THE BOOTLE COMMISSION
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 07 January 1888
The examination of Izzatt and Weir, so far as I can glean, furnished matter for further investigation, and it is tolerably certain that the fate of Bootle hinges upon the credibility of the two Scotsmen, who left them under circumstances already detailed in this column and which demands that their evidence should be received with the utmost caution. Izatt and Weir were both chosen to play for Bootle against Workington in the first round of the English Cup ties; by no hint was the Bootle Committee apprised of their intention to go over to Everton; on the day for the Cup tie both players failed to put in an appearance, whilst on the same day Izatt accompanied Everton to Bolton in their ill-dated tie with the Wanderers. Now the action of these players is capable of only one of two possible explanations; they were either susceptible of some wrong from the Bootle Committee, or they were acting in a purely malicious spirit against the club of their adoption. In either case their evidence against Bootle should be substantiated very convincingly before acceptance, a fast rendered the more necessary because in the minds of a large section of Everton supporters there exists a firm conviction that Bootle were really responsible for the suspension of the Anfield –road club. This idea, I may say, is not entertained by the official members of the club, who look upon their suspension as the result of the misfortune of being the first club to come under inquisition for veiled professionalism, coupled with treachery from within.
THE CLOSE OF THE HOLIDAY MATCHES
The close of the festive season heralds the new birth of Everton, who will today resume operations, and let us hope, take a new lease of life in-exampled in prosperity in the history of Association Clubs. There is no club in England with such a bright future; the club with a more numerous or more enthusiastic following; what is necessary is a careful pilot with boldness, tact, and discretion and above all a loyal support from all sections of the club. Misfortunes have indeed accumulated upon the Everton lads, whose luck was proverbial in the past. The attempt to bring off the holiday fixtures by proxy has been a financial failure, and has made clear that the doings of strangers even at Anfield-rd are regarded with indifference. The game between Stanley and Ulster on Boxing Day was comparatively successful, but those between Stanley and Northwich and Northwich and Cowlairs fell very flat indeed, and if, as stated in the Field last week, Cowlars were to receive 30 pounds, it is certain they would carry off far more than the actual takings at the gate.
THE BATTLES OF THE INVADERS AT EVERTON
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 07 January 1888
By Mickey Free
BATTLE NO.1
Stanley and Northwich Victoria brought off their friendly bout last Saturday, although grave doubts were entertained at the beginning as to whether the light would last long enough to permit the contestants to have a fair spin from both ends as there was a nasty thick fog settling down on the field which prevented the possibility of recognizing a player on the opposite side. But towards the close the fog lifted and a well contested game was played out. The Victorians were the first to come to the front, and it was a wonder that the crossbar was not shivered by the first shot from Goulding. The Cheshire men passed much better than Stanley, and six minutes from the start saw them chalking up their first notch. The game does not call for much description, it was seldom exciting and ended in a close finish.
BATTLE NO 2.
Better things were hoped for on the Bank Holiday. Ah, well, it might have bene otherwise had the weather been anything approaching what was devoutly wished for; but alas it was simply dreadful, and it was a puzzle to me to understand how some 1,500 spectators could muster courage to leave comfortable quarters to witness a match under such conditions. The Everton ground having a slight slope generally looks well even when other grounds are like a quagmire, but on this occasion it was really dreadful. Large pools of water and mud galore covered the young crop of grass. Cowlairs started uphill and Fallowes was soon required to kick and fist out with all his might. Strainger and Hickson made a brave effort to get away but a long return by McLoughlin caused matters to resume what became a normal state of affairs, that is, the fight in the Northwich half. Scott just shot wide and from a free kick the Scotsmen scored a great goal. Reynolds landing a second in followed by a third and Hickson and shortly before the interval Scott added a fourth point by a lofty shot. It now became more clear than ever that it was only a question of the number of goals by which the Cowlairs men would win. They passed well, seldom missed a chance and took a kindly to the mud larking as if it were no uncommon occurrence whereas the Northwich men never shone and the beating of nine just about represents the state of the case, McLeod at back was as cool as usual, McPherson the old Everton half-back, was loudly cheered on presenting himself and he showed that he has not lost any of that cleverness which made him such a favourite last season. The forwards seemed a good lot but I would like to see them play again. There were a goodly number of friends of the Scotsmen on tour with the team, and the manner in which they disported themselves created much amusement. After each goal a small party matched round the ground blowing trumpets and bearing small drums, whilst another yelled themselves hoarse from one corner of the grand stand. Under ordinary circumstances the row kicked up would have been a nuisance, but on this occasion, everything being so damp and miserable, I declare solemnly that the horseplay and discordaus sounds were a regular relief.
AT LAST
Oh, that month! Upon my conscience I never remember anything like it. It seemed like a whole season. Well, sir, it is at an end at last and the blue and white will be seen once again on Saturday, and with a fine day won’t there just be a gathering to welcome, not only our own lads, but Notts Forest, who will make their debut at Everton on Saturday.
NUGGETS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 07 January 18
Association Game January 7 th 1888. The Liverpool Courier.
The Patrons of the Anfield enclosure had for their delectation on Saturday the Stanley v Northwich Victoria fixture, but so miserably cold and dull was the weather that the crowd was of smaller dimension Everton being unable to fulfil their engagement with Cowlairs, owing to their term of suspension not being expired arranged with Northwich Victoria to meet the Scotch visitors at Anfield on Monday afternoon. Unfortunately the fixture was favored with anything but pleasant weather, but notwithstanding this some two thousands people lined the enclosure and it is worthy of mention that McPherson (late of Everton) received acordial reception when he made his appearance upon the field.
Everton v Notts Rangers.
January 9 th 1888. The Liverpool Courier.
The Everton ground on Saturday presented something like its wanted appearance. Long before the contest commenced there were quite 5,000 spectators present. The ground was very greasy, and in front of the lower goal it was very bad indeed. The weather was fine, and on the visitors presenting themselves they received a very cordial greeting. Shortly afterwards four of the Evertonians appeared, and received a real hearty cheer. There was an awkward interval after this, clearly showing that the effects of the suspension had not been got rid of. At length, after twenty minutes' waiting the game was began, Everton playing only ten men, but what a team it was! The game calls for very little in way of criticisms although Notts Rangers only won by three to one, the chief merit of the low score against the home team rests with Smalley, who defended the charge in excellent style. Everton lost the toss, and Gibson, who had to go centre forward, kicked off. Notts at once pressed Gandy shot in, Smalley hit out, a corner followed, but Hodder kicked wide. Dobson was forced to concede another corner; this unproductive and then Jones stopped a dangerous rush by Shaw. Hodder, and Partington, and aided by a couple of free kicks, Everton at length broke through the blockage which had been established. This relief was of short duration, and Smalley had to punt clear, but a centre from the right, and Gandy by a screw from the left defeated him for the first time. The eleventh man, Welsh, now joined the home team, and the play became somewhat more lively, and at the expiration of half an hour's play Gibson, receiving the ball from Douglas, scored the only goal for his side. Half time arrived with the score one each. After crossing over, Notts kicked off and Everton ought to have done better, as they had the benefit of the breeze, but it was clear that the majority of the men were entirely out of condition, and therefore unequal to the back of improving the opportunity. Fayer put in some good work, but Dobson was all abroad and missing his kick, Shaw caused a second downfall of the Everton colours. A.N. Other and Farmer then made many attempts to break through, but being well attended to, they failed whilst from the neat run down Cook scored a beauty. This player soon after tested Smalley severely, but he cleared, as he did soon after from a beauty by Hodder. Hands off Dobson close to goal caused more trouble, but again Smalley did the needful and time came at length with Everton beaten as above. Teams; - Rangers; - Dawson, goal; Edwards and Carlin, backs; Shelton, Palmer and Archey, half-backs; Candy, Partington, Hodder, Shaw and Cooke forwards. Everton; - Smalley, goal; Dobson (captain) and Fayer, backs; Jones, Welsh and Cartwright, half-backs; an Other, Farmer, Gibson, Evans, and Douglas forwards.
NOTT RANGER V. EVERTON
January 9, 1888. The Liverpool Mercury Everton recommenced play, after their month's suspension, on Saturday, on the Anfield ground, in the presence of about 4,000 spectators. The visitors were the first to appear on the ground, followed shortly afterwards by the home captain and six others, the spectators being kept in suspense as to the other four. Eventually another two turned up, and the game was commenced with nine men. Gibson kicked off for Everton, and soon Hodder was at the home goal, which was only saved at the expense of a corner. Continuing the pressure, the Rangers had hard luck in giving hands just a Smalley's charge was threatened. From the free kick, Hodder again got possession, and rushing up the field, had a flying shot, which just went over. From the goal kick, the visitors again became aggressive, Jones putting in some nice work to save. At length pressure was eased, and Farmer was just robbed of a nice chance by Carlin. At the other end Gandy had hard luck, in not scoring, Smalley just saving in time. At this juncture the home team was completed by two substitutes turning up. Everton now showed up better, Framer putting in some dodgy play, but still they could not pass the Rangers' backs. The home goal was now visited, and Smalley had a hard task in saving through Dobson heading the wrong way. At last the visitors were rewarded with a goal, which was scored by Shaw. From the kick-off, Notts again assumed command, but were spoiled by Welsh, who passed the ball to Farmer, the latter player missing a nice chance through dallying. Hodder had another shot as Smalley's charge, and then off-side, by Cooke getting too near in, eased the pressure, Farmer now run the ball down the field and passed it to A.N. Other, who muddled. Shortly afterwards hands were given to Everton, and Gibson succeeded in equalising. Continuing to press, Farmer came with a rush and passed to Douglas, who fell just as he was about to shoot for goal. Nothing daunted, Gibson made it very warm for Dawson who kept his charge in grand style. Then the Rangers looked dangerous, but could not augment their score, half-time arriving with the game one goal each. On resuming the visitors were soon at the Everton goal, and Shaw scored goal 2 for the Rangers. Kicking off, Everton warmed to their work to equalise, but the inferior play of three substitutes enabled Cooke to added a third goal. Smalley soon had another handful, and then A.N. Other took a flying run, but Shaw easily pulled him up. Hodder paid a further visit to Smalley, and then Farmer took possession, the visitors' goalkeeper saving at the expense of a corner. Shaw and Hodder also had shots, and a very unexciting game ended in the defeat of Everton by 3 goals to 1. Teams- Everton; Smalley, goal; Dobson and Fair, backs; Jones, Cartwright, and Welsh, half-backs; A.N. Other, Farmer, Gibson, Evans, and Douglas, forwards. Notts Rangers; Dawson, goal; Carlin and Edwards, backs; Archer, and Shelton, half-backs; Cooke, Shaw, Hodder, Partington, and Gandy, forwards.
Notes
Everton made a bad impression on resuming play, and the disastrous effects of their suspension, presented as they were in all their nakedness, were aggravated by ill-luck, not to say schism. It is not going beyond the mark to say the team on Saturday was the worst seen at Anfield in a first-class match. Bad as the eleven was, it was incomplete until Welsh filled up the gap, ten minutes after the start. Of the eligibles, Fleming could not assist through business calls, Higgins was “indisposed” and Costley on the sick list; whilst Dobson, though playing, had not fully recovered from a throat affection. Notts Rangers were not a powerful lot, or they would have managed more than 3 goals against Everton's 1, but they played pretty well together in an ostentatious manner. Cook, Shaw, and Hodder dropping in for the bulk of the attacking work. It will be kinder to say nothing about the Everton display except that Smalley did fairly well in goal –Joliffe would have done as well, by the bye –that Fair promised satisfactorily as a back, and that Gibson and Farmer were the most brilliant among weak forwards.
EVERTON REDIVIVU
Athletic News - Tuesday 10 January 1888
Everton's "calendar month" having expired on Thursday, they re-commenced operations on their own account on Saturday. And what a start! A rising club in Notts Rangers had been engaged, and about 4,000 supporters repaired to Anfield to give their pets a welcome, but with expectations, of course, of witnessing a good game. The chagrin felt can readily be imagined when it became certain that there was something wrong with the locals. “Authentic cards" of the tam were hawked about. The one there recorded was only a shadow of former talent, but the eleven that eventually did duty was weaker than that officially announced per programme. The game commenced with nine men to maintain the reputation of the ill-starred Liverpool Cup-holders. Welsh, a cast off some years ago, and Cartwright were subsequently induced to don the jersey and make, for appearance sake, if not for skill, a complete numerical side. Only Smalley, Gibson, Dobson, and Farmer represented Everton's pre-suspension formation; but where were Higgins and Fleming? The former was on the ground, watching the discomfiture of his confreres. Are Everton going through a second crisis, and this from a rebellious attitude of old players? Surely, Everton have received a shock more severe than had been hitherto anticipated. The makeshift eleven included Douglas, a second team man of at least ten years standing; Evans, from Oswestry, who wore "specs," and was corpulent; and an old Welsh Internationalist, who up to last season had figured regularly in the Bootle team. The Rangers, too, were not in their full strength, but they had little difficulty in holding the game well in hand. Ends changed with the score a goal each, Everton securing their point from hands. In the second half Notts did the bulk of the pressing and scored twice, thus winning by three goals to one. Smalley kept goal efficiently, and it was his skill alone that confined the record to only three. Fair, Jones, Gibson, and Farmer were most conspicuous of the others. Notts had a level set of forwards, Cooke being a shade superior to his four colleagues ; Palmer and Shelton were clever at half-back, and, whilst the hacks were but moderate. Dawson did what little he had to do between the posts in a finished manner.
The Everton Football Club.
January 10 th 1888. The Liverpool Courier.
To the Editor of the Liverpool Courier.
Sir –Permitt me to thank you on behalf of a large section of the football community, for the space allowed in your paper for the ventilation of matters relative to the above club.
It is well-known that owing to the gross mismanagement and willful evasion of Association rules the club has been suspended for the last months, which has deprived some thousands of people from enjoying the winter pastime. During the suspension, it was expected that the executive would have called the members together in order to explain to them this causes of the unfortunate difficulty. This was not done, but upon a syndicate of members being formed a meeting was held at which the committee were severely censured for their reckiestness. It was evident from the discussions which took place that the club is not governed by the executive, but by an “insignificant Cabal” whose action are evidently influenced by sordid motives (the existence of a “ a clique” in this case, as in others, is a sure preludes to future decay). At the meeting members were led to believe that greater care would be excised in the future, but such is not the case; for though the committee had a month to prepare a team for Saturday last, they did not meet until Friday evening last for that purpose. A team was picked consisting of a number of fairly good players; but owing to their not being informed of selection when the ground was reopened on Saturday only four members of the team were present to meet the Notts Rangers, who were present to a man at the advertised time. After waiting fully 20 minutes during which the committee were busily engaged begging and praying of all the football “nonentities” (including the late captain of the abused “Bootle”) who were to be found, a team was at last got together. During this time loud expressions of undigation and disgust were manifested by the thousands who were present who had paid their money to see “Everton” and not to see her represented by a collection of nondescripts. The charge at the gate together with cards sold on the ground, is one of the greatest pieces of fraud ever perpetrated within my recollection.
It is therefore apparent that the hopes of reformation, of which we had fondly dreamed, are not to be realised. May I express the desire that members will take immediate action to avert further disaster, and restore our club to her once proud position. –Yours &c, A Member, January 9 th 1888.
Association game.
January 14 th 1888. The Liverpool Courier.
It would have been charitable had the process been possible to have drawn the vail over last Saturday's proceedings at Anfield, where after the vocation, Everton, or what is left of the old team, were opposed by the Notts Rangers. Notwithstanding the opportunities presented for reflection and reform, there was evidently a screw loose somewhere, for at the last moment a full team could not be placed in the field. It is all very well to say you can “command” professionals, but cannot control amateurs and it may be that there has been just a trifle too much of the commanding theory practised already. It was an unenviable predicament for the good old club to be placed in, but fortunately the hugh crowd confined the criticism to good-natured banter, chiefly at the expense of the powers that be. The play needs no comment and with Everton defeated by three to one, a further dark cloud would seem to have unbranded the Anfield district. Todays match. Everton v Witton on the Everton ground. The Everton team will be selected from; - Smalley, Dobson, Dick, R. Jones, Higgins, Gibson, R. Jones (Wrexham), Fayer, Whittle, Eyton-Jones, Farmer, Roach, Fleming and A.N. Other.
EVERTON’S NEW BEGINNING
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 14 January 1888
THE COMMITTEE CAUGHT NAPPING
By “Mickey Free”
Someone had blundered was the prevalent feeling at Everton on Saturday last when half-an-hour after the advertised time the game against Notts rangers was begun, and even at that late hour the home team were still short of a couple of men. After the lapse of nearly 20 minutes the number of men was complete, and that is about all that can be said of most of them. Why is that? Surely the necessity of making an effective start must have been apparent to the least thinking member of the club, and something like a team of players ought to have been ready to take the field. It is difficult to reason against this way of putting the matter, yet I am informed that owing to various causes the usual days for the sitting of the Committee had of necessity to be passed over, and it was only on Friday night that the team was selected. This proved an unfortunate business as on Saturday between business sickness, and internal dissensions only six or seven of the chosen band turned up, if I may except Higgins who was seen on the ground walking towards the grand stand with a kind of Don’tye wish ye may catch me look on his countenance. Even supposing he had a grievance of some kind I cannot help thinking that he should either have taken his place in the field with his comrades or remained away. Let us hope that this is the last time it will be necessary to draw attention to such matters, and that the few busy-bodies who are doing their utmost to injure the club with which they are at present connected, will endeavor to find a new sphere wherein to give full scope to that legislative ability of which they appear to imagine that they are the only possessors.
THE GATE AND GAME
I find myself after all is over in a kind of half discredited position and it is thusly; I foretold a good gate- that was right; a good game-therein I erred and profiting by experience shall be very chary of predications in future. Gibson started the fun, and the Rangers were immediately in close proximity to Everton’s goal, Smalley having full scope to show what he could do in the way of taking care of his charge, and the impression he made on the spectators was most unmistakable as was evidenced by the hearty cheer which greeted him on charging ends. The visitors had all the best of the game during the first half, but could only manage to get one shot through, and this was equalized by Gibson. The change of ends gave the Evertonians the benefit of the breeze and the game became more even. On one occasion E. Jones and Farmer got the ball away, and a fine centre right in the goal mouth followed, Douglas a sturdy veteran, made a desperate effort and looked like covering himself with glory, but no, the fates willed it otherwise, he missed his kick, rolled over, and came up smiling, covered with mud instead. It was a fine chance lost. The Rangers right wing made a vigorous rush. Dobson ought to have pulled them up, but missing his kick the ball shot just past Smalley. Once again Cooke got the ball through, and the game ended in a defeat of three to one.
THE PLAYERS
The Rangers were short of a couple of good men, and it was very fortunate for Everton that it was so, but they would have a very poor chance against Everton’s old cup team. Dobson was in his worst form. Fair did well at full back, whilst W. Jones worked very hard at half, and considering how seldom Welsh is now seen in the football field, he acquitted himself very well. The left wing had the most of the work to do, but being well watched their efforts were abortive. Today the Witton lads will appear at Everton, when I hope a better state of affairs will be maintained.
EVERTON v. WITTON.
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 14 January 1888
For the first time this season these teams met on the Everton enclosure. On the first occasion, thanks to the fact of Jolliffe being very much out of form, the Blackburn lads had not much difficulty in registering a win by five to three. The second meeting was in the Lancashire Cup, when Everton were much weaker owing to a number of non-eligible, and again victory rested with the Wittonians by a still heavier score, vis., four to one. On this occasion the Everton team of necessity was a very mixed one, but still it was much superior that which did duty here last week. The ground was in much better trim also as a wise precaution had been taken in sanding the lower goal. The weather was very threatening, but dull as it was it was sunshine as compared with the dense blackness in which the city has been enshrouded during the whole of the week. Three thousand persons were present when the teams faced each other as follow; - Witton: Wilson, goal; Smith and Pickering, backs; Whiteside, Almond, and Astley, half-backs: Haresnape, Grimshaw, Cunllffe, Horsfield end Turner, forwards. Everton: Smalley, goal; Dobson and Houldsworth, backs; R. Jones, Gibson and Fair, half-backs; Whittle, Farmer Higgins, Gilder, J. A. Eyton - Jones, forwards. Forty minutes after the advertised time Whittle Kicked off. Witton got down, and Whiteside kicked wide. Turner and Horsfleld next became prominent on the left, but the latter sent over the line. Farmer then came away but was nicely tackled by Grimshaw, who deprived him and got on the back track. Fanner, being nicely fed by R. Jones, again got away but putting too much beef into his kick, got the ball over the line. Whittle met the kick out and finished with a good shot. Wilson saved and Darwen by good play got back, Houldsworth and Dobson in turn checked determined onslaught and Horsfield shot wide. Turner was penalized for lying off-side from which point he sent in a dangerous shot. Everton now rushed up, Gilbert getting in a meritorious run and pass to centre, but E. Jones screwed wide, a groan of disappointment following. The excitement began to rise as the play improved. Wilton got well back, and a claim of off-side was just allowed as Grimshaw shot the ball through. Of course the point was not allowed, and Smalley was cheered for a splendid save from Haresnape. Whittle next dribbled up and passed to Farmer, but the latter was ruled off-side. E. Jones end Farmer again came with a rush, Farmer centred, and Gilder shot in. Wilson saved at the expense of a corner, which was cleared. Up to this time Everton were playing minus Fleming, who had not turned up. Half-time arrived with no goal scored. At this point another player joined the home team. After the kick-off a comer fell to Everton, Wilson having a near shave of being shoved through. Seven minutes elapsed and Whittle scored a beauty tor Everton. Great cheering followed. A few minutes later Whittle headed a second goal from a corner. Everton had decidedly the best of the play now. Farmer, receiving from R. Jones, shot in, but Smith returned. The Witton left came up and Gibson returned. Final Result;- Everton 2, Witton 0.
NUGGETS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 14 January 1888
GRUMBLERS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 14 January 1888
Grumblers (Not the “Grumbler”) up Everton way are asking;-
Is the Everton suspension over?
Where were Higgins and Fleming on Saturday? Have they been driven away?
Who is the Everton Committeeman who “don’t care for the club’s reputation”? Haul down the Flag.
Is the team of Saturday, the 7th to be the team for the remainder of the season?
If so, what will be the gate on Saturday next? Ichabod.
Who’s “on” for another meeting of “members”?
Who got your Briscoe “suspended”?
Were there no “old horses” at Everton without going to Bootle, Alec?
Is that your team to play “As(h) ton Villa,” John?
Won’t the Field waken them up next Saturday, boys? You bet!
The Everton Football Club
January 14 th 1888. The Liverpool Courier.
To the Editor of the Liverpool Courier.
Sir –Will you please find space for me to vent my feelings to the above? In the first place I beg to endorse every word in “A Member's” letter published in your issue of the 10 th instant; alas to add that I, and in fact, the majority of those present at Anfield on Saturday last, went with the full intention of giving out local champions a real good hearty British cheer, when they entered the field of action (but, alas! The solitary four of the once famous eleven whom used to do duty under the banner of Everton! Now, why should not the clique publish the list of players in your weekly issue, so that the constant supporters of the club could see on Saturday morning who are going to represent Everton in her engagement for that day, and not let the poor working men to proceed upon to the extent of three pence entrance to ground and another threepeace for the new stand which I consider that the working man brought for the club last season, to see such a poor display as that of last Saturday.
Such treatment as this I consider is nothing short of imposition, and that imposition does not end here. Immediately you have entered the ground a small army of youths surround you with cry of “Programmes with names and positions of players.” Naturally you like want to know who the players are and therefore lay out another hard-earned penny, and what's the result. Why another –well, I won't use the word that comes to my pen. Well might your correspondent of the 10 th ask, where are Higgins and Fleming? The former on the ground looking on, the latter I knew is much pressed always to be on time for a 2-30 kick off. But what about that useful member Costley? Nothing, said. Just fancy five to six thousand people being gulled in this fashion. I think the sooner the management throw up the rains of office the better. Let the club be thoroughly overhauled, and the members who are wanted to play be informed of the fact before nine or ten o'clock on Friday evening, so that they can arrange to appear in condition at the appointed time –Yours &c, Everton. Jan 15 1888.
FOOTBALL NOTES
January 16, 1888. The Liverpool Mercury
Everton have rallied. A week ago it was painfully proved that they had not then obtained their equilibrium after the staggering below delivered by the all-powerful English Council. In their anxiety to present as good a front as possible on reappearing to the football world, the selection of the tear was driven off till the eleventh hour on Friday week. This proved a false step, as players were not apprised in sufficient time of their selection to play, and thus it was that Everton were shorthanded in their opening contest. Since then the cup holders have secured a grand centre half-back in the person of R. Jones, who has been a conspicuous figure in the Wrexham Olympic team, and has, in addition, been selected by the Welsh Association for international honours. This useful player has recently taken up his abode in Liverpool, and will, no doubt, be often seen displaying his undoubted skill at Anfield. Witton, who have twice this season beaten Everton rather easily, and that on Liverpool soil, were the opponents of Everton on Saturday. The visitors were without Shorrocks and Hottersall, but there were good substitutes for these conspicuous absentees; but though Everton were a man short up to the interval, an opening being left for Fleming, who was expected to join the team, they held their own during the first half, and did all the scoring in the second, winning by 2 to 0, after an interesting contest. The attendance was not so large as on the previous Saturday, for obvious reasons, but the 3,000 faithful followers were agreeably surprised to witness such a sterling performance on the part of Dobson's colleagues. Higgins was in good form at half-back; Dobson never played better than he did after the opening ten minutes; Farmer, Whittle, Eyton-Jones, and Gilder worked together; but R. Jones was the hero of the day, and fed his forwards with judgement. He back tactics of Witton were superior of those of their forwards. Spectator.
Everton v Witton
January 16, 1888. The Liverpool Courier.
Everton met their old opponents at the Anfield enclosure on Saturday with a reorganised team, and in anticipation of a good game, the supporters of the home club again turned up in large numbers, close upon 4,000 persons, being present. Still some difficulty was experienced in making up the team, but eventually the services of a full quorum were accrued with the result that a welcome victory was achieved. Whittle started for Everton, who were a man short and Eyton-Jones losing possession, Whiteside rushed off, but shot wide. Witton pressed, a kick off by Dobson clearing. Farmer then romped away to no purpose and on R. Jones passing to Eyton-Jones, Farmer had another chance at goal, but was beaten ere he got steadied for a shot. Houldsworth, when play was at the Everton end, saved well twice, and then Everton paid several visits to Witton goalkeeper, R. Jones repeatedly supplying his forwards with opportunities, but Wilson saved well, though Gilder's attempt nearly upset him. Smalley next fisted out hard, and again Everton gave anxiety. Witton cleared with some difficulty, and the visitors went down the hill in the most determined manner, Smalley after some meddling shot had been attended to saving grandly near the post from Cunliffe. Back again, =R. Jones gave Everton forwards the ball, Farmer forcing a futile corner. Everton continued the pressure for a time, and after withstanding a short but sharp assault at their goal, the homesters moved up the left, a pass by Farmer to Eyton-Jones being just cleared by Wilson, and this scarcely been done than Higgins sent in a good one. Some even play, during which Dobson put in really grand work, was followed by Everton forwards going along in fine combination, a hot shot by Farmer, which Wilson saved magnificently, bringing up the interval. Cartwright, on changing ends, completed the home team. Still Witton left at once became busy, R. Jones having to kick off; a hot assault ensued, without effect, and so Farmer rushed off, Whittle nearing beating the goalkeeper, who saved in giving a corner. Hands to Everton was sent outside, but as Witton failed to clear, Everton again closed up, Whittle scoring first goal in the game in quiet shot. On resuming Witton became troublesome, but Smalley took in hand Cunliffe's shot. Everton again at once got under sail, and from a corner taken by Higgins arising from a hot scrimmage, Whittle headed through a second time. Continuing the attack, Farmer passed to Whittle, who made a good attempt, and then a nice pass by Whittle to Cartwright met with a like result. Witton now had a brief look at Everton goal, R. Jones preventing danger, and in turn Pickering was soon called upon to check a raid. For a long period play was almost entirely confined to the visitors' quarters, Farmer doing some brilliant runs. Witton however, at the close got up to goal in a most menacing attitude, a volley of quick shots being only nufflified by Smalley chucking behind, and this was followed by a practiced assault, but no weak spot was found in Everton defence, and the home club secured a meritorious victory of two goals to nil. Teams; - Witton; - Wilson goal; Smith and Pickering, backs; Whitside, Almond, and Astley, half-backs; Haresnape, Grimshaw, Cunliffe, Horsefield, and Turner, forwards. Everton; - Smalley, goal; Dobson (captain) and Houldsworth, backs; Gibson, R. Jones, and Higgins, half-backs; Eyton-Jones, Farmer, Whittle (Liverpool Gymnasium), Cartwright, and Gilder, forwards.
EVERTON THEMSELVES AGAIN
Athletic News - Tuesday 17 January 1888
The fiasco of the previous work at Anfield has had an effect upon the attendance, as it was expected to do. The disgust felt was general that matters should have been muddled, after having had four week’s leisure for reflection and re-organization. However, there were about 3,000 persons present to witness the Everton display against Witton. Had Liverpudlians been sure that such a fine game was in store as that of Saturday turned out to be, the assembly would have been 6,000 strong. Witton have twice this season, at Anfield, lowered the Everton colours somewhat ruthlessly; but on their third meeting the tables were unexpectedly turned, as Witton were beaten by two goals to none, and there was no fluke in it either. R. Jones, of Wrexham Olympic, and Welsh Internationalist, has taken up his residence in Liverpool, and, expected to assist Everton regularly. He played for the first time for the Liverpool Cup holders on Saturday, and his finished skill as centre half-back explains everything concerning Witton’s discomfiture. Farmer was well fed by him, and as Eyton Jones, Whittaker, and Gilder (a second team man) ably seconded Farmer's efforts; this quartette were ever giving trouble. Higgins and Gibson were also good half-backs, Dobson was in rare form, Smalley clever as usual whilst Houldsworth promised well as back. For Witton, Wilson behaved handsomely between the sticks; and Smith and Pickering backs, Whiteside and Almond half-backs, and Grimshaw and Cunliife forwards, made most friends. Everton played ten men in the first half, and ends were changed with the score blank. In the second portion Everton popped the only goals scored in an interesting match.
Witton had 20 pounds guaranteed to play their return match at Everton instead of Blackburn, and made a good investment in face of the Rovers and North End match.
WITTON V EVERTON
January 21, 1888. The Blackburn Standard
Witton, for the third time this season, paid a visit to the Anfield-road enclosure on Saturday. The home club was strengthened from the previous Saturday by the presence of R.Jones (Wrexham Olympic) and J. Whittle. There were about 3000 spectators present when Whittle kicked off for Everton. Soon Witton were at the home goal, and Whiteside shot wide. Farmer then came away, but was eased by the strangers' right wing. From a kick by Smith, R. Jones got possession and gave to Farmer, who sent in a beauty, but Wilson managed to clear. The ball soon travelled to the other end, when Smalley had to negotiate two shots, and Witton would have scored had Turner not been penalised for off-side. Continuing the pressure, Witton were soon at the Everton goal, Houldsworth being conspicuous in clearing. Farmer was now off in a tricky run the length of the field, finishing up with a shot which Wilson cleared. The home left were again seen to advantage, Eyton Jones just shooting over. Excitement ran high as Smalley was fisting out shot after shot, Grimshaw being ruled off-side just as he put one past. From the goal kick Haresnape got the leather, and called on the home custodian to handle a warm one. R. Jones was here playing splendidly, and assisted Farmer in getting up the field, the latter player giving to Whittle, who tried an overhead shot for goal, which Wilson got away. The Witton forwards were now busy, but found Dobson in his place. The spectators cheered loudly as the home forwards were seen in a pretty piece of play up the field, the Witton goalkeeper clearing a shot from Farmer at the expense of a corner. Higgins took the kick, but nothing came of it; and half-time arrived neither side having scored. Assisted by Cartwright in the second half, Everton took the upper hand, and were awarded a corner, Wilson throwing to the side, as he was pushed through the goal. Nothing came of the kick, and the ball was taken to the other end, where Harsenpae just sent over the bar. Coming down again, Farmer tried a shot, and then hands were given against Witton. Gibson essayed a lob, which was cleared, and soon afterwards Whittle scored for Everton. Witton now put in a lot of work, but found the home back division too strong. It soon became evident that Everton were wearing the strangers down, Wilson having to save six or seven shots in succession, but he could not clear a very easy one from Whittle. With two goals to the good, Everton continued to play hard to augment their score, but found no further opening. Witton pulled themselves together for a final effort, and nearly scored, when the whistle sound, with the score –Everton, two goals; Witton, nil. Teams; Witton; Wilson, goal; Smith and Pickering, backs; Whiteside, Almond, and Astley, half-backs; Haresnape, Grimshaw, Cunliffe, Horsfield, and Turner, forwards. Everton; Smalley, goal; Dobson (captain) and Houldsworth, backs; Gibson, R. Jones, and Higgins, half-backs; Eyton-Jones, Farmer, Cartwright, Whittle, and Gilder, forwards.
BRAVO OFF
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 21 January 1888
Last Saturday was signalized by some very agreeable items to Liverpool footballers, and it is a long time sines matters have so been bright and promising as just now. The clouds which hung threateningly over Bootle were dispersed, and they have emerged from a very trying ordeal with flying colours. Everton have, by their victory over Witton, won back the allegiance of their supporters; and, lastly, a Liverpool and District eleven proved altogether too powerful for a strong team of Cheshire. The first event was anticipated with confidence by Messrs. Heard and Prescott, after the very searching inquiry which they felt confident had failed to elicit any instances of a breach of Association rules, although after the suspension of Everton the supporters of the latter club appear greatly surprised at the immunity of Bootle. Everton’s victory over Witton aroused something like the old enthusiasm amongst its supporters, and the result created no little surprise amongst those who were not witnesses of the game. “Witton must have had a weak team" was the universal cry: but no, such was not the case for the absence of Shorrocks and Hothersall makes small difference in team with such a strong list of playing members as Witton. Over, Everton played in the first half with ten men, and the eleventh was not of much assistance when did turn out. Perhaps the most surprised of all were the Witton players, who had a right, and who evidently did expect an easy victory, for they very obligingly played the fixture, which was down for settlement at Witton, on the ground of their opponents, a matter which they will probably now regret. The easy victory of the District team over Cheshire was due downright superiority, and the greatest credit is due to all the players for their fine exhibition.
A RARE VICTORY
After the fiasco of the 7th, the game at Anfield Road proved quite a refresher to the sinking spirits of Evertonians. The crowd was not anything like so numerous as on the previous Saturday, a pretty plain warning to the Everton executive; and when it was noted that only team turned put to commence the game, there were ominous shaking of the head all-round the ground. But before the game had progressed for all the mistakes of the past were condoned, when it was perceived that the home team were playing with the traditional Everton dash. Houldsworth, of the Reserve, partnered Dobson, although it was believed that Dick might be able to take up his old place. A new half-back was called up, Jones, late of Wrexham Olympic, who gave promise of turning out one of the most brilliant players in his position that the club has yet possessed. A.N. Other blossomed forth as Eyton Jones on the left with Farmer; Whittle once more came to the rescue of a club for which he ought always to have played, and then whom they have never had such a centre since the palmy days of Jack McGill. The right wing was occupied solely by Gilder during the first half, and he was partnered by Cartwright afterwards. Thus a most serviceable side was got together, and with a little practice they will prove tough enough for the strongest teams. The match was thoroughly well contested, and it speaks volumes for the newly-modelled team that at half-time they and quite maintained their own against odds. In the latter stages Whittle scored twice amidst the most unbounded enthusiasm, and strive as they would Witton could not get upon terms. Jones was the hero of the home side, but Smalley deserves immense praise for his fine goalkeeping. Witton were not half so keen as on the occasion of their other visits to Liverpool; their forwards seemed to have grown stale, for they were certainly not nearly as clever as on their last appearance at Everton.
AN EYE-OPENER AT EVERTON
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 21 January 1888
By “Mickey Free”
WONDERS WILL NEVER CEASE
It’s myself would just like to see the gossoon who’d have been bold enough just to whisper that there was the remotest chance of the Everton mixture upsetting Witton last Saturday. But there’s no getting over the facts, at least I used to think so, but after some decisions, which I have lately heard of, by a very notable body of gentlemen, well I’m beginning to have some glimmerings of doubt on the subject. Be that as it may, Witton got walloped very handsomely, and it is not too much to say that it was accomplished by ten men, as the eleventh man who joined the game at half-time had little or nothing to do, and perhaps it was just as well, as he has had very little practice, and hence of very little use.
A GOOD GAME THIS TIME
Everton had to face the incline at the start, and murmurs were heard predicting another fiasco when it was noticed that the Blue and Whites only numbered ten, the absentee being Fleming. Very few minutes elapsed before the uneasy spirits began to open wide their eyes. Could it be? Aye, there could be no manner of mistake about it, Jack was as good as his master, and Everton were holding their own. When this revelation fairly dawned on the spectators, as they saw Georgie Farmer dash off along the wing from a pretty pass by R. Jones, they lifted up their voices in a loud and prolonged cheer. This feeling was kept up after a futile attempts on the part of Grimshaw and Turner, when Whittle caused Wilson no end of trouble to save a well-directed shot. Nothing daunted, however, the Wittonians made a dashing attack, calling out all the powers of Messrs. Dobson, Smalley, and Houldsworth. At one point Witton looked very dangerous, but Turner’s zeal overstepped his judgement, until an appeal of offside brought him to his senses, as his playing the ball upset Grimshaw’s chance, which he took directly afterwards. Everton made a spirited reply to this onset, and showed combination which it was too much to expect from a lot of players almost strange to each other. Smith cleared a corner shot, and then the whole four forwards came in line, E. Jones passing to Farmer, he to the centre, and by an overhead kick Whittle almost scored. Houldsworth then nearly made a fatal mis-kick. Meeting a shot from Turner he screwed the ball hard into his own goal, but Smalley was there, and then from a pass by Farmer, Eyton Jones showed that he can still shoot, but Wilson stopped grandly, and so the game proceeded full of smart bits of play, but it was not till seven or eight minutes after the change of ends that Whittle managed to put on the first chalk, and after an exactly similar interval the same player shot in hard, but I afterwards ascertained that Wilson had partially cleared this shot when Farmer, by an irresistible spring, headed the ball back, and so won a splendid game by two to love.
THE PLAYERS
If Samlley’s goalkeeping had not been of an exceptionally high order Witton would doubtless have gone back with lighter hearts. Dobson contributed his very best efforts towards the very much to be desired result. Houldsworth was just a little wild but for a young player did very well. Gibson was very safe and Higgins was in good trim, whilst R. Jones was always where he was wanted, in fact to use the genial referee’s opinion (Mr. Brownlow) he played a champion game. Gilder did very much better than when I saw him last, whilst the other three worked beautifully together. For the visitors Smith and Pickering played a fine game, Whiteside, although at times up to his old form, was a bit erratic, but the forwards played a pretty game, although they failed to find an opening. On one occasion they really had hard lines, as the ball struck the crossbar and came straight down, but was just hit away in time.
THE GATE
There was a considerable falling off in the attendance, which of course was only natural after the exhibition of the previous Saturday, it must be borne in mind that where are institution, be it what it may, is kept up by the public, its foundation is not of adamant, but rather of the quicksand type, so that if it is to be retained no effort must be spared which will ensure this end.
Everton meet Stanley on the ground of the latter to-day, and as A. Dick has received the sanction of the Association to play, the team available should be somewhat stronger than last week.
Association Game
January 21 st 1888. The Liverpool Courier.
The victory of Everton over Witton came as a welcome surprise to the former's supporters, who had assembled to the numbers of quite 3,000. The “universal providers” as Witton are termed, brought a strong team to do duty for them, whilst the home club had a far different eleven to that of the previous Saturday. R. Jones a welsh International considerably strengthened the half-back division, and Whittle (Liverpool Gymnasium having kindly allowed him to assist his old club) acquitted himself most evidently as centre forward. This is the third time the clubs have met this season, the previous games ending in Witton's favour. The first part of the match proved of an interesting character, and notwithstanding the disparity in point of numbers, the Everton forwards, who were well fed by R. Jones, often placed the Witton goal in danger. Both custodians, however, managed to keep their respective charges intact, and up to the interval no pints had been scored. During this half Everton had only been playing ten men, but on the resumption of play Cartwright completed the team. Shortly after the restart, Everton attacked hotly, and Whittle beat the visitors' custodian with a quiet shot. After a futile effort by Witton a corner by Higgins was turned to advantage by Whittle, who thus had the honour of scoring the only goals in the match. Witton tried hard to equalise towards the close of the game, but without success, and was evidently ouzzled to account for their defeat.
STANLEY V EVERTYON
January 23, 1888. The Liverpool Mercury.
Walton Stiles was visited by a large company of spectators, possibly 4000 or 5000 to witness the contest between Stanley and Everton. The visitors were without Whittler and Gibson, the latter having been injured during the week, and R.Jones received a kick on the knee shortly after the start, and had to cease play. Dick entered his professional career as centre forward. Stanley were more fortunate than Everton, as they were enabled to put their best team in the field. Dick started against the wind, and the home forwards moved up, hands for Stanley resulting in first goal kick, from which Dobson sent to the left, Eyton-Jones and Farmer rushing down and shooting behind. Brown retaliated, and a foul against Dick looked critical, but Smalley kicked away smartly. Stanley located play in Everton quarters for a time, and on Everton relieving a littler W. Wilson put Stanley again on the attack in a fine punt. Brown shooting outside and over, and McGoldrick also going behind. R. Jones, Dobson, and Dick worked hard to stem the home rushes, but Stanley were so persistent that Dobson was forced to yield a corner, whilst an advantous throw in was of no use in the hands of Roberts, who chucked behind. At length Everton cleared on the left, who got well down, Gilder going outside from a pass. R. Jones, who had one or two tussles for possession with Goodall, at this juncture received a severe kick on the knee, and was incapacitated for further play. Farmer now went half-back, and the game proceeded with four forwards for Everton. Stanley were again, busy at goal, but the several shots were harmless until Goodall sent in a real beauty, which Smalley coolly handled. Dick made his way to the half line, where Stanley took a throw in, from which Jones ran and shot well, and this was followed by a very near thing from Brown, who skimmed the bar. Stanley had more ineffective shots, and then Higgins beating Goodall, a throw in was nicely kicked away by W.Wilson, and a short attack finished off by Charteris sending behind. In a twinkling, Smalley had to fist out twice, and Stanley pressed severely, but, Higgins, Farmer, and Dobson always managed to be in the way to prevent disaster. A rush by Everton was easily repelled, and Stanley renewing the assault, Jones and McGregor each tried good shots. Houldsworth headed away nicely, though not effectively, as Roberts forced a corner, and, after some skirmishing near goal Jones sent across to Brown, who at last beat Smalley in a shot that passed just under the bar. Houldsworth cleared another onslaught, and this incident brought up half-time, with Stanley leading one to nothing. On Goodall resuming, Dobson missed his kick, which enabled Stanley to be troublesome, and after some pressure W.Wilson sent the ball well up to Goodall, who passed to Jones, the latter scoring in a surprising manner, and this against a strong wind. Everton relieved on the left, and attacked , though not heavily, and after Farmer had failed from a long range Stanley backs cleared, the home forwards going away in a fine run, Brown testing Smalley with a difficult shot. Jones had a chance, but did not avail himself of it, and then the visitors went away for a short and rather weak attack. Stanley right wing next became conspicuous for a dashing run, which was nipped in time, and on Everton closing up to Stanley goal Glider essayed a good shot. Urquhart saved by a throw, and Stanley once more paid a visit to Everton goal. When in close quarters, Dick and Brown came in conflict, which was decided against the Evertonians, and Pollock took the free kick arising from the foul. This was so well placed that Goodall easily turned it to account, and scored a third goal for Stanley. The play after this incident was of equal merit; both ends were several times reached, but nothing could be done to change the score, so Stanley are to be congratulated on a well-earned victory over their old rivals and neighbours of 3 goals to nil, for which achievement they were the recipients of a hearty cheer. Teams; Stanley; W. Urquhart, goal; G. Wright, and W. Wilson, backs; J. Roberts, H. Pollock, and J. Wilson, half-backs; C. McGoldrick, R. Jones, A. Goodall, W. McGregor, and A. Brown, forwards. Everton; W. Smalley, goal; Houldsworth and G. Dobson, backs; W. Jones, R. Jones, and M. Higgins, half-backs; Gilder, Charteris, Dick, Farmer, and Eyton-Jones, forwards. Referee, Mr. Fitzory Norris.
FOOTBALL NOTES
January 23, 1888. The Liverpool Mercury
The leading item of interest to associationists in Liverpool on Saturday was the fight between Stanley and Everton. A contest in which head local clubs are the principals is not a common occurrence in this district, and as Stanley have steadily improved as the season has advanced, whilst Everton have retrograded from their high estate, a hard tussle was generally anticipated. Walton Stiles presented an unusually animated appearance, for where Everton are there also will be found their crowd of patrons. It is not often, if ever before, that 4,000 spectators congregates at the Stanley ground, and the numerous officials had more work than could be accomplished in trying to keep the field of play clear, though it must be said the touchline was seldom encroached upon. Stanley have made some creditable displays during the season, notably against Halliwell, Mitchell St. George's, Earlestown, and Chester; and they have been lucky in being able to put almost identical teams in the field as that of Saturday. On the other hand, Everton's career lately has been a chequered one, and they were singularly unfortunate for their match with Stanley. R. Jones (who, the secretary of the Welsh Association writes to say, has not been selected for international honours) came into violent collision with Goodall early in the game, and received an injury severe enough to prevent him continuing play, and Everton were thus left with ten men. Gibson also met with an accident whilst following his employment during the week. It is true Dick, who has now come out as a fully-fledged professional, resumed a position in the Everton team, but it cannot be said he made a taking impression as a centre forward either for skill or tactics, as he gave several fouls. Taken on the whole, the cup holders were a moderate lot. The forwards being perhaps their weakest spot, and it is very doubtful, even with a complete eleven, if they could have staved off defeat. Stanley played a sterling game, and, though their shooting in the first half was not so accurate as it might have been, had it not been for the smartness of Smalley the scoring would have been heavier. The home team, curiously, were the more effective against the wind, whilst Everton were correspondingly disappointing with the breeze at their backs; and, always having the game well in hand, Stanley achieved a coveted victory of 3 goals to none, and a popular one too, judging from the triumphant progress from the ground to the headquarters. Where the result has been so satisfactory it will be hardly necessary to particulates any Stanley players. The present team thoroughly understand each other under the captaincy of Archie Goodall, and they may yet grasp the local cup.
Stanley v Everton
January 23 rd 1888. The Liverpool Courier.
These teams met at Walton-stiles on Saturday and notwithstanding the unsettled state of the weather there was a large attendance of spectators, close upon 3,000 being present. Everton opened against the wind, whereupon Stanley returned and crossed into the Everton half. Here “hands” were given to Stanley, the ball from the free kick going harmlessly over the line. Jones and Farmer broke away, which was not off by Brown, who got well into Everton quarters. Hands, off Dick caused Smalley to clear smartly. Stanley continued to press without advantage, and the attack was renewed on Wilson kicking strongly. Brown and McGoldrick took futile shots, and after Everton backs had cleared, Stanley again became the aggressive, Dobson giving a corner, as a check, Roberts took a throw in badly, and then Everton moved away on the left Gilder putting behind from a pass. R. Jones in collision with Goodall, got badly hurt at this point and retired, Farmer going half-back. On resuming Stanley pressed and shot often, one by Goodall being especially well saved by Smalley. Dick got under sail, but was sent cut at the half line, and from the thrown-in Jones, got up and shot nicely without effect, and Brown shortly afterwards surmounted the bar. Some more shooting ensued, and Higgins dodging Goodall, got well off and threw in close up to goal, W. Wilson clearing, but Charteris ran up and shot outside. Stanley now pressed determinedly, but Smalley starved shot after shot, and it was just on half-time when Jones passed nicely over to Brown, and Smalley was at last beaten in a clinging shot. Up to now it looked in Everton's favour as one goal up to nothing was not very formidable with the aid of a strong wind. But Everton were at once in difficulties son resuming Dobson missing a kick from Goodall's kick off, and in a few moments on W. Wilson putting in a useful kick Goodall took the ball up, Jones taking the pass and scoring cleverly. Everton then attacked for a time, which culminated in Farmer going wide from a long shot. Stanley forwards next ran down in pretty combination, but Smalley safely attended to Brown's difficult shot. Another short assault by Everton was followed by an exchange of visits. Gilder shooting well without success. A little later Dick fouled Brown, and give a free kick near goal, from which Goodall scored. The subsequent play was more even, but nothing occurred in the scoring line, so Stanley scored a popular win by three goals to nil, in a game in which they excelled at almost every point. Teams; - Stanley; - W. Urquart, goal; G. Wright, and W. M. Wilson, backs; J. Roberts, H. Pollock, and J. W. Wilson, half-backs; C. McGoldrick, Jones, W. McGregor, W. Brown, and A. Goodall (captain), forwards. Everton; - W. Smalley, goals; Houldsworth and G. Dobson, (captain), backs; W. Jones R. Jones, and M. Higgins, half-backs; Gilder, Charteris, Dick, G. Farmer and Eyton-Jones forwards.
St. Helens Association v Everton Reserves
These teams met on the Everton ground at Anfield on Saturday, and notwithstanding the wretched state of the weather, there was a large attendance of spectators. The visitors held the upper hand from the commencement, and playing well together severely pressed their opponents. The visitors goalkeeper never touched the leather on one occasion in this half, and ends were changed with the score St. Helens two goals, Everton nil. In the second half the home team were again on the defensive, and Joliffe saved repeatedly. When time was called St. Helens had won by four goals to one. The game was considerably more one-sided than the score indicates, but the visitors' forwards shot badly. The following were the teams; - St. Helens; - R. Pinnington goal; R. Green and F. Lloyd, backs; J. Duxbury, R. Stoddart, and T. Howard, half-backs; J. Pinnington, W. Miller, J. W. Sims, R. Jones, and W. Gilbert, forwards. Everton; - C. Jolliffe, goal; Pace and Oakley, backs; Brown, T. Jones, and Graham, half-backs; Douglas, Halton, Houghton, Hughes and E. Jones forwards.
STANLEY ENTERTAINS THE EVERTONIANS.
Athletic News - Tuesday 24 January 1888
Everton visited the plains of Walton Stiles on Saturday. to renew their acquaintance with Stanley, accompanied by a large following of Anfieldites. About 4,000 paid for admittance, an unexampled amount of patronage for Stanley, and their exchequer, which can hardly be an overflowing one, will receive a welcome lift. Stanley's ground is capacious, but there are no stands, and the consequence followed, of the crowd continually crossing the barrier. A numerous staff of officials, however, managed to keep the touch line almost clear. There was a strong wind blowing from goal to goal, and so the home team had the advantage of the breeze during the first half. They pressed persistently, but Smalley was only nonplussed once. This looked favorable to Everton, but. "0, what a surprise!” as Stanley romped off, were steadier against the wind than with it in front of goal, and scored twice, finally winning by three goals to nil. Stanley played uniformly well, and thoroughly deserved victory. They will yet show good fight for the Liverpool Cup. There are "extenuations" to be recorded for Everton's breakdown. Gibson was prevented from playing through injury at his work, and R. Jones, who was the life and soul of the team last week, got kicked by Goodall on the knee early in the game, and had to cease play. Farmer went half back then, and left the forwards, who were far from strong, still weaker—hence the fall. Dick is too useful at back to go centre forward, where he does not shine. Everton will be stronger by and bye, as Fleming will be available when the light admits of later starts. Whittle was area absent.
EVERTON RESERVES “DROPPED” BY St. HELENS
The St. Helens Association Club, whose progress during the season has been marked with wonderful consistency, met a strong “Reserve” team of the Everton Club on the latter’s ground at Anfield. The play was very one-sided from the commencement, and during the first half the visitors’ goalkeeper never touched the ball once. The St Helens men had matters all their own way, and won by four goals to one.
Association Game
January 28 th 1888. The Liverpool Courier.
As was naturally expected, the meeting at Walton-stiles of Stanley and Everton excited a large amount of local interest, and with nothing of moment standing in the way, the attendant crowd must have numbered close upon 3,000 persons. For once Everton commenced with a full team, but with their evil star still in the ascendant, the valuable services of R. Jones at half-back were lost to them early in the game, leaving the remainder to be played out with ten men. They nevertheless made a good fight of it upto the change of ends, the arrival of which found them only a goal to the bad, Brown having just previously beaten Smalley with a clinking shot. The concluding half, however, opened disastrously, for the ball had not been long in motion ere Jones scored a second point for Stanley. It now became evident that the intrepid “Blues” had the game in hand, and playing up vigorously, Goodall, their captain succeeded in placing a third by which number they were, amidst much jubilation, hailed the winners of a game in which they had the advantage throughout. The Evertonians had several shies at goal, but their shooting was erratic, and invariably wide of the mark. Smalley, however, kept goal with credit and for one disaster at least he must be held blameless. Stanley attacked in good style, besides exhibiting good defensive powers; and on their present form the final struggle for the holding of the Liverpool Cup bids fair to arouse a much larger degree of interest than was apparent some weeks ago.
Todays matches.
Everton v Darwen at Dawren
Everton; - Smalley goal; Dick and Dobson, backs; Higgins, Jones and Fayer, halfbacks; Farmer Eyton-Jones, Goodall, Roach, and Fraser, forwards.
Everton Reserve v Tranmere Rovers at Anfield.
Joliife, goal; Houldsworth, and Richmond backs; F. Parry, Cunningham, and Crosbie, half-backs; Costley, W. Douglas, Farish, Gilder, and Charties, forwards.
A TASTE OF STANLEY QUALITY
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 28 January 1888
The gradual development of form by the Stanley team, has been one of the most important points in connection with local football during the current season. Their display against Mitchell's St George’s, which I had the pleasure to witness a few weeks backs, was to me quite a revelation, and their easy defeat of Everton last Saturday is one further proof that this, the most poorly supported of our best local clubs, is deserving of far more notice than is usually bestowed upon it by the public. The history of the club affords an Illustration of what dogged perseverance, in the face of apparently insuperable obstacles, may accomplish. It has always been a matter of surprise to me that so few spectators are attracted to Walton Stiles, but perhaps its exposed position renders some explanation of this fact, and indeed it is, perhaps, the chief reason. This lack of public support, has been compensated by the enthusiastic and practical aid of the faithful band who have stood to the club through thick and thin, and are now receiving that only sought reward, the establishment of their club on a footing with the best of the district. The defeat of Everton was easily achieved, and though somewhat discounted by the fact that one of their opponents retired early in the first-half, it is generally agreed that Stanley must have won under any circumstances. Goodall makes an excellent captain, and the constant effort to bring the same eleven together for every match is bearing food fruit in the excellent understanding which exists between all the players. The forwards are a capital string, and they go in for the short passing game, which they have cultivated and make use of to a greater extent than any set of forwards I have noticed in the district, with the exception of the Bootle Reserve, whose style is quite different to that of the first team.
EVERTON PEGGED BACK
The success over Witton had inspired Evertonians with confidence of their ability to give Stanley their quietus, and something like 4,000 spectators turned up at the stiles, an unwonted crowd, and Mr. Grant, for once in a way, had a “heavy bag,” This will not be the last if his team can keep up their present form, for the strangers to the ground, though not enamored of the accommodation afforded, expressed themselves as surprised at the clever tactics of the home team. Everton had a somewhat different side to that which defeated Witton. The appearance of Dick as a registered pro, was accompanied by the disappearance of Whittle and Gibson, the former preferring to assist Gymnasium against Bootle Reserve, whilst Gibson was injured during the week at his work. Then Charteris, an old failure of the proscribed team, was again tried on the right wing, but again proved a failure. R. Jones, the Wrexham half back, was hurt at the commencement of the game, and his absence for the remainder of the match, turned out a very unfortunate circumstance. The game was not long in progress before it animated a tendency to go in favour of the home side, and this tendency became more marked as time wore on. Many excellent assaults were made on the Everton goal, and Smalley again earned unstinted applause by his clever defence. It was, however, close on half-time before Brown brought about the downfall of Everton by good shot. Although they had to face a rather stiff breeze, the Stanley players showed no diminution in their power to hold Everton in check and to break through their defence. Jones scored a real beauty and Goodall got a third goal, leaving Everton defeated by three to nil The Everton display was disappointing, that of the forwards more especially. Dick was not a success as centre, and signalized his return by a resort to the “same old game,” whilst Farmer was principally engaged in the half-back line. All the winners played a good game, but Brown’s playful tendencies were again in evidence. This youngster has a bad name for roughness, which he was apparently ridding himself of. The presence of his old friend Dick proved too much for his self-restraint, and the pair had more than one playful encounter. Now that Bootle appear determined to win the Liverpool Cup this season, if they can, a lot of interest has suddenly arisen in the languishing competition. Stanley are glad that it is Bootle’s first team they will have to encounter and they are quite confident of their ability to give them a further release from the responsibility of preserving the valuable bit of plate during the season 1888-9.
EVERTON SNUFFED OUT AT WALTON STILES
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 28 January 1888
By “Mickey Free”
HOW HAAVE THE MIGHTY FALLEN
Comparisons are generally awkward on one side or the other, but one can hardly get on in an intelligible way without making them, this being especially the case when the question under discussion happens to be the doings of a football club. With this little prelude I will proceed to take up my parable, perhaps “conundrum” would be a better word, as in some senses it is more applicable to the doings of the Everton boys since their return to business. One Saturday we are mortified by seeing a moderate team of the Notts Rangers fairly gallop round them, the next week with the throbbing pulse we wait anxiously to see what will be done against a strong team from Witton and the unexpected happens-Witton is sat upon and no one more surprised than the men who performed the (for them) pleasant operation. What next? Dim visions of a run of luck a leathering of all the remaining clubs on the fixture card. Alas, the meeting with their old local rivals at Walton Stiles was indeed a rude awakening from a pleasant dream. The dribbling administered by Stanley was drastic enough, in fact it is a pill so difficult to swallow that I would not like to hazard a guess at the probable quantity of special brew which would be required to wash it down.
WHAT IS THE CAUSE
This is a question continually poked at yer humble servant-Now, sir, as I have never dabbled in the black art, and have no pretension to be an Oedipus, the question remains unanswered as I am quite as much in the dark as anyone else. Of course, I hear of broken promises on the part of players who have promised to come and give a helping hand until some of the men who styled professionals have been restored as amateurs. Until this much-to-be-desired result has been attained the Evertonians must of necessity be placed in a difficult position as to obtaining the services of men capable of doing justice to their colours, and it is absurd to pile the whole of the blame on one man.
THE GAME
The game was well patronized. In fact the number of spectators was so much above the ordinary attendance at this ground that several of the very numerous body of stewards appeared to lose their heads, and the unfortunate press men were ordered about in a most unceremonious fashion, so much so indeed that I have resolved that it will be my last visit unless proper accommodation is provided. A few chairs or a form from their dressing-room would not be a great infliction on their resources, but would prove a boon to men trying to record their doings. After the start it looked as if Everton would hold their own but the absence of Gibson at half-back was soon felt, and then R. Jones, who was playing in rattling form, received an ugly charge from the strudy Goodall placed him horse de combat, and as the game had only been in progress ten minutes when this took place, it was manifestly all up with the Evertonians and their defeat was a foregone conclusion.
THE PLAYERS
For the winners the back division had very little to do, but of what had to be done Pollock was always to the fore, whilst Goodall, Brown, and McGregor were most conspicuous in the van. Little need be said of the vanquished except that Smalley kept goal in his usual style. Houldsworth was a bit wild. Dobson missed Dick very much and my tip is don’t take him out of his proper place again. Higgins performed creditably at half-back. The efforts of Eyton Jones were fairly nonplussed after his partner Farmer had been withdrawn to defend. Gilden was just as bad as he was good against Witton, whilst Charteris had evidently not recovered from his recent illness. Today, the boys will perform before a Darwen crowd, but the team will be a better one than last week, and I expect to see them make a good stand.
DARWEN V EVERTON
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 28 January 1888
The return encounter between these teams was played in magnificent weather on the Barley Bank ground, this afternoon in the presence of 200 spectators. Owing to the severe frost the ground was extremely hard, but otherwise in splendid condition, and there was every reason to expect a capital game. The following were the teams, Darwen being minus Strachan, and the visitors Dobson and Gibson;- Darwen;- Holden, goal; Ireland and Leach, backs; Owen, Thornber and Marsden, half-backs; B. Dimmock, H. Shorrock, J. C. Holden (Wigan), Smith, and J. Shorrock, forwards. Everton; Smalley, goal; Dick and Fayer, backs; Higgins, W. Jones, and Nidd, half-backs; Fleming, Goodall, Roche, Farmer, and Eyton-Jones, forwards. Referee Mr. Joseph Hartley, Accrington. At ten minutes to three, Roche started the leather in the teeth of a piercing wind, and at once the game was taken into Everton territory, the sphere going out on two or three occasions. The visitors’ forwards then braced themselves together, and racing off to their opponents’ and Goodall shot through. The whistle had, however, just previously been blown and the point did not count. From a free kick in midfield, the homesters burst off to the Everton goal, and J. Shorrock had an easy chance of scoring, but mulled the chance miserably. Nidd relieved his lines, but the Darweners were not to be kept at bay, and once more attacking Smith sent in a demon shot which Smalley only just succeeded in getting round the corner of the upright. Nothing came of the corner, but still the home team maintained the aggressive, the visitors finding it difficult work to battle against the stiff breeze. Several times the ball was kicked behind the posts, and on one occasion an exciting scrimmage occurred in the goalmouth, Thornber ultimately kicking inside. At length the backs relieved, but Howard Shorrock returned the leather with a beautiful kick, which would certainly have scored had not Smalley put himself in the way and fisted out. Dimmock again shot in, and the “Toffy” colours would assuredly have been lowered if Dick had not kicked out. The corner proved abortive, and then the visitors’ forwards woke up, and by some pretty passing transferred the play to the home end. Roche sent in a splendid shot, but Holden was on the alert and fist out Eyton-Jones directly afterwards kicking past the posts. A minute later a corner was gained, but this was got safely away, and Everton once more forced on the defensive. J. Shorrock failing in an attempt at scoring. The pressure was still kept up, and after some severe struggling, in which Dick got his knee injured, Owen scored the first goal, the game having then been in progress 25 minutes. From the kick out, Everton pulled themselves together, and at once made tracks for their opponents citadel. The backs tried hard to prevent their progress, but they were successfully eluded, and Goodall banging the leather in Rochew gave it the finishing touch, the score thus being equalized. Spurred on by their supporters the Darweners strove hard to again obtain the lead, and for a few minutes it appeared as if the visitors’ defence would be broken through. Time after time was the ball sent in, but Smalley and Dick worked hard, and eventually sent their opponents away empty handed. A momentary visit was made to the home fortress, but a few minutes later the ball was again dancing about in dangerous proximity to Smalley’s charge. Twice did that player save in splendid style, but despite his and Dick’s utmost charge as they could not keep their goal intact, Holden being responsible for the Darwen second point, Smith followed with a third a minute later, and at the interval the visitors were in a minority of three goals to one. Immediately on resuming, Everton started off with a will, and took the leather to the home end, Leach pulled them up, however, and with a hugh kick transferred play to midfield. His forwards took up the running and made tracks for Smalley’s goal, where they were successfully tackled by Dick. A lot of even play ensued, either side struggling to make an impression on their opponents’ citadel, and both being denied victory. After twenty minutes there was a furious rush of Darwen forwards, and Smith added a fourth point. Farmer next put in a good run, but finished with a bad shot. Smith made a good reply, and then Farmer centred and Fleming scored a second goal, a rather easy one. The game again became a bit slow, the only feature being the couple of clever saves by Smalley. Holden added a fifty goal. Final Result. Darwen 5, Everton 2.
“MICKEY FREE’S” OBSERVATIONS
Bejorrah shure it’s nothin’ but grievances I’ve had to write about lately. The Everton Executive might all be Irish tenants; they have had so much to growl about. To-day the forward division were all right, but the backs all wrong, the long and short of it being that Fayer had to take Dobson’s place, the latter being in the hands of the doctor instead of his trainer. So much for doing the light fantastic two or three times a week! The Evertonians arrived on the Barley Bank ground in good time. The turf looked beautiful, but just a trifle hard after the severe frost, and I would have been better pleased had my seat been in the sun instead of the shade of the grand stand. Gibson was also an absentee, Nidd filling the vacancy. There wasn’t much difficulty in estimating the number of spectators when Roche kicked off against the wind. A couple of hundred would about the meet the mark. The game started tame until Goodall shot through, but the whistle having just sounded, Archie’s efforts went for nought. Darwen next looked like doing business, but Smalley slid the globe out, and the corner having been duffed Everton re-started and some pretty kicking and heading followed. A spicey bully in front of goal caused the few spectators to bristle up a bit. The very good defence of Fayer, Dick, Nidd, and Co, prevented mischief. A fine shot by H. Shorrock and Smalley shone, and a corner followed, and again Smalley pleased his admirers by a clever save. Fleming, Goodall, and Roche looked like bringing off a score, but the Darwen backs put in a strong negative, and E. Jones shot over. Everton were rewarded by a corner, but this was unproductive. Twenty-five minutes after start Owen sent in a corker which struck the underside of the bar and dashed past Smalley who couldn’t save it. Bravo Goodall! After a pretty run he shot in, Holden hit out, but Roche was in the right spot, and made matters level. But how tame the whole business seemed with scarcely a sound to be heard except the rattling of feet on the stand. Again Everton were on their mettle, and Smalley saved very neatly. Dick and Smalley were most deservedly cheered for a bit of clever saving. A corner and a scuffle, and Holden notched a second goal. Couple of minutes later Everton were again in trouble, a daisy cutter by Smith being quite too good for Smalley just before the whistle announced half-time. A couple of minutes’ rest for the teams and a drop of hot coffee- in which we did not participate-mores the pity- and the game recommenced. So far I have been very favourably impressed with Nidd’s playing and as our boys have the breeze in their favour there’s no saying what may happen. Fayer just missed a kick aand it almost happened that Holden put on another goal, the ball just going over the bar.
NUGGETS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 28 January 1888
Darwen v Everton
January 30 th 1888. The Liverpool Courier.
These teams met at Darwen on Saturday, but although the weather was all that could be desired the fixture aroused comparatively little local interest. Roach started for Everton, against a strong wind, and in a few minutes the ball was nicely worked into the Darwen quarters. Then a free kick was given against Everton, and J. Shorrock had a clear chance of scoring, but he hesitated, and the pressure was eased. Once more Darwen attacked, and secured a corner, but nothing resulted. A free kick for hands was given for the home team at the half-way flag, and Ireland sent in a grand shot. Howard Shorrock also sent in a clinking shot, which was nicely handed out by Smalley and only a corner resulted, which, however, proved fruitless. Heresabout Everton had a chance of scoring, but Eyton-Jones kicked the ball out. Then Shorrock saved at the expense of a corner, but the ball was got away, and worked into the Everton quarters. Not to be denied, Darwen continued to press, and from a bit of fine passing by Dimmock, and Marsden, Howard Shorrock sent in a shot, which striking the crossbar, bounding through, thus scoring the first point for the home team. The visitors restarted, and after a bit of fast play Goodall centred nicely, and Roach put the ball through, equalising the score. Some grand shots were sent in to the visitors goal, but Smalley proved equal to the occasion. Then he saved another shot by Dimmock at the expense of a corner, which however, was not improved upon. From hands, close to the Everton goalline, Holden scored goal No 2 for Darwen. Then, two minutes afterwards, Smith sent in a stinging shot, which beat Smalley, and notched the third goal for the home team. When the whistle blew for half-time the score stood –Darwen three, Everton one. After the resumption Darwen continued to press, and Holden sent in a good shot which only just went over the crossbar. Very soon afterwards a corner accrued to Darwen, but nothing resulted. Darwen still continued to press, and after a tight struggle Smith scored the fourth goal. Farmer made a good run up the Darwen left wing, but his shot went past the post. Everton began to press, and Holden had a grand shot to stop. From a centre by Fleming, Farmer scored another easy goal for the visitors. Darwen continued to press, and just before the whistle blew Smith added another goal for the home team, Darwen winning by five goals to two. Teams; - Everton; - Smalley goal; Dick and Fayer, backs; Jones, Nidd and Higgins, half-backs; Eyton-Jones Farmer, Roach, Goodall, and Fleming, forwards. Darwen; - Holden, goal; Ireland and Leach backs; Owen, Thornber, and Marsden half-backs; R. Dimmock, Howard Shorrock, J. C. Holden, Smith, and J. Shorrock, forwards.
Everton Reserves v Tranmere Rovers
The meeting of these teams took place at the Anfield enclosure on Saturday in the presence of close upon a thousand spectators. On the Evertonians kicking off downhill, with the sun in their eyes, they were drove on the defence, and after Joliffe had cleared one or two warmish shots the home custodian was beaten by D. Sheridan from the centre. Everton developed better combination on resuming and pressed for a time, during which the Rovers defence was very active, and allowed nothing serious than a few futile corners. Even play intervened, both custodian having some work to do, and then Everton equalised out of a passing run Gilder doing the needful. Between now and half time nothing further was scored, though Charteris and Sheridan shot well for their respective sides. On restarting the Rovers pressed heavily, the shots sent being good, but he opening was permitted by Joliffe and the backs. The Rovers maintained the attack, Costley, Oakes, and Jolliffe failing in the bulk of the clearing. Later on Morgan ran smartly down and centred, a running kick by McAfee being near scoring. Routledge also ran up well, and brought about a scrimmage but Jolliffe cleared well from the scrimmage, and then Everton indulged in a rush, the visitors custodian fisting out twice. The game eventually remained drawn –one goal each. Teams; - Tranmere Rovers; - H. Sheridan, goal; Bradfield and Littler, backs; Roberts, Beard, and Taylor,, half-backs; McAfee, D. Sheridan, Routledge, Morgan, and another forward. Everton; - Jolliffe, goal; Oakes and James, backs; T. Jones, F. Parry, and Costley, half-backs; Douglas, Crosbie, Fairish, Charteris, and Gilder, forwards.
EVERTON RESERVES V. TRANMERE ROVERS
January 30, 1888. The Liverpool Mercury
This match formed the attraction at Anfield on Saturday, and was witnessed by several hundred spectators. Everton opened play with the hill in their favour, but had the sun to contend against. The visitors soon got up to the home goal, and gave Joliffe several handfuls, which he attended to safely, but returning to the attack almost immediately. Tranmere scored from the foot of D. Sheridan, Everton at once rallied, and pressed for a time, only corners however, falling to their lot against the good defence. A spell of even play, during which both custodians were called up to use their prerogatives, culminated in favour of Everton, as on the forwards closing up in a good run Gilder took a pass and made the score even. The conspicuous items between now and the interval were clinking shots by Charteris and Sherdian for either side. Proceeding with the second half, the home goal at once became the scene of sustained interesting play; but Joliffe ably assisted by Costley, Oakes, and James, starved off the attack. At length Everton broke loose on the right, though not formidable; and then Morgan, who had repeatedly contributed fine dashing runs, got right down, his centre being charged just outside by McAfee. This was followed by a hot scrimmage, imitated by Routledge, Joliffe chucking aside cleverly. The visitors again attacked without effect, James this time being the chief defender. Just before the close Everton became aggressive, but nothing came of a corner and Charteris's shots, and when an interesting game terminated in a draw of 1 goal each, Everton were engaged in repelling the Cheshire men. Teams; Joliffe, goal;' Oakes and James, backs; T. Jones, F. Parry, ad Costley, half-backs; Douglas, Crosby, Farish, Charteris, and Gilder, forwards. Tranmere Rovers;- H. Sherdian, goal; Bradfield, and A. Littler, backs; McAfee, D. Sheridan, W. Routledge, Morgan, and another, forwards.
EVERTON V. DARWEN
January 30, 1888. The Liverpool Mercury
Played at Darwen, before 200 spectators. Neither team was thoroughly representative, the home team being without Strachan and the visitors with Dobson and Gibson. Everton kicked off against a strong and bitterly cold wind, and were at once placed on the defensive. Time after time was the leather sent in, but the defence remained impregnable until twenty-five minutes had elapsed, when Owen defeated Smalley. The visitors then woke up, and, dashing off, Roche equalised from a neat pass by Goodall. Darwen again took up the attack, and Holden scored their second goal, Smith following with a third. At the interval Everton were behind by three goals to one. Twenty minutes later Smith added a fourth point, and a few minutes later Fleming scored for Everton, while Holden afterwards added another goal for Darwen. Result- Darwen 5 goals; Everton 2, goals. Teams; Darwen; Holden, goal; Ireland and Leach, backs; Owen, Thornber, and Marsden, half-backs; B. Dimmock, H. Shorrock, J.C. Holden (Wigan), Smith, and J. Shorrock, forwards. Everton –Smalley, goal; Dick and Fayer, backs; Higgins, W. Jones and Nidd, half-backs; Fleming, Goodall, Roche, Farmer, and Eyton-Jones, forwards.
Notes on Football
Everton's ill-luck seems to cling to them most doggedly. Dobson has now entered the sick list, and with the captain (Gibson) and R. Jones also incapacitated, it was hardly to be expected that Everton would be able to again triumph over Darwen. The team that journeyed to Barley Bank was all right forward, as it was composed of Farmer, Goodall, Roche, Fleming and Eyton-Jones; but not so the backs for W,. Jones, Nidd, and Fayer, though useful, are scarcely class enough to battle such clubs as Darwen. Everton had the wind to contend with during the first half, but they did not allow Darwen to have matters all there own way even against this odds, as ends were changed with the score –Darwen 3, Everton 1. The second half was more even, but the visitors could only manage an additional goal, against two obtained by the home team, and were accordingly beaten by 5 to 2 –not an overwhelming disaster, all things considered. Everton Reserves were also in possession of headquarters, and had as opponents Tranmere Rovers. Everton were fortunate in getting something like a decent team together from various sources, with the result that an interesting but unexciting encounter terminated in a draw of one goal each. The visitors were pretty evenly balanced, Morgan, the Sheridans, and Routledge –especially the former –being the principal actors. Everton were strongest in the forward department, next to goal, for Jolliffe towards the close, when the Rovers were pressing persistently, did much to confine the score to an equality.
EVERTON 'WRECKED AT DARWEN.
Athletic News - Tuesday 31 January 1888
Poor Everton! A two to one or a three to two defeat is not so hard to bear, but when it comes to a licking of five goals to two, and that, too, at the hands of a club whom they have previously beaten, then the pill is, indeed, bitter to swallow. But what can a club do when there are two of its sturdiest players absent, such as Dobson and Gibson were and although one has to admit that these two could hardly have made three goals difference, yet I venture to say that the disparity between the teams would not have been so great. Then, again, Darwen were in demon form all along the line, and even had Everton placed their very best team in the field, they would, I think, have been defeated. Playing against the breeze in the first half, and having Old Sol staring right into their eyes, the visitors (the match was played on the Barley Bank Meadow) were for the most part acting on the defensive, and had it not been for the sterling work done by Smalley, in goal, and Dick, at back, numerous goals would have been scored. Corners innumerable tell to the latter, and eventually their unceasing efforts were rewarded by Owen tipping the leather through the posts and scoring the first point. The attack was still kept up, but no further disaster resulted, and the pressure being relieved, the Everton forwards raced off to the Darwen end, and, after some exciting scrummaging, Roche equalized. This success his inspired the visitors, and again they attacked, only, however, to be forced back empty-handed, and their own fortress assailed. The Darwen forwards played a grand game, and, despite the stubborn defence they had to contend against, they twice sent the ball flying past Smalley, holding a substantial lead of three to one at the interval. With their backs to the wind, it was thought Everton would soon pull up in the second half, and the way they started off augured well for those expectations. The Darwen backs were not to be caught napping, though, and repulsed their opponents in fine style, transferring play to the latter’s end in double quick style. Here Smith added a fourth goal and soon afterwards Fleming replied with one for his side. The home team once more took up the running, and before the finish gained another point, eventually winning as above stated. There is no doubt victory rested with the better team, the defence and combination of the winners being far superior to that of their opponents. The Evertonians appeared to be out of form altogether, and it is a long time since they played a worse game or appeared to greater disadvantage. Since their defeat by Accrington, the camp of Darwen has been cast in gloom, but their triumph over Everton has dispelled the clouds, and joy once more reigns supreme in the “Peaceful Valley.”
EVERTON RESERVE DRAW WITH TRANMERE ROVERS
Athletic News - Tuesday 31 January 1888
The Everton ground was monopolized by the Reserves and Tranmere Rovers, and a very even fight they made. The visitors were the first to be aggressive and scored early, but this was set off by Everton before half-time. On changing ends Tranmere pressed almost uninterruptedly without finding a flaw in the defence of Joliffe and the backs and a quiet, level game ended in a draw of a goal each.