| Everton v Rotherham United Goalscorers and Results (League Cup) | |||||
| No | Season | Ground | Score | Everton Scorers | Rotherdam United Scoerers |
| 1 | 1987-88 | Goodison Park | 3-2 | Snodin, Wilson, Clarke (Pen) | Scott, Pepper |
| 2 | 1987-88 | Millmoor | 0-0 | ||
| 3 | 1992-93 | Millmoor | 0-1 | Goater | |
| 4 | 1992-93 | Goodison Park | 3-0 | Rideout (2), Cottee (Pen) | |
| 5 | 2018-19 | Goodison Park | 3-1 | Sigurdsson, Calvert-Lewin (2) | Vaulkes |
| 6 | |||||