Macconnachie responded tellingly. Again were Everton witnessed in dashing and clever mood, and following splendid aggressive tactics Freeman and his left wing the ball across the face of the Rovers' goal some 12 yards out. Here Sharp came on the scene to try a shot, but the ball cannoned at right angles off a visiting defender to Coleman, who happened to be splendidly placed. The ex-Gunner made no mistake and emulated his former club mate Freeman by scoring Everton's second goal with a tremendous ground shot which Ashcroft could only look at regretfully. The game was thus only seven minutes old when Everton had gained an apparently easy winning position. Everton were simply all over the East Lancastrians, and after skillful footwork Young brought Ashcroft full length in dealing with a terrific shot. At the other end Scott dealt in masterly fashion with a splendid long shot from Kyle. Balmer, Taylor and Harris all excelled in defence. But Everton as a whole were simply walking into the weak spots in the visitors armour, and here Sharp came on the scene with a couple of smart runs. From the second of these he centred the ball finely right off the goal-line, which time Suttie was hanging on to his heels. The ball went right across the face of the Rovers’ goal, where Crompton and Coleman were in close attendance; the ball travelled beyond Coleman to Crompton, who, to his intense disgust, banged the ball into his own net, Everton thereby leading by three clear goals after quarter of an hour’s play. Crompton, by the way, appears partial to scoring against his own side in this way -the result doubtless of trying “impossible" shots. Surely the sensational had been crowded in today's first 15 minutes play, and the late comers were given food for comment and reflection when they heard the news -the attendance would now number fully 22,000. There was one disquieting feature, however, from an Everton standpoint—the light was already wretchedly poor, and there was more than a suspicion of mist in evidence.  The Rovers here showed a bold front.  Scott being more than requisitioned as the result of smart forward tactics. MaConnachie once saved a scorching shot by Latheron, who a little later, banged the ball high over the Everton crossbar when favourably placed.  Coleman was at this point just about the cleverest forward on the field, his footwork being pulse-stirring, and his passes the acme of perfection.  His "getting" of the ball to Sharp from all manner of positions was really delightful. "Tim ’’ here fully deserved a goal, as he neatly tricked two opponents, and then fired in accurately, but Coleman happened to bar the way.  After a stoppage through injury to Makepeace, the Rovers nearly rushed a goal per Kyle, directly following the restart, Scott being unable to cope with the situation but fortunately his comrades—jealous of Scott s citadel —succeeded in keeping the enemy at bay, thanks to a little dash of luck thrown in. Just before the interval Young made another brilliant scoring attempt, but Ashcroft was not to be beaten. Sharp a little later just missed the ball when favorably placed, while just before the whistle went Scott executed a splendid save from Kyle, who was the Rovers' best marksman. Everton were easily the better side during the first half. Their early big lead was pleasing indeed, yet it tended to take out the match something of that excitement which is always coupled with uncertainty. Everton were much too good, but in the last twenty minutes a good deal scrambling play was witnessed. Interval; Everton 3, Rovers 0.
A Rousing Second Half.
The players were hurried out into service again after a bare five minutes' rest. The Rovers restarted with spirit, and from a centre by Anthony Davies was rather unfortunate in failing to get the ball past Scott, a hot shot being accidently deflected wide of the goal-post. Young clearing from the corner. However, with the second stage only advanced some five minutes zest was added the proceedings in the shape a well-deserved goal to the Blackburn side. Davies, who throughout the game had been a prominent forager, raced right down the centre, and then when in close proximity to Scott he banged the ball home. This stirred both Everton and their opponents. The Rovers were again distinctly dangerous, but Everton having stalled off this attack, soon regained the three goals lead. Their clever Makepeace defeated Anthony and then served to Young, who made a fine run and then passed square to Coleman. Who took up the story. Ashcroft was drawn, and Coleman drove the ball into the net, Everton thus leading by four goals to one. Everton now kept up a scorching attack, in which that wizard of the game, Sandy Young, was a tremendous force for good. Barlow, who had not been a success previously, was now doing better. Even Crompton could make little of Young. Everton were trying desperately for further goals, Sharp ending one bombardment by shooting over the bar, whilst Taylor plied Ashcroft with a rasping shot. Then a brilliant right wing and centre movement culminated in Coleman again netting, but the goal was disallowed, Tim having infringed the offside rule by a foot or so. Anthony was twice noticeable for the Rovers, but on the whole they were well kept in hand. With 25 minutes remaining for play the ball was only with difficulty followed from the Press-box. Anthony was much the most effective forward in the Rovers’ ranks hereabouts, and some of his work deserved better reward than was bestowed upon it by his inside forwards. However, with 22 minutes go, Garbutt centred from the other wing, and Davies slipped the ball into the net, Scott failing after advancing to intercept Garbutt’s centre. Then almost directly from the re-start Davies went right through, Scott rushed out some distance as a last resource. But the little Rover unerringly shot the ball into the haven, thereby bringing the score 4-3 in sensational fashion, at the time completing the hat trick. Thus the issue was made wonderfully open, and the spectators were once again pitched into the throes of excitement.  Whether the visitors would have scored as they did in a better light is neither here nor there, certain is they were fighting tooth and nail to save their away unbeaten certificate. The defenders were sorely harassed, especially Anthony, whilst Crompton was repeatedly heard shouting instructions his men. Ten minutes from the end the Rovers executed a dashing attack on the right, and the ball being centred Davies added to his laurels the scores, which was a caution. The Everton defence was undoubtedly weak this portion. Still the Rovers were worthy of every' praise for making such a valiant fight, was worthy of the club’s best cup-tie fighting traditions. The closing stages were excitedly fought out, but the Rovers held their own, to effect a sensational division of the points, and the same time retained their clean slate on foreign soil. The Everton side suffered a serious relapse in the second stage. They are evidently not twilight team. Final; Everton 4, Blackburn Rovers 4.

November 23, 1908. The Liverpool Courier.
We had quite a thrilling game at Goodison Park on Saturday –one to be long remembered by all who witnessed it. If only one could have foreseen what actually happened, there would of a certainly have been an even larger "gate" satisfactory though it was seeing that the attendance must have been somewhere near 25,000. Only rarely does a side pull a game out of the fire in the manner of Blackburn Rovers' performance against Everton. The game ended in a division of the honours, with four goals each. At the interval probably not one in a thousand of the spectators ever dreamt of such a result. Everton secured a three goal lead in the first quarter of an hour, and this on ordinary occasion is quite sufficient to ensure victory. Certainly on their form during the opening half the chances of Blackburn Rovers appealed gloomy indeed. But what a change came over the scene after the teams crossed over. Davies quickly scored, then Coleman added another for Everton, and all seemed over. This, however, was not the Rovers' ideas, for playing up with a dash and pluck, which were worthy of the highest praise, they bothered the home defence so greatly that Davies was responsible for three other goals. It was an eye-opener for Everton supporters, but the crowd, to their credit be it said, waxed enthusiastic over the exhibition of the Rovers, who came pretty near winning the game after twice being three goals in arrears.

But to consider the play in rather more detail. Everton commenced in irresistible fashion. Even before the home right wing had played the ball, Freeman found Crompton hesitating, and credited himself with his nineteenth goal of the season. Young's cleverness was really responsible for the point, and a few minutes later that player enabled Sharp to put in a grand shot, which Crompton deflected to Coleman, who had no difficulty in netting. This was a great beginning and the whole side were playing so well that the Rovers looked quite outclassed. A quarter of an hour from the start, a third goal arrived, the redoubtable Crompton this time turning a centre from Sharp into the net. After this the Evertonians took matters easily, but for all that Scott was rarely troubled. With three goals against them no one imagined that the Rovers, had any prospect of preventing their undefeated away record being besmirched. However, it was soon evident that they had made up their minds to do or die. Straight away, Davies worked his way through and cleverly scored his first goal, but when Coleman, mainly through Young's brilliant work, put on a fourth, it was though that all was over for the Rovers. Then it was that the visiting side roused themselves, after the manner of football heroes. Anthony delighted with some beautiful sprints, which were too much for the Everton defenders, Davies was ever on the alert, and taking a pass from Garbutt, he scored his second goal, completing the hat-trick a few minutes later, by a fine individual effort. Even then he was not satisfied, for he claimed a fourth. Were Everton after going to lose? There were moments when this seemed not out of the question, but happily the Blues roused themselves, and Ashcroft cleared a splendidly from Sharp. The end, however, was four goals each.

No more brilliant forward and half-back work could be desired than that shown by Everton in the earlier stages, of the contest. Young was a artist, he was Sandy in his happiest vein, and we all know what a brainy player he is. Well, he was simply delightful. Sharp and Coleman were also rare form, and it was hard lines on "Tim" that he was deprived on the "hat-trick" for which he worked so hard. Neither Freeman nor Barlow was up to concert pitch. The Halves did not last as well as usual, but there is this to be said for them, that both Harris and Makepeace sustained injuries. When the Rovers were making those dangerous rushes, they failed to hold them at bay, and during this period Balmer and MaConnachie were at fault, the latter especially being singularly ineffective. Scott, as far as could be seem in the bad light, could not be blamed for either of the goals put up against him. The Rovers were quite a difficult lot in the second half. Earlier their forwards were inept to a degree, and the awakening later was quite a revelation. Anthony played a sparkling game at outside left, but the remarkable success was Davies, who will have pleasant memories of the fixture, seeing that he scored all the goals for his side. Crompton was by no means the Crompton, that we know, for the most part he found more than his match in Young. However, he improved as the game progressed, and his stimulating influence had doubtless something to do with the Rovers partial success. While congratulating the Rovers upon their splendid uphill fight, Everton with a four-one lead half an from the finish never to have lost their hold over the game. Teams: - Everton: - Scott, goal, R. Balmer, and McConnachie, backs, Harris, Taylor, and Makepeace, half-backs, Sharp (Captain), Coleman Freeman, Young, and Barlow, forwards. Blackburn Rovers: - Ashcroft, goals, Crompton, and Suttle, backs, Houlker, Chapman and Bradshaw, half-backs, Garbutt, Latheron, Davies, Kylie, and Anthony, forwards. Referee J. Mason.

November 23, 1908. The Liverpool Courier.
Lancashire Combination Division One (Game 11)
Everton found Blackburn Rovers very keen opponents at Ewood-Park, but managed to share the points by reason of a draw of two goals each. The Rovers started well, Aitkenhead opening the scoring in the first minute, while soon after the change of ends the same player added a second goal. Then, however, Everton set to work, and Jones and Dawson scoring, the honours were divided. The Everton forwards took a long time to settled down, and has they started as well as they finished they might have carried off both points. Everton: - Berry, goal, Stevenson, and Strettell, backs, Rafferty, Borthwick, and Adamson, half-backs, Buck, Lacey, Jones Bolton, and Dawson, forwards.

November 24, 1908. The Liverpool Courier.
Lancashire Senior Cup Semi-Final.
Our great local clubs, Everton and Liverpool, were drawn together in the semi-final of the Lancashire Cup Competition yesterday. The officials of the two clubs tossed for choice of grounds. The Everton secretary was successful, and the game was played at Goodison-park yesterday afternoon. The result was that Liverpool qualified for the final by two goals to nil. On the run of the play there was to other ending possible than a triumph for the Anfield-road organisation. But, after all, there was nothing to boast about in a full Liverpool League team, with two exceptions, vanquishing what was really an Everton reserve eleven. No doubt Everton, in their sensational game with Blackburn Rovers, had a quite unusual number of players more or less crippled. Therese were accidents which could not be helped, and nobody could have been more disappointed than the Everton directors themselve by the fact that they were only in a position to play three members of the team which figured against the Rovers. This in itself robbed the match of whatever interest it might otherwise have presented, for at all tomes local rivalry is aroused when our two local teams are seen in opposition at full strength. Such was not the case yesterday, and therefore, as has already been indicated, the fixture did not command the attention which otherwise would have been the case. The game itself calls for little in the nature of serious comment. Liverpool made their position secure in the first half of the game. During this period they gave an exhibition of delightful football, that is when an opposition is not too tertile or re-sourceful. Goode, the reserve inside right of Liverpool scored a couple of fine goals, besides accomplishing a lot of really clever work. After the chance of ends, the Everton shaped more creditably, but there was never any real danger of the "Reds" losing their lead, which they kept to the finish without much trouble. As for the players, Goodie was one of the most conspicuous men on the field, apart from his goal scoring capabilities, while Harrop played a great game at centre half-back, Settle was over-weighted by Cox, who, however, rarely drove his advantage home, and the best man in the half-back line of the losing side was Adamson. Young and Coleman gave occasional glimpses of their real form, but taken all round the Everton attack was only occasionally deadly. Berry shaped well in goal, and could not be held responsible for either point, which counted. Teams : - Everton: - Berry goal, Strettell, and R. balmer, backs, Rafferty, Borthwick, and Adamson, half-backs, Buck, Coleman Jones Young, and Dawson, forwards. Liverpool: - Hardy, gaol Chorlton, and Dunlop, backs, Parry, Harrop, and Bradley half-backs, Goddard, Goode, Parkinson, Hewitt and Cox, forwards. Referee Mr. T. Campbell. The attendance was 8,000, and the gate receipts about £250.

November 30, 1908. The Liverpool Courier.
Everton had they baptism so far as First League football in Bradford is concerned on Saturday. It was their eight away fixture of the season, and the satisfactory feature of the visit to the Yorkshire City is that Everton still possess their unbeaten record away from home. True, they did not win, but they succeeded in accomplishing the next best thing –dividing the points. On the general run of the play the leaders, it must be admitted were lucky in escaping defeat. They met a team who plays a different class of football, and who, as possessors of the wooden spoon, are becoming really desperate in their quest of points. Now men are being secured in the effort to improve the club's position and, judging by the second half of Saturday's game, the management are being loyally supported by the players. Certainly after appearing quite a beaten side in the earlier portion of the match, the Bradford boys were a vastly different lot afterwards. They entered into their work, with wholehearted enthusiasm, and no wonder the Everton defence was upset by the do or die rushes of the home attack. Scott, in goal bore himself bravely, as he has oftentimes before now, and it was in no small measure due to his thoroughness and excellent judgement that Everton can still boast of a remarkable record in away fixtures –six wins, and two draws, or 14 out of a possible 16 points.

Contrary to expectation Everton placed in the field their recognised League eleven. A week's rest had worked wonders with the injured players, at the same time it was evident as the game progressed that more than one of their number had not completely recovered. Their opponents had two recruits in their ranks. One of them was the ex-amateur Lintott of Queen's Park Rangers, and the other was a young sturdily built back, Torrance who was quite new to First League football, in which he promises to make a name for himself. The meeting of the top and bottom clubs attracted a big typical Yorkshire crowd, who were anxious to see the local record to much-desired victory, been though it meant breaking Everton's proud record. With the wind behind them, Everton were always masters of the situation. Although not approximating the form of which we know them capable, they were obviously cleverer than their opponents, who, forwards in particular, were woefully weak. Only once, however, did Everton penetrate the Bradford City defence. It was during a creditable movement on the part of the front line that the success arrived. The ball was sent well up towards goal, and Freeman was becoming so dangerous, that Torrance could not avoid kicking it against the Everton pivot, who promptly had it in the net with Spendiff hopelessly beaten. Though it appeared a lucky point, it was really well deserved, if only on account of Freeman's judicious seizure of an opportunity. Scott had practically nothing to do, and beyond one great effort by Coleman his vis-à-vis also was not tested to any extent. After the change of ends, Bradford's display was an eye-opener. Lethargy gave way to wonderful energy. There was nothing pretty about their football, but dash and grim determination compensated for want of class. Their bustling tactics quire put Everton off their game. It was a beautiful goal, too, which they scored, just such another as West obtained at meeting the ball with his head directed it into the far corner of the net. After this, except for brief intervals during which Taylor narrowly missed there was only one side in it, and that was not Everton. Scott performed prodigies of valour. More than once he seemed certain to be beaten, but somehow or other be managed to keep his charge intact. Right to the end Everton's record was in danger of being besmirched, and it was a relief to those supporters of the club who had made the journey to Bradford to hear the whistle blown for the final.

As already indicated Everton were seen by no means at their best. To some extent doubtless they were hampered by the narrow ground. The fact remains that they only occasionally gave glimpse of their real form. Even when they were quite the superior side there was a lack of that cohesion which they have been showing lately. Freeman had few chances of breaking through, and neither of the inside men was as affective as usual. Sharp was not at all happy, indeed he found a tough customer to tackle in Hanger. As for Barlow, he brought off several clever bits of work, but generally his play could not be regarded as much above a mediocre description. Of the backs, Makepeace was by far the most promising. Taylor did his best work in the first half, and Harris was evidently feeling the effects of last week's injury. Balmer and MaConnachie performed creditably considering the pressure to which they were subjected, but the outstanding man on the ties as a custodian, the Bradford spectators must have great respect. Lintott, although appearing in the centre half position played a fine game, especially in the second half. Torrance has already been mentioned. The side can exhibit the same determination as characterised their later efforts many League teams will not take even one point from Valley Parade. Teams: - Bradford City: - Spendiff goal, Torrance, and Farrer, backs, Robinson, Lintott, and Hanger, half-backs Barlett, Whittaker, O'Rourke, Logan, and West forwards. Everton: - Scott goal, R. Balmer, and McConnachie, backs, Harris, Taylor, and Makepeace, half-backs Sharp (Captain), Coleman Freeman, Young, and Barlow, forwards. Referee J.W.Bailey.

Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 28 November 1908
By Richard Samuel
Home patrons of the Everton-Blackbnrn Rovers’ match were delighted with what they “saw.” Later in the game, however, they were by no means pleased at what the almost vanished light permitted them to merely glimpse at. If ever a game seemed won and lost it was When Everton led 3—0 after 15 minutes play, and again led 4-1 three-quarters of an hour later.  Then it was that the Rovers were encouraged with a second goal to go on and show those wonderful fighting qualities which made the names of the blue and white quarters so famous in the eighties. I think full credit, must be given our East Lancashire friends for so gallantly pulling the match out of the fire. It is all very well to say that Everton should never have allowed them to draw or that the Rovers were lucky to divide the points.  As a matter of fact rather fancy Everton were glad when the end came as it did. Let us look at the picture this way. Had Everton been at Ewood Park and found themselves 4—l in arrears with half an hour to play, and had they then succeeded like Blackburn in pulling level 4—4, should we not all have written this down as a brilliant performance? Then, I repeat, let us give the Rovers a hearty hand clasp for pulling up so magnificently. It can be said for Saturday’s crowd that they did so in the main. The Rovers were given round after round of applause at the close. Such results as that of a week ago are the very essences of the game, its pulsating life’s blood, so to speak. Of course, it is galling to us all to think that Everton should lose such a golden opportunity to strengthen their leadership position on the very day that Newcastle United were failing at home There is also no doubt about it, too, that the Everton defenders were as a as a whole caught napping, through an inclination to take matters too easily at the time when the side appeared to have their opponents in the hollow of their hand. And there is little doubt but that the Everton middlemen paid far too much attention to attack and too little to defence when they saw. Those emboldened Rovers taking the most direct route for Scott’s dwelling, place. Further Comments.
During the first half Everton’s behavionr had been glorious, but their casing off subsequently was had policy. Of course, there was some little excuse for their later decline, as Freeman was never himself following a heavy collision with Crompton, whilst Val Harris was in the wars consequent upon receiving an accidental kick over the eye by Anthony, I think. Nothing could have excelled the brilliant forward play of Coleman and Young, however, during the time that Everton held the lead.  Coleman’s deflections to Sharp were thrillingly done and wondrously accurate, whilst Young played one of his most masterful games—at times even a little bit too much so. Freeman’s two-minutes’-goal put us on the tip-toe of expectation, but afterwards Chapman and Crompton were in the main his masters. Captain Sharp did much fine work in the opening half: afterwards his opportunities to excel were rare. The three half backs distinctly cut their work into two halves—the first excellent and the other moderate. Taylor seemed unhappy after the interval, whilst Harris was naturally scarcely himself, and even Makepeace found more than he could manage in marking Anthony. Further in the rear “Bobbie” Balmer was no more successful in taking the Rovers’ left winger into custody, whilst Macconnachie’s display reminded one of what his former day failures as a half back were, although his case one hears that the cool Scotsman had been unwell. He certainly looked ill (at ease), to say ‘the least. Scott’s position was an unenviable one. For those Rovers’ forwards —and Davies in particular—l have nothing but praise. Chapman is a centre half who would adorn any team, and I wonder how it is that this local developed player escaped Mr. Tom Watson’s spectacles. Crompton is great back still, -and one charitably disposed, witness his goal for Everton. He has a promising helpmate in the fair-headed Suttie.
Monday’s Lancashire Cup semi-final ’twixt Reds and Blues proved somewhat tame and disappointing affair, for the simple reason that the two sides were unequally matched. Several of the Everton leaguers were “knocked up” in consequence of the Rovers’ Saturday rushes, whilst Scott was the victim of severe cold and Balmer at business. The presence of such as Sharp and Makepeace, however, would have gone some way towards making the match more interesting, and Everton’s spectators had undoubtedly reason to grumble at the poor fare served up from home point view. As a matter of fact the Everton side only included three of Saturday’s League team, and had it not been for the passages-at-legs between Young and Parry the event would have been absolutely devoid of incident so far as Everton’s partisans were concerned. Liverpool, on the other hand, played at practically full League strength, the only changes being Goode for Robinson at inside right and Dunlop vice Saul. Liverpool won 2 —0, both goals being admirably obtained by Goode prior to the interval. Goode’s general footwork and his marksmanship in particular won the highest praise; and a repetition of such form would surely entitle him to unchallenged position in the Reds’ League team. He fully deserved to complete the hat trick, and was practically the only" first class shootist on view; I shall disappointed if he doesn’t do well in the, League team. Played well; ditto Chorlton, whilst Dunlop delighted his friends.  For Everton Strettle, Rafferty, Borthwick, Buck and Jones were each disappointing.  Liverpool have done extremely well throughout the competition, and I hope to find them eventually successful in winning the handsome vase.
Looking Ahead.
Sheffield Wednesday’s fine form is a certain "guarantee for a great match and a big crowd at Goodison Park seven days hence, for the Blades, as a downright honest team of genuine triers, rather than a mixed set of star artists and semi-dullards, are ever popular here. Besides are they not recalled as Everton’s victors at the Palace two seasons ago?  But additional interest is lent to their pending visit in that it has been set aside for the joint benefit of Messrs. Harry Makepeace and Robert Balmer, two of the most unassuming and respected members of Everton’s league team; also two of the most capable.  As Balmer is a born and bred local, and as Makepeace is one in all things save that of birth, the success of their dual benefit should appeal all the more heartily to local admirers. It is something to their “benefit” undoubtedly that Everton and Sheffield Wednesday should be located at the head of the table, and they deserve bumper, especially as neither man has cost the Everton club penny piece in the shape a transfer fee. The careers of both are too well known to require another description here. Both, however, may he said, are extremely youthful beneficiaires, so that there is not the slightest reason why with average luck they should not qualify for a second benefit. As a matter of fact neither man made his League debut for Everton until the latter half of season 1902-3 was reached. R. Balmer’s one appearance that season was, curiously enough, made against Makepeace native town’s club, Middlesbro’, January 22nd at Goodison Park, Williamson, the Tees-side goalkeeper, making his League debut the same day. Makepeace’s first season match was v. Manchester United, February 21st, 1903, at Goodison, in the second round of the English Cup competition, Harry operating at inside left in Settle s absence. His League debut followed a week later v. Bury also at inside left. He also assisted the senior team that season at centre forward and left half back. The full list of the two players’ League team appearances to date is follows : Balmer; 1902-3 1; 1903-4 3; 1904-5 10; 1905-6 20; 1906-7 25; 1907-8 26; 1908-9 (todate) 14. Total 99.  Makepeace; 1902-3 3; 1903-4 0; 1904-5 20; 1905-6 27; 1906-7 23; 1907-8 31; 1908-09 (to-date) 13, Total 117
Both men are this season absolutely right at their very best, and I join with countless others in wishing them well. 

Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 28 November 1908

(League –First Division.)
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 28 November 1908
This match was played at valley parade, in the presence of 20,000 spectators.  Lintott, the International half from Queen’s Park rangers made his debut for the City.  Teams;- Bradford City;- Spendiff, goal; Torrace, Right-back and Farren, Left-half-back; Robinson, Right-half-back, Robinson, Centre half-back, and O’Rourke, Left half-back; Lintott, Outside-right, Bartlett, Inside-right, Whittaker, Outside-right, Smith, Centre, Logan, Inside-left, and Gould, Outside-left.  Everton; Scott, goal; Balmer (R.), right-back and Macconnachie, Left-back; Harris, Right half-back, Taylor, Centre half-back, and Makepeace Left half-back; Sharp (captain), Outside-right, Coleman, Inside-right, Freeman, Centre, Young, Inside-left, and G.H. Barlow, Outside-left.  Referee; Mr. J. W. Bailey, Leicester.
First Goal For The Visitors.
Everton won the toss, and O’Rourke started against the breeze, Logan and Gould going on nicely, but being held by Balmer.  Again the City attacked, and Logan gave Whittaker a pretty opening, but the inside right was not ripe for it, nor was Bartlett able to do anything with another opening.  Meanwhile a quick rally by Everton enabled Freeman to shoot, but the centre man’s aim was poor.  Again the visitors attacked, but a corner saved the situation, when Young was playing dangerously.  The champions-elect continued to have the better of the operations, but the Bradford defence sufficed, with some luck.  Young was particularly vital, and a shot by him whirled a little over the bar.  Several times the City broke away, and began to show some improvement.  Farren was injured temporarily in coping with Sharp.  The City were aggressive nevertheless, but had no definite method.  Coleman played solo effectively, and upon the vantage he gained Freeman stole through the home backs with a low swift shot.  Spendiff was not prepared for this, and the City were a goal down after 20 minutes’ play.  It was with difficulty that Freeman was frustrated a minute later, and from a centre by Barlow he had yet a third shot.  Effective service by the visitors’ halves kept the play in a menace to the City for a considerable time, but the home backs bustled among the opposing forwards in capital style, and stayed off danger, although with difficulty.  The City again showed slight improvement, and in one instance assumed a likely attitude, but they could not elaborate any really effective resistance.  The visitors played to Sharp repeatedly, but he was well watched, and a packed goal defied more varied effort.  An exciting incident was a swift run by Freeman, who got through, but Spendiff realizing that pluck was required, ran out and saved in the nick of time.  Bartlett was prominent in the City attack but as before he found more than his match in Macconnachie.  When time was nearing the interval there was to be noted the fact that not once in the game, so far, had Scott been tested.  There were one or two endeavours to score, but these were very poor.  On the other hand, Everton found tough back play opposed to their every endeavor, the home halves being driven back so often that their policy was chiefly safety-play.  Close on half-time the City were rather ominous occasionally but were well met, Scott coming out once or twice to seek work.  Interval; Everton one, Bradford City nil.
City Pull Up.
Almost with the restart the City showed sting, and after a neat centre by Bartlett there was a shot from Logan which called upon Scott to save smartly.  O’Rourke made a poor exhibition when he should have scored close up, but after four minutes there was a see-saw attack by the City which culminated in a cross-kick by Bartlett, and a magnificent header into the net despite a desperate lunge by Scott.  The equalizer roused the crowd to a madness of enthusiasm.  The City were full of fire, and Scott had to save.  At the other end Spendiff was also tested.  So imminent was danger in one case that Scott in fisting out conceded a corner, while the goal was luckily saved twice afterwards.  The excitement was intense.  Still, the City had the better of the exchanges, but were too eager, and faults arose on this account.  Everton had an exceedingly warm time, Scott being bombarded amid thunders of applause.
Final; Bradford City 1, Everton 1.

(Lancashire Combination.- Division 1.)
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 28 November 1908
Carlisle won the toss, but Buck sent in a shot which cannoned outside off Mackenzie.  Everton had White and Clifford, and also McKay, a Scottish junior.  Soon after the start Strettle headed a fast shot into his own net.  The Carlisle defence was very sound.  Laburn stopped several hot shots in fine fashion.  White was injured and left the field.  Some exciting play was witnessed in the Carlisle goalmouth.  White returned, and immediately afterwards Mountford almost beat Laburn, his shot just going wide.  Everton attacked strongly, but their efforts were futile.  Clifford was playing well for the home team at centre half.  Play was in midfield chiefly at this point of the game.  On the Carlisle side the better of the two backs was Carter, whilst Foster played well at left-back.  White and Mountford on the left wing did good work for Everton.  Carlisle were generally in Everton’s half of the field.  Half-time; Carlisle United 1, Everton Reserves 0.  Resuming, White sent in a shot which MacKenzie charged down.  The Carlisle men were very tricky on the ball, but their shooting was their weak point.  Everton were awarded a penalty, from which Mountford equalized with a shot that Laburn had no chance to save.  Some good play was seen, and Kirkman was hurt by the ball hitting him in the face.  The Everton forwards could not get past the visitors’ defence.  White headed a cente from Mountford just over the bar after Laburn had fisted out.  Buck made a good attempt to score, the ball missing by inches.  Laburn saved well from White.  Just on three-quarter time Banchop gave Carlisle the lead.  Final; Everton Reserve 1, Carlisle United 2.

November 30, 1908. The Liverpool Courier.
Lancashire Combination Divison One (Game 12)
Despite the inclusion of White and Clifford, the ex-Bolton Wanderers, Everton were defeated at Goodison-Park by two goals to one. The game had hardly been in progress five minutes when Strettell had the misfortune to head the ball through his own goal. This completed the scoring in the first half. After the change of ends Everton equalised by the aid of a penalty kick, which did Mountford safely negotiate. Nearing the end the visitors secured the lead through Beauchope, who scored from a very doubtful position. Carlisle have a first-class custodian in Laburn, and he was well covered by a clever pair of backs in Mackenzie and Carter. Beauchorpe was the most conspicuous in the attack, and he was well supported by Sanderson and Spencer. On the Everton side White most filled the eye, and several times he had hard lines in not scoring. Adamson and Clifford were prominent in the defence, and Berry could not be blamed for his side defeat. Lacey gave his lamest display of the season, and McCage tish debutante was not a success. Everton: - Berry goal, Stevenson, and Strettell, backs, Rafferty, Clifford and Adamson, half-backs, Lacey, White, Jones Mountford, and McCage, forwards.





November 1908