EVERTON 2 THIRD LANARK 2
January 2 1889. The Liverpool Courier
Continuing their holiday tour the 3 rd Lanark traveled out from Manchester and opposed Everton at Anfield enclosure yesterday. A thick of enveloped the ground, which the recent frost had rendered hard and extremely dangerous. It was nearly half-an-hour past the advertised time when Milward on behalf of the homesters placed his foot to the ball, and within a couple of minutes from the start Marshall had scored for the visiting team. The restart was followed by another attack, but although danger threatened the home quarters were cleared, and Farmer and Watson, took in the ball from midfield, and gave Brown a spendid chance on the left of goal which to the disappointment of the home supporters ended in failure, the ball being shot barely a couple of feet outside the post. Undismayed by this abortive attempt the Evertonians ranged themselves in front of the Lanark citadel, and during a hot melee Davies headed in only to find Downie not-out consummate skill. For some time afterwards Everton continued to have the best of the play, Milward at this time being one of the most conspicuous of the players. At length the siege was raised, and on a return to the lower ground Jas Oswald sorley tested the defensive powers of Joliffe who, however kicked away and averted a second disaster. With the ball again in midfield, Farmer took a free kick for hands and in close following Milward and Watson were conspicuous in good play. The visiting centre and right relieved admirably where upon Chadwick and Brown inaugurated a reversal of positions, and Dobson having beaten Marshall Chadwick and Milward rushed up. Downie momentarily repelled the attack, which however was renewed, and a moment later Milward equalised amidst the enthusiastic plaudits of the crowd there being at this time about 6,000 persons present. Desultory play ensued, during which the players were partially obscured by the fog. Watson made a temporary raid, which being repelled the Volunteers were again skirmishing vigorously on the lower ground. At length Ross missed his kick and taking full advantage of the centre setups Oswald rushed up and beat Joliffe for the second time. Closely following the re-start Chadwick sent in a neat shot, which Rae repelled. Again the sphere was brought up, only however, to be shot outside. The Scottish right-Marshall and John Oswald-now contributed neat passing play, the result of which was that the home lines were again beleagued. With relief at hand the ball was again traveled upfield, when Brown essayed a shot which was headed safety away. Soon afterwards Ross was favored with a free kick, and from a resulting corner Everton were within an ace of scoring. From now to half-time the play was of a fairly even character, and when the official whistle was blown for change of ends, the score stood, 3 rd Lanark 2 goals, Everton 1 goal. James Oswald having resumed, the ball for a time was gyrating dangerous near the visitor's posts. At last the sphere came bounding through the fog to misfield false criss of ‘'goal'' having previously been raised. Again nothing could be seen of the players until from a free kick the play was momentarily located in the centre of the field. Everton were now having much the best of the game, the Visitors indeed not having crossed the dividing line since the change of ends. A dark mass was now seen surging through the fog, which at this time was so dense that neither goal could be seen; but although a footing in the home half was gained, the raid was quickly repulsed and a moment later a tremendous shout revealed the fact that Everton had scored a second gaol and qeualised the score. Now that the teams were on equal terms the play became more vigorous even than before. Suddenly the misty canopy was raised and the 3 rd Lanark were occupying the higher ground. Joliffe having kicked out in front of goal, Holt made a thoroughly antistic run, and, aided by Davies and Watson on the right the visitors quarters again became the venue of play. Brown centred to Davies who headed in grandly where upon Downie fisted out in admirable style and for a time more even play prevailed. For a moment the sphere was at the Everton corner, and danger being cleared, Holt contributed an additional fine piece of play. Still the men of the Lanark pressed on, and after a grand dribble James Oswald shot across the goalmouth,, and thus a grand of advantage was lost. Johnson however, returned with the ball, but fell on the frozen ground. Just when success seemed to be within reach. The Evertonians, and especially Joliffe, were having an anxious time of it until the tension was eased by means of a kick from the front of goal. Davies now made a clinking run down the right, which was responded to by a most brilliant run by Johnson on the right which culminated in a free kick for Lanark in front of goal. Nothing accured, however, but although a moment later Downie was sorley tried, his charge remained intact. A grand passing movement on the part of James Oswald, Johnson, and Hannah towards the close of the game jeopardized the home goal, which however, was promptly relieved and as the whistle was shortly, afterwards blown a well contested and most amicable game was brought to a close, the result being a draw of two goals each. Teams; Everton:- Joliffe goals Ross (captain) and Dobson, backs, Weir, Holt, and Farmer. Hal-backs Watson Davies Milward Chadwick, and Brown forwards. 3 rd Lanark:- Downie, goal, Fairweather, and Rae,, backs,, McFarlane, Ferguson, and Thompson, half-backs, Oswald (t), Oseald (John), Hannan, Marshall, and Johnson, forwards.
EVERTON 2 CAMBUSLANG 1
January 3 1889. The Liverpool Courier
The third match of the latter's English holiday tour was played on the Anfield enclosure yesterday. The weather was again very foggy, and of course greatly millicated against accuracy of play. The visitors were strongly represented, whilst the homesters also had a full eleven for the occasion of the two previous matches of the tour, the scotchmen had won one (Preston North End), and lost one 9Bolton Wanderers) whilst on New Year's day, Everton played drawn game with the 3 rd Lanark R.V. thus the fixture proved to be an interesting one, and when the team. Faced there would be about 2,500 persons present. Millward kicked off on behalf of Everton, whose forwards were pulled up by Downes, and the Scotch van dashed down to the Everton goal. A throw-in accrued to the visitors near the corner and the home citadel was seriously menaced till relief came through the ball being shot over the line by H.Gourlay, Neat passing by Chadwick and Angus was spoiled by Russell, and Camburslang again assumed an aggressive attitude, but again failure attended the shot at goal. A free kick to Everton in the centre was taken by Ross, Davies and Watson were prominent on the right but were promptly robbed by Russell, who dribbled down the centre. Ross was passed, and the Everton goal looked like being captured. The Latter, however, rushed back, and after some brilliant tackling secured the ball, and the home forwards were again swarming round the scotch goal, Milward here compelled Downs to handle. The Cambuslang custodian threw sharply out, but Angus secured the ball and shot outside the posts. From the kick out of goal, the ‘'Scots'' claimed a free kick in the Everton half and this being granted them, hot play ensued round the home posts. The fog here became very dense and it was with difficulty that the movements of the players could be followed. Cambuslang, however, forced a couple of corner, the first of which went outside whilst the second was headed away by Sugg. Angus dribbled well on the Everton left but kicked too far ahead and Fryers got the ball away. Joliffe was forced to handle at the other end. The venue of play, however, was quickly removed to the upper ground, and Angus shot in capital style, the ball just passing outside the posts. Everton were having by far the best of the game and expert for an occasional breakaway by the visitors forwards were pinned within their own quarters. After several unsuccessful attacks on the Scotch goal. Chadwick shot the sphere past Downs this feat being greeted with encouraging cheers by the home partners. Ross foiled several attempts to score by the Cambuslang right wing, who now became troublesome, and after a run down by the home forwards the some was equalised. From the centre kick, Chadwick, Angus and Farmer showed good points for Everton but they were met by the sterling defence of the Scotch backs, who kicked and tackled capitally. A combined run by the Everton left brought dangerous the visitors goal, but the latter put the leather over the line. Everton still pressed, but a long kick by Gournley took hostilities to the home citadel, where a corner kick was conceded the visitors this proved futile, as did a quick shot by Buchanan. A run down the field by the Everton forwards, met with no better success, but a few minutes later loud cheers proclaimed the fact that Milward had placed the homesters ahead- doing the trick from a pass by Watson. Cambuslang next showed dangerous tackles, Sugg kicking out of goal. The Visitors, however, returned, but half-time was called with the score:- Everton two goals, Camsbuslang 1 goal. Caldon re-started the ball on behalf of Cambuslang, but Davies securing possession of the sphere, rushed down the field. Unfortunately, however, he kicked two far ahead, and the ball rolled harmlessly over the line. A free kick accurued to the Scotchmen from ‘'hands'' off Holt, and the ball being well placed, hot play ensued in the home half, Joliffe having to hit away a shot from the foot of Prendeleitch. Dobson further removed the danger, and the Everton forwards crossed the half-way line. They were driven back however, and Play again raged in the Everton quarters. Holt attempted to clear, but was prevented by Hendry holding him round the back. Farmer, however, was successful in clearing, and the forward rank of Everton menaced the Cambuslang goal. A corner resulted, from which Everton had extremely hard line in not scoring, Downes clearing in the nick of time. Play was suspended owing to a slight accident to Davis who however, resumed a few minutes later. Play was still down at the Cambuslang goal, but no impression could be made on the Scotch defence. Low and Prindsleith ran nicely along the Cambuslang left wing the latter sending in a swift shot which Ross repelled in capital style Angus replied on behalf of Everton, but nothing accrued. An attack by the homesters was cleared by means of a free kick. Dobson replied by a huge punt, but the visitors were not to be stalled off, and the left wing again broke away. This was followed by extremely neat passing by the Cambuslang forwards, Ross meeting them in grand style. Low returned but shot yards wide of the posts. Undaunted by this the Scots returned, and looked like equaslising being prevented however, by the defence of Ross Joliffe, and Dobson. The latter took a free kick for the home team, who attacked the Cambuslang goal strongly, the ball being shot over the line. Milward was next seen dashing down the centre with the ball at his toes. Downs robbing him in the nick of time. Everton, however, kept up the pressure, and a free kick was awarded them in the Cambuslang half. Ross took the kick and sent the ball through the visitors posts. The homesters claimed for a goal, but as the ball had not touched any of the players during its flight the point were disallowed. Cambuslang next assumed an aggressive attitude and siege was laid to the home goal. In their attempt to score they were fouled by Ross and Joliffe and the home van were next attacking in hot style. Gourlay relieved, but Dobson returned the ball with a nicely judged kick. A free kick to Everton right in front of the Cambuslanf ‘'sticks'' was taken by Dobson, this being followed by a couple of corners, both of which were got safely away. Holt tried a long shot from the centre right off the touch line Downs relieving in good style. The whistle now blew for a cessation of hostilities Everton having won by two goals to one. Teams; Cambuslang:- Dunn, goal, Downs, and Foyets, backs, Hendry, Gourlay (j), and Russell, half-backs, Low, Prendeleith Caldow, Groulay (h), and Buchanan forwards. Everton:- Joliffe goals, Dobson, and Ross (captain), Holt, Sugg, and Farmer half-backs, Watson, Milward, Angus, Davis, and Chadwick, forwards.
LIVERPUDLIANA BY RICHARD SAMUEL
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 05 January 1889
AT EVERTON
Everton’s first Scotch match was with Third Lanark on New Year’s Day, and a very fine exciting tussle it proved. The visitors came to Anfield fresh from a defeat at newton Heath, and their form against Everton was all against the correctness of such form. They left behind them the impression that they are a grand team right through, and Everton did well to come out of the engagement undefeated. With the exception of Joliffe for Smalley and the trail of Milward in the centre, the Everton team was the strongest possible, and the Third were very powerfully represented. Their forwards were soon seen to be a formidable quintette, and before the game was five minutes old Marshall had scored a fine goal. For a long time a very keen struggle was waged, and it looked odds on the Lanark men maintaining their lead. Milward, however, got a good goal from a melee near Downie. Although Hannah was said by some of the compatriots to be somewhat off colour, he made some pretty play on the left, and after ross had been beaten James Oswald scored with a fast shot-quite beyond the capacity of Joliffe to deal with. In the second half, play was undistinguishable for quite thirty minutes, and during the whole of this time the ball never went beyond the centre line into Everton quarters. Play under the circumstances was a farce, and Everton equalized; how I can say. Immediately, the mist vanished, with a hiddenness quite remarkable, and the rest of the game was of the most interesting description. The Everton forwards were rarely dangerous again, whereas some superb individual outbursts and grand combined runs were made by the visitors. No score was made, however, and the match remained drawn-two all, a precisely similar result to that which attended the game between Bootle and Lanark on the previous New Year’s Day. Ross was not inform on this occasion, Dobson and Holt being the best of the defenders and the home forwards were a lot inferior to those of the Scotchmen.
A WIN AGAINST CAMBUSLANG
The last of the Scotch matches, on Wednesday, was a really good one, and Everton scored a success by two goals to one. The good form previously shown by the Cambuslang men had rendered their appearance at Everton interesting, but they were mot such a clever lot as the 3rd Lanark, especially forward. Everton had to good deal the best of matters, and Ross made ample demands for his shortcomings of the previous day with a fine exhibition.
FOG AND MUD AT EVERTON
STILL UNHAPPY AWAY
After the storm, which in this case means the tussle between Everton and Bootle, there was not only a great calm, but apparently an unaccountable falling off in energy somewhere, as Everton had to go to Accrington short-handed. Holt was on the sick list, Farmer was playing for the Reserve, and through some bungling Albert Chadwick was on the stand looking on instead of being away at Accrington. Smalley is still suffering from his collision with Dewhurst at Preston. Altogether the position the of “powers that be” cannot be a happy one. A licking at Accrington was looked for, yet it ought not to have been so heavy, and Dobson is considerably to blame for getting out of his place, as this helped the disaster not a little.
THE THIRD LANARK
The visit of the celebrated Volunteer team was looked forward to with considerable interest, and although the weather was wholly against the chances of either a good game or a good gate, we had both. Without any disparagement to other good clubs which have figured on this ground, I think I am safe in saying that a better exposition of the game has never been witnessed this season, and Everton may well clap themselves on the back after making a draw of it. When the game started it was very foggy and the ground muddy, but the boys reveled in it, and it was a caution to see the way the ball danced backwards and forwards, at one tune between the backs and halves, and then the forwards, so that there was no dallying or sparring for wind. On the game went ding-dong right to the end. Brown missed a fine opening early in the game, and then Joliffe, instead of catching the ball when Marshall shot in, made a tremendous blow at it, and instead of going half-way up the field it slipped through his goal. Moral: Don’t trust to wet balls going true. Weir was not so reliable as usual. Holt was like a Will-o’the-wisp. The forwards passed for a wonder, and Millward appeared to advantage in the centre. The way in which he rushed the first goal was exceptionally good. The fog lifted towards the close and the game was contested all the more warmly, but in the very best of spirits, as was evinced on one occasion when Holt and an opponent came a cropper. They assisted each other, not only to rise, but to clean the mud off one another, to the great amusement of the spectators. A draw represented the result in play.
CAMBUSLANG
We hoped for better things for the following day, when the men of Cambuslang were the visitors; but no, the fog was worse, and the ground more sloppy. Being an off-day, the attendance was very meagre when the kick-off took place, and after that time there was no chance of seeing whether there was any improvement. For a short time the players were all visible, especially when from a big return by Ross, Chadwick scored the first goal. The visitors were not long before they equalized, but doubts rested in their own minds as to who performed the trick. My impression was that it came from Buchanan. Nothing further occurred until close on half-time, when Farmer tried a long drop. Grey kicked out, and Chadwick returned hotly. Again the ball was observed coming out, but a figure was seen to dash forward, and from the wild shout which followed it was assumed that another goal was scored, and so it proved. The second half was begun with the fog worse than ever. A few forms could be seen rushing along, and then a big shout of” O-h!” as the goal escaped narrowly. The spectators at either end cheered lustily when the players came within sight, as it was undoubtedly a rare treat. In spite this state of affairs I could occasionally catch glimpses of good play by Downs, Russell, Foyers, Buchanan and Caldon on the one side, and Holt, Sugg, Ross, and several of the forwards on the other. At length we heard the whistle sound near the visitors’ goal. There was a pause, Sugg was noticed making a move, and then a tremendous cheer announced another goal. But no, The referee Mr. Mclntyre—for some reason, which was very “foggy,'' disallowed the point. It was thus. Sugg kicked forward to Ross who sent the ball through with such speed that the goalkeeper had not even a glance at it. I understand that “Mac” expressed his regret afterwards, but it might have lost Everton a well won game.
FROM OUR ACCRINGTON INKSTAND
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 05 January 1889
REDS IN FORM
Much to speak about this week and little room, I guess, to do it in, so I shall have to pack up my remarks in the proverbial nutshell. Well, to start off with, we may have just cause for being a bit high, seeing that the Reds have bene working so well during the holidays- no joke. All wins, no blanks- not even the customary draw, as of yore, and sixteen goals to three. Play up, old firm! Of course there was nothing better on for Saturday than returning the compliments of the League season to the bounders of Anfield-road. What was wanted came off, and Everton were shown the way to the seventh-place. It was very fortunate for them that they were able to pick up Harry Parkinson in lieu of the missing eleventh member of their flock, or the letting down would have been accomplished with much more ceremony than was the case. However, a win of three to one for the Reds was satisfactory enough in itself that it was a win, and that arrears from last September were duly wiped off, and don’t you forget, by-the-bye, that we are out of N0.7 purgatory, for a time. There was not a very elaborate display. For the greater part the game was made up of Accrington’s persistent attack and Ross & Co’s argument to the contrary. With four other forwards of the stamp of Watson, Everton might have done good business. They were lucky to get off with as little as they did. There seemed a peculiar fate hanging over most of the shots which were intended for Joliffe’s goal, and a still more peculiar fate which provided the Liverpudlians with so many goalkeepers, when there was any fighting at close quarters. Eh, what? No, I don’t say that anyone knocked the ball back when it was going through, only two of Accrington’s goals were obtained from free kicks almost under the cross bar.
EVERTON V. BLACKBURN ROVERS. '
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 05 January 1889
This return League fixture came off at Everton today in the presence of 6,000 spectators. Everton: Joliffe goal; Dobson and Ross, backs; Weir, Farmer, and Holt, half-backs; Brown, Watson, Milward, Chadwick, and Angus, forwards. Blackburn Rovers: McOwen, goal; James Southworth and Forbes, backs; Douglas, Almond, and Forrest, half-backs ; Cronshaw, Walton, John Southworth, Whittaker and Townley, forwards. Referee Mr. Hugh Mclntyre.
Millward kicked off, and the Rovers left made demonstration on their wing. Everton returned the play very earnestly, and then the Rovers burst through, futile attempt to lower the Everton colours Milward was observed dashing along, but his career was cut short by Forbes. The Everton right now got past Forbes, and registered their first corner, but this brought no advantage. Millward then sent to the left, Chadwick to Angus, and the latter gave McOwen his first handful. Milward next shot in hard, and McOwen scooped the ball scooped the ball out, but Watson dashed it through after 20 minutes’ play. From the kick-off play became very lively. The Rovers experienced hard lines, the ball struck the at bar, and from the corner which followed a severe scrimmage ensued in the Everton goalmouth. Ross cleared, and for a time the men were seen fitting about like phantoms. Townley got up on the left, but the ball was repelled, and at the end of thirty-five minutes Mr. McIntyre blew for half-time. Everton crossed over leading by one to nil, and Southworth kicked off. The Rovers now began to press, and Joliffe saved three shots in quick succession, a corner only being the result. This was cleared, and the Everton left came well up. Brown sent in a beauty from the right, which McOwen cleverly saved. More even play followed, and then Joliffe save magnificently, but it was impossible to see who sent in the shot. Everton spurted up, and Watson sent in a clinker, but again the Rovers’ custodian was equal to the occasion and Townley darted back. From a pass by Chadwick, Milward shot hard, but it was well saved. The Rovers then, fed by Forbes Douglas who had gone full back, made a severe onslaught on the home goal, but again Joliffe was to the fore. McOwen saved from Chadwick but time arrived with Everton 1`, Rovers 0.
Final Result; Everton 1, Blackburn Rovers 0.
THE FOG FIEND AT EVERTON
By Grumbler
The “Happy New Year” of Grace 1889 don’t seem to want to develop too quickly. Up to now there has been a misty obscurity about the prospect that puts a salutary check on undue hilarity. It is said that “None but the brave deserve the fair.” Well, there must be a lot of brave men Everton way when they turn out five or six thousand strong to stand an hour and a half with cold feet, or to sit a similar period thawing a frost-strewed form- as the case may be –simply with the object of peering half-way across a field at the spectacle of some twenty-two misty forms fitting about in chase of a leather ball. However, as they seem to enjoy it, I suppose I oughtn’t to grumble, but rather to accept with what resignation I may the symptoms of incipient rheumatism creeping up the small of my back, whilst the fast-melting frost trickles slowly between my legs and form a little skating rink at my feet. If it were not for the gate, and the difficulty of dealing with those obstinate individuals who persist in having what they doubtless regard as “value for their money,” I should be an advocate for the abandonment of all football under the atmospheric conditions that resigned today, but as it is I suppose I must adjust my spectacles, attempt to grab a pencil and record whatever comes within visual range- which, I confess, isn’t much. To start with- or rather before the start-Nick Ross lands up to the press box with the intelligence, that by mutual agreement this is not to be regarded as a League match proper, that in fact a draw has been arranged, and that the spectators will accordingly be indulged with an “exhibition” game. This knocks the remaining stuffing out of the proceedings, and excitement goes down, in accord with the weather to zero. I confess to a slight flutter of pleasure when the further news reaches us that hostilities will be confined to thirty-five minutes each way. There is a late commencement, and when Milward kicks off the goal posts are barely visible from the stand, whilst the ground presents a variegated panorama of a frost-tipped fringe of grass with a centre of brown, liberally bestrewed with sand. The Rovers’ left are soon away in possession of the ball, and Joliffe makes a neat save. As the attack is renewed, there are visions of a repetition of the previous experience against the Rovers when the Blackburnians won by three goals to nil. The difficulty of descrying “who’s who” in no way lessens, and we sign for the fulfilment of Mr. Nisbet’s brilliant suggestion that a phosphorescent ball should be employed. The dangerous conditions of the ground in no way seems to appeal the players, who charge and tackle with a freedom that is unpleasantly suggestive of cracked bones. The first real attempt to lower the Rovers’ colours was made by Chadwick, who, trusting to luck and the fog tries a long shot which, however, is not sufficiently well-directed. This is followed by a corner to Everton, of which nothing came, and Angus next ran in with a good one. Egerton continue to be busy until the lapse of twenty minutes, when McOwen after throwing out an awkward one from the left falls to negotiate a return from Watson, whose success is greeted with a resounding cheer. The same player nearly succeeds in repeating his success, and play becomes a bit faster, the falls considering the slippery surface singularly few and far between. It is now the Rovers turn and for the remainder of that half they make strenuous efforts to knock off their opponents lead. Being well fed by Forest Townley on the outside left gives Dobson a lot of trouble, as George doesn’t move at all freely, and frequently mis-kicks. The elather is again and again forced over the Everton lines, and Joliffe effects a grand save from an attack by Whittaker. Matters are, however, destined to remain unaltered, and at the end of the thirty-five Everton are still in possession of their leading goal. The fog is still stationary when the men cross over, and the Rovers at once force the pace, the right wing becoming dangerous Joliffe saves, and a second crashing shot all but scores, the ball travelling the least bit wide. Walton now makes it hot for the custodian, who twice throws out amid applause. There is now some stiff scrimmaging and Everton breaking through Brown is conspicuous for a fine attempt to improve the Evertonian position. Milward, who has been well to the fore all through, fails to quite get round a pass from Angus, and the ball travels swifty right across the Rovers’ goal. This series of attacks about equalizes the advantages which the Rovers possessed in the early part of the half, and it is evident there will not be very much in the game at the finish. It is, however, time to investigate the “Mysteries of a Hansom Cab,” and the temperature of the L and Y foot-warmers and for the final score please consult my confrere above.
NUGGETS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 05 January 1889
EVERTON REVIEW
January 5 1888. The Liverpool Courier
Everton were most unfortunate in meeting Accrington in the League fixture minus Farmer and Holt, the former of whom oddly missed his train so that the team had to make the journay with only ten men. A useful recruit, however, was picked up on the way in the person of Parkinson, of Bell's Temperance, a promising Youth, who played a capital game, and was party the means of Everton's scoring the only goal. Turning to the game, the play during the first half was of a grand character, Chadwick, Ross, Parkinson, Brown, and Watson for Everton and Brand (who dribbled magnificently) Howarth and Lofthouse for the ‘'Reds'' all deserving credit for their heroics efforts. Watson scored for Everton and from hands of Ross Accrington equalised the score, at the interval standing one goal each. The second half,, was also well contested, the Accringtonians, in particular, playing grandly, Dobson and Ross put in some fine back play for the Evertonians, notwithstanding which Accrington scored twice Howarth successfully with a long shot Everton failed to get on even terms, and were defeated by three goals to one. The match between the Reserves of Everton and Bootle did not produce edifying display, but was on the contrary voted one of the worst games ever played at the Anfield enclosure,, Certainly Everton were inadequately represented, and although the Bootle second string is not so strong as it was a season ago, a fair chance was presented of lowering the colours of the rival club after a lot of scrambling play each side scored a goal, and as in the last of the games between the senior teams the match remained drawn.
EVERTON 1 BLACKBURN ROVERS 0
January 7 1889. The Liverpool Courier
The return League contest between the above clubs took on the Anfield ground on Saturday. An Attendance of fully 6,000 spectators testified to the immense popularity of the engagement. A good deal of curiosity was evinced as to the composition of the Rovers teams owing to their having to play off their Lancashire Cup tie but when the players put in an appearance it was noticed that the Rovers were fully repreented. The recent frost had made the ground somewhat dangerous for the players. At the time of starting the ground was enveloped in very thick fog. At 2-20 Southworth having been successful in the spin of the coin, Milward kicked off and immediately the Rovers became aggressive. Joliffe having to clear from Townsley. A long punt by Ross gave Everton relief. Angus and Chadwick forced the play on the left the ball going outside. From the kick out J.Southworth ran up the centre ‘'Hands'' against Holt gave the Rovers a chance, Dobson heading clear. Brown and Watson with a grand passing run caused Forbes to concede a corner. The ball was nicely cleared by Almond after to had struck the upright, Milward was noticeable with a fine shot, which McCowan fisted out. A grand run by Whitaker put the Rovers on the aggressive Weir kicking clear. The Rovers left still pressed, until Farmer passed to the left, and from a pass by Angus, Brown kicked outside. From the kick-out the home forwards got well in the Rovers quarters, where Milward shot in, McCowan clearing. The ball was met by Watson, who scored 15 minutes from the start. The spectators greeted this success with turmeniuos applause. The Rovers left forced play, Dobson heading clear. From a throw in by Douglas the Rovers took a foul in the goalmouth. Ross working the ball clear with some fine tackling. Whittaker and Townley ran up the left, J.southworth missing a grand chance by kicking outside. A throw by Farmer enabled Chadwick to break away, Forbes robbing him as a dangerous moment. Half-time Everton 1; Rovers 0. After the usual interval Southworth put the sphere in motion, the fog being heavier than before. Townley immediately put in a screw shot which Joliffe cleared. The Rovers took a couple of corners that were well cleared by the Everton defence. A good bit of passing by the Everton forwards removed the venue to the other end, where Southworth kicked clear. Watson now forced his way up the right . farmer relieving him and passing to Watson, who put in a stringing shot, which McCowan again cleared. Everton kept up a persistent attack, McCowan stopping shots from Angus and Milward. By good passing the Rovers again paid Joliffe a visit, a good shot from Douglas going over the bar. From midfield Milward had a magnificent forward movement Watson finishing with a grand shot. Which was well charged by Southworth in a marvelous manner. The Rovers attack on the left, Ross and Weir clearing their lines with some fine kicking. Chadwick got possession in the Rovers quarters and passing to Angus he again shot in, Southworth clearing. The Rovers getting into line again Everton were pressed, Ross kicking clear. Chadwick spinted up the left and passing across the goalmouth, Forbes kicked out. Turner renewed the attack the ball going over the bar. The Rovers rights was broke away but could not break through the Everton defence. The home team brought the ball into midfield, when the official whistles sound. Result Everton 1 ; Rovers o.
Previous to the engagement of the match it was decided that owing to the condition of the ground and fog that whatever the result might be match to deferred a draw and count accordingly. Teams; Blackburn Rovers:- McCowan,, goal Southworth, and Forbes backs, Douglas, Almond, and Forrest half-backs, Douglas, Watson Southworth (j) (captain), Whittaker, and Townley, forwards. Everton:- Joliffe, goal, Ross (captain) and Dobson backs, Farmer, Holt and Weir, half-backs, Angus, Chadwick, Milward, Watson, and Brown forwards.
SOUTHPORT OLD BOYS 2 EVERTON RESERVES 1
January 7 1889. The Liverpool Courier
Played at Southport on Saturday before a good attendance of spectators. A dense fog extended the field, so that it was with the utmost difficulty that either the players or the ball could be distinguished. In addition to this, owing to the recent from,, the ground was rendered very hard and slippery making it dangerous and uncomfortable for the players and preventing them from giving an good exhibition as they otherwise would have done. A start was effected about 3-30 by the home team kicking off. Everton having the slight wind at once assumed the aggressive and experienced hard lines on several occasions. About ten minutes from the commencement Smith scored for the Old Boys with a spendid screw shot and his effect was greeted with a loud shout of approval from the Old Boys supporters. This reverse seemed to awaken the Evertonians somewhat and they went to work with renewed vigour but the defensive tactics of the Old Boys back division nullified their efforts, and several corners fell to the visitors, but nothing resulted there from, and half-time arrived with the score:- Old Boys 1 goal, Everton nil. In the second half the visitors assumed the offensive, and a smart dribble on the part of their forwards ended in a goal being scored after the kick off. The game was contested on the most even terms until with three minutes of time when Dutton the centre-forward for the Old Boys shot another goal. The Evertonians on the plea of off-side disputed this, but the referee allowed the point. Everton then left the field. Final result Old Boys 2 goals, Everton 1 Reserves 1 goal.
LIVERPOOL AND DISTRICT COMMENTS
Athletic News - Monday 07 January 1889
By The Loiterer
THE EVERTON BILL OF FARE
The match Everton v. 3rd Lanark deservedly stands at the top of the tree as an exposition of the Association game. The Volunteers came with a great reputation, and they worthily upheld the estimation formed of them by the Scotch critics. They played a rare good passing game, and it was backed up by sound defence. Everton’s display was equally good, and it is very questionable whether they have been seen to such advantage this season, and a draw was a fitting conclusion of the match. In their match with Cambusland, Everton were more successful, as, after an even game, they won by two goals to one. The visitors full backs and the left-wing played a grand game, and foremost amongst the home team was Frank Sugg. He played centre half-back, and did any quantity of work, and did it well, too.
THE ROVERS AT ANFIELD-GOOD OLD FOG.
Notwithstanding the disagreeable weather, between 5,000 and 6,000 spectators turned up to see the League match with Blackburn Rovers. Taking into consideration the fog and the dangerous state of the ground, the captains agreed to consider the match a draw. Under what rule they acted was not very clear, but I guess if the League objects to the arrangement the Rovers won't mind playing another game, providing they can have share of the “dibs” Joliffe soon had to handle a shot by Townley, and, after a spell of even play, the home team pressed and earned several corners. These were successfully negotiated, but the home team again came up, and, after McOwen had thrown out, Watson scored for Everton. Up to half time play was pretty even, and both goalkeepers had to save.
On resuming, the Rovers were the first to show up, but Joliffe soon demonstrated that he was in his best humour, and knocked out several shots in good style. Eventually the siege was raised, and the home lot made off to the other end, where Angus had a chance, as McOwen was down, but his shot was wide: and a little later Chadwick was equally faulty when in a good position. A lot of the play was now on the east side, but owing to the fog not much of the game could be seen, though Townley seemed to make several good spurts, and the home goal was in danger several times. The defence, however, could not be broken, and a well-contested game ended in Everton scoring one goal to nil.
In view of the decision to call the game a draw whatever was scored, it would hardly be fair to severely criticize any of the players. Joliffe kept goal very well, and as he managed to have a clean sheet no one has any right to grumble. Both Ross and Dobson played a good game in the slippery ground, Dobson occasionally infusing some vigour in his tackling. Holt and Weir were ahead of Farmer at half-back, and Millwood did as well as any of the forwards. Chadwick worked hard, but scarcely fed Angus at all, during the second half at any rate. This is inexcusable, as Angus, if he is not over-brilliant in his play, is at all events generally in his place, and, moreover, is a very awkward customer to deal with; but he had seldom the opportunity of shining. Brown and Watson, on the right, did some good work now and again, but Forbes was too clever for them.
McOwen did very well in goal for the Rovers, and I am sorry he had to vacate his post through injuries. Forbes was decidedly better than Southworth at full back, the latter apparently not caring to risk anything on the hard ground. All the halves did their work neatly, Almond, perhaps, showing up best. The forwards possess a lot of speed, and they were quick on the ball, but I hardly think we saw them at their best, as several appeared to fight shy of a charge, and I trust their next visit will be favored with something likes decent weather.
NOTES
People were not a little mixed as to how they must look upon the result of the Everton v. Rovers return League match. As the referee proclaimed it a draw for a start the fairest course to adopt is to credit both clubs with one point, according to the rule of counting. If this is done the Rovers are still one ahead of the Albion. On the other hand, if Everton are given a win, as per result, the present holders and the ex-holders of the F.A Cup are on the same level, Perhaps the question will have to be settled by the League themselves.
Mr. Hugh McIntyre seems to have become a permanent institution at Anfield-road. He has officiated in the whole of the Everton New Years fixtures, so that by this time the old warrior should be pretty well qualified for the very invidious post of referee.
The semi-final for the Lancashire Cup will not be so uninteresting after all if the Rovers can scrape through, for Everton will be able to play a fairly strong team, and either Accrington or Halliwell will provide a good match for someone. Haydock enters this stage of the competition for the first time, as well as Everton, who have relied upon their second string all through the piece.
It would seem that the fame of A. Brady, of Burnley, had reached Walsall. When the Walsall players reached Turf Moor, one of their number, so it is stated, began to make acquisition to the Burnley ranks- as to what kind of a man he was, where he played, &c. The person to whom these questions were addressed thought proper to misinform the visitor, with the result that visitors’ forwards paid especial attention to the one pointed out, but they were on the wrong track, and it was not until the real Brady notched the second goal that they were undeceived, and then because one of the spectators happened to cry, “Well done, Brady,” or something to that effect. It was noticed that subsequently young Brady did not show up quite so strongly as before.
LIVERPUDLTANA ; BY RICHARD SAMUEL
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 12 January 1889
LEAGUE OR NON-LEAGUE MATCH
The circumstances attending the meeting of Everton and Blackburn Rovers were miserable in the extreme; in fact, such as to take all interest in the sport away, even from a game of such momentous issue to Evertonians. Everton have yet to play five League matches, one each with North End, West Bromwich Albion, and Stoke, and a couple with Wolverhampton Wanderers. They should beat Stoke today at Anfield-road, but the other four games will be a severe test, and success in any is problematical. There is this much in favour of the Liverpool lot; only one match is an out one, and no club in the League has yet lowered the Everton colours at Anfield-road. The Rovers essayed the task but failed on Saturday, although Everton’s success was overshadowed by reason of the pre-arranged draw. The teams were well advised in avoiding a heated struggle on the hard ground, but the question of counting points will have to be reserved for settlement by the League. It is scarcely likely that the others members of the League will consent to each of the contestants counting one point. The question of position is so important that some other solution will most likely be sought. The most just one would be to have the game replayed; another suggestion is to declare the game void; so far as counting of points goes; but this is as manifestly unfair to Everton and the Rovers, as the division of points is to be others. The only fair course, in my opinion, is to replay the game at Everton on the half-gate principle.
SOME ACCOUNT OF THE PLAY
The Rovers were short of Arthur, Beresford, and Fecitt, and Everton were without Smalley’s help, and as Davies failed to turn up, Brown was impressed into the service of the home side. Of course, this does not have regard to the absence of Waugh and Costley, two very useful men, whose services Everton have sadly missed for some time past. The game was only of seventy minutes’ duration and it was none too short. The players were compelled to tread very gingerly, and the spectators had to put with a lot of discomfort from the intense cold and the wretched fog. The first stages of the play were not at all one-sided. After the Rovers had badly missed scoring from the first run of the game, the argument was heated as to which half of the ground the ball should be confined to. The Everton forwards were far more risky than those of the visitors but not nearly so finished. Watson and Milward were especially active, but Brown made many blunders by the side of Watson, and Chadwick seemed determined to shoot at all hazards. He ignored the presence of Angus, and banged away at goal whenever he got the ball, or sent it right across to the other. Such efforts as these contrasted strongly with the beautiful touches of the Rovers’ forwards, but for all that the excess of vim carried the day, and Milward and Watson between them managed to give Everton the first goal. The second half was not so exciting, and the Everton forwards approached nearer to the standard of their opponents. For all that Everton have to thank Joliffe for some most remarkable defence that the Rovers did not at least equalize. McOwen hurt his thigh at the other end, and Southworth had to go in goal, whilst Jimmy Douglas fell back to assist Forbes. Naturally the crowd were much disgusted when it leaked out that they had been treated to an “exhibition,” and that the victory was no victory at all. Of the players, Joliffe, Weir, Watson and Milward were most prominent for Everton; Forbes, Forrest, Whittaker, and James Southworth most worthy of notion for the Rovers. Holt was foiled far more frequently than is customary by the Rovers’ forwards, and the backs were none too safe, though Ross greatly excelled Dobson on this occasion. Milward gives promise of turning out a serviceable centre forward, and Watson is improving steadily. He still falls a lot short of the form he showed with Everton last season before his suspension, and much of this is to be attributed to his falling heavily into flesh.
RESERVES
The Everton reserve had an unhappy, as it is an unusual experience at Southport. I suppose it must count as a defeat that the referee records the game as Old Boys two, Everton one, but there are certain circumstances which discredit this return to some considerable extent. Mr. Stockton informed me that his team was sadly spoiled by the claims of the first eleven and the veteran Jack McGill was induced to turn out to make a complete side. The referee was a Southport man and his decisions were not always characterized by strict impartiality. The incident which caused a stoppage of the game was narrated to me as follows by the Everton assistant secretary. Everton claimed a throw-in at a certain point; the Old Boys claimed a free kick; before any decision was given, one of the home team threw the ball in and it was shot through the Everton goal. Though Everton disputed the point, it was allowed by the official, whereupon Everton left the ground.
WHAT “MICKEY FREE” SAYS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 12 January 1889
FROST AND FOG
It is not my intention to attempt to criticize the play at Everton any further than what has already been done, for the simple reason that a considerable amount of the scuffle took place out of sight of the stand; as for instance when either goal was visited it was utterly impossible to say exactly what was going on, except when Charlie Joliffe knocked the leather out with such mighty pucks that it travelled as far as it would do from an ordinary kick, and the cheer which followed from the crowd on the big stand behind the goal. There were two surprises. The first we received was that in consequence of the frost-bound state of the ground it was not considered desirable to play the match as a League one, and the difficulty was got over by the captains agreeing to make it a draw on that head, and play the match as an ordinary fixture. The trouble which this arrangement caused after the match was phenomenal, and attributable entirely to the question of bets being off. However, as I am no authority on such matters, I shall leave the problem for others to solve. Surprise number two was to find that an old Blackburn Rover was officiating as referee- what a compliment to Mac’s honour! –and a Bootle man filling the position of umpire for Everton. What could you wish for more? It is useless to speculate on what the result might have been had the conditions been favourable; one thing is certain and that is, that the Rovers would have found the team they had to oppose a very different thing to that which succumbed inn such a rotten fashion at Blackburn. The question now arises –Had the captains the power to make the match a draw, and count a point each? Will the League Committee recognize it?
EVERTON V. STOKE
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 12 January 1889
This return fixture was played in dull weather. There was no fog however. Wilson, of Stoke, was the only absentee. His place was taken by Barr, of Dumbarton. There were 6,000 spectators. The teams faced each other as follow;- Stoke; Rowley, goal; Clare and Underwood, backs; Ramsay, Shutt, and Smith, half-backs; Lawton, McSkimming, Barr, Edge, and McLarvie, forwards. Everton; Joliffe, goal; Dobson and Ross, backs; Farmer, Holt, and Weir, half-backs; Angus, Chadwick, Milward, Watson, and Davies, forwards. At 2.45 Barr kicked off. Davies passed to the centre, and Milward shot hard at Rowley, who saved cleverly. Angus next made a pretty pass, but Watson shot wild and Underwood and Edge repelled. Milward got up and Angus shot in, but Rowley saved magnificently. Again Watson passed to the left, and Chadwick shot hard, but Rowley scooped the ball out. Ross put the ball through from a free kick, but it did not touch anyone. Stoke then spurted, and Everton had a few anxious moments. Twenty minutes from the start Lawton arrived. Everton still pressed and Farmer sent in a beauty but Rowley claimed. After 40 minutes play Milward managed to touch the leather through amid loud cheers. Davies made a fine run along the right, but should have passed sooner. Rowley then made a splendid save. At half time Everton had scored one to Stoke nil. Milward re-started down the incline. Everton came well up, and a free kick endangered the Stoke goal, but it was cleared. Angus raced back, passed to Chadwick, he to the right, and Davies headed a cleverly. Rosss got hurt, and immediately after he came out again just in time to stop a dangerous rush, Everton replied and Chadwick shot in, but Rowley again kept out. Holt robbed Barr prettily and Chadwick sent to Angus. The latter sent in a clipper, but Rowley hit out. Subsequently he hit out one from Holt, Lawton and McSkimming came along the right but the ball was worked behind. Chadwick raced back and Watson shot over. Ten minutes from time Edge scored cleverly. Davies now went half back and Everton got up, but Chadwick shot wide. Milward made a mistake in judgement when an opening presented itself. Final result; Everton 2, Stoke 1.
NUGGETS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 12 January 1889
EVERTON 2 STOKE 1 (game 17)
Janauary 14 1889. The Liverpool Courier
The return league contest took place at Everton on Saturday, fully 7,000 spectators present. At 2-40 the teams took up their position on the field. Stoke started with 10 men, Ross having won the toss, Wilson kicked off against the wind. From a long return by Farmer the Everton forwards forced Rowley to clear. Again the Everton right worked the leather into the Stoke quarters, Rowley having to fist out a hot shot from Chadwick. By neat passing Lawton and McSkimming removed the play to midfield. Holt returned, and again Rowley saved from Watson. At this point the Stoke eleventh man joined his team. A grand run by Chadwick and Angus forced the Stoke captain to concede a corner, the place kick was nicely put, Underwood clear. The visiting right forced their way, Ross stooping the rush with some fine tackling. From a throw in by Farmer Chadwick struck the upright the ball going outside. Hands against Stoke gave the home team a grand opportunity, from a pass by Holt, Ross shot through; a claim off offside against Milward was sustained and no goal conceded. A combined run by the Stoke forwards caused the Everton defence some trouble, Ross heading clear. The home right wing put in a spendid run, Davies compelling Rowley to concede another corner, and from a pass by Watson, Milward scored a well-earned goal. From midfield Watson dribbed up the centre, Farmer intercepting the pass and again Milward and Chadwick called upon Rowley to save. The Stoke left removed the danger Joliffe having to clear from Lawton. Weir was now prominent with some fine half-backs play, and passing to Milward he in turn put in a regular daisy cutter, which Rowley kicked clear. Davies was now cheered for a magnificent run down the right Clare robbing him at a dangerous moment. Edge and Milarvie in a fine run up the left , Ross kicking out to clear. Half time Everton 1; Stoke nil. After the usual interval Milward kicked off, Rowley received a magnificent reception from the spectators on taking his place in the goal-mouth. His display in goal is undoubtedly the finest that has been seen at Anfield enclosure this season. Weir was immediately called upon to stop McSkimming, who had worked his way down the left. A couple of fouls now fell to Everton Ross having hard lines with a stinging shot. Lawton and McSkimming put in a most determined rush. Ross kicked out and Angus took up the attack, and passing to Davies he headed through. From the centre of the field Wilson forced the play down Ross receiving a nasty kick, which accussitated his working for a little time. From a throw in Chadwick received from Holt, and again Rowley fisted clear. The home van would not be denied. Rowley saving shots from Chadwick and Milward. From a goal kick Lawton removed the venue with a strong run. Farmer removed the danger with a timely kick. Weir now left the field having received an injury. The Stoke forwards played much better, but could not break through the fine defence of the home backs. Edge gave Dobson some trouble, Joliffe clearing from Milarvie. After a spendid run by Ross Angus passed to Milward who kicked over the bar. Another visit was paid to the Everton citadel, where Angus gave a foul for ‘'Hands'' After a warm tussle in the goal mouth McSkimming secured the first point for Stoke. Joliffe in saving from Ramsley conceded a corner, Milward kicking clear. Watson broke away, Chadwick missing a fine opportunity by kicking outside. From the throw in Watson put in a splendid run, Milward missing a good chance by dallying in the goal mouth. Again Everton pressed, but could not score. Even play followed Chadwick pit in a fine screw, which Rowley saved, and a well though game ended in favour of Everton by 2 goals to 1.
Teams Stoke:- Rowley (w) goal, Clare (t) (captain) and Underwood (a) backs, Ramsley (r) Shutt (g), and Smith (e) half-backs Lawton (g), McSkimmer (r), Hogg (a) Milarvie (r), and Wilson (j) forwards. Umpire Lockett. Everton:- Joliffe (c), Ross (captain), and Dobson backs, Farmer, Holt and Weir half-backs Angus, Chadwcik, Watson Davies, and Milward, forwards. Umpire Mr Berry referee Mr Fitzroy Norris (Bolton).
LIVERPOOL AND DISTRICT COMMENTS
Athletic News - Monday 14 January 1889
STOKE AT ANFIELD-ROAD
By the Loiterer
Agreeable weather favoured the return fixture between Everton and Stoke, and about 6,000 spectators were present. The ground seemed to be in very fair condition, but on examination it proved to be deceptive, being rather heavy in the entre. Well, we must not grumble, as it will probably be a lot worse before it is any better. The game was a rather quiet one, and ended in favour of Everton by two goals to one. I ought to mention that the visitors played ten men for the first twenty minutes, Lawton being late. The play was only moderate, and, with the exception of Rowley's goalkeeping, never brilliant. The home team had all the best of the play in the first half, and for a considerable portion of the second, and then Weir's retirement caused the forwards to fall to pieces. Stoke did not fail to take advantage of all this and put in all they knew, but failed to draw level. Of the visitors, Rowley was really splendid, and the spectators were treated to a fine display of goalkeeping. Both Clare and Underwood played a good defensive game, and that is about all they did. I never saw two backs adopt such cover-goal tactics in my life. Of the halves. Ramsey was the last of a good trio, and they all did their work well. The forwards apparently know how to pass, the left wing pair being very clever and causing Dobson no end of trouble, but the opposite wing were decidedly funky in tackling Ross. Barr, the new Scotchman, in the centre, made a good first appearance. He dribbles very closely, and seems to have a good idea of when and how to pass, and I hope he will turn out to be an acquisition to the Stoke Club. He hails from Hurlford. Somehow, the home team seemed to be out of gear. Joliffe had three shots to stop, two he hit out and the other he hit in. Dobson was all over the shop, and although he pulled himself together in the second half, he did not play a good game. Edge and Milarvie were a wee bit too clever or else too little for him. Ross and the halves were all right, but the forwards are not yet up to the mark. There is too much individualism, and against the backs they have to contend with it won't come off. There is nothing prettier than a good, fast dribble, always providing it meets with success, which is very seldom nowadays, and one or two of the home forwards would do a lot better if they would drop self and play for Everton. A forward, individually, has no chance against a back player, inasmuch as his efforts are directed to a limited space, whereas the back kicks anywhere so that he clears for the time being, and as soon as the Everton van recognizes this fact the better.
RESIGNATION OF THE EVERTON TREASURER
Athletic News - Monday 14 January 1889
By the Loiterer
Mr. Marriott has resigned his position as treasurer of the Everton Club. Like a good many more people, he doubtless finds the Anfield enclosure most inconveniently situated for those engaged in business, and in his official capacity as treasurer, it either means neglect of business or things going wrong at the ground; in fact, it just amounts to this, that he is unable to attend to both his own business and that of the club. It has long been his intention to give up the post, and twelve months ago, when the club was in troubled waters he told me that but for appearing to show the white feather, he would have resigned them. Mr. Marriott has stuck to the club through thick and thin, and I hope they will be successful in appointing a man worthy to succeed him- not an easy job by any means.
LIVERPUNDIANA; BY RICHARD SAMUEL
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 19 January 1889
Richard Samuel.
EVERTON GO UP ONE
Everton had no difficulty in getting through their last League fixture with success, for Stoke is not at all a formidable side, for Stoke in the light of their display in Liverpool last week. It would seem that the North Staffordshire team is suffering are so many other clubs are suffering or hare suffered, from the beelines of their agent-procured recruits from over the border. And yet they have the temerity to tempt Fortune ones more—for exit Sloane, enter his countryman Barr. No team has been more puffed as to its resource than this same Stoke dub. Stoke Swifts and New Swifts are reputed to be the champion light weights, so to speak, of the football world. But when a vacancy arises in the first team Scotland is scoured by the lean and hungry agents to fill the gap. And the Swifts and New Swifts meanwhile? Ah! Well ! A few more Barbours and Brands and Sloanes and Izatts, will soon stifle the importation which so troubles the souls of Scottish football authorities, and the veiled professionalism which sets at naught and flouts the English Association. But to return. Stoke, as constituted last week, were no match for Everton, and though the margin goals—2 to 1— in favour of the Liverpool men was only very narrow, the run of play was far more one-sided. To Rowley and Clare and Underwood—to Rowley in the highest degree—is duo the smallness of Everton’s score, and the spectators at Anfleld Road can well attest to Me dexterity and superlative qualities of Rowley as a goalkeeper. The Everton forwards were no better than their usual moderate standard, a little more of an understanding being discernible between left wing pair, and a falling off in the centre play Milward. The Stoke forwards were perhaps a cleverer lot, but where the visitors were unmistakably and decisively beaten was at half-back, their trio bring long a way inferior to those of Everton. The latter’s evil genius demanded another sacrifice, Weir joining the cripples’ list before the game terminated, and it would indeed be a misfortune if the hurt be serious.
“MICKEY FREE’S” LUCUBRATIONS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 19 January 1889
A nice game
Now, I daresay some people would be spiteful enough to say “Oh aye, when the boot is on the right foot the game is always happens, well, then, the game has been a ‘rotten one,’ and the men played like “sticks.” But in the match under consideration the play was good all round, and Stoke, although beaten, stayed the longest, with the result that whereas Everton fell off in the last half the visitors appeared as fresh as possible. True, for a considerable part of the last period Weir took no part in the game as he had to retire hurt, and so badly, that he will not be able to take part in the big match today, more’s the pity. It must also be remembered that for 20 minutes in the first half Stoke only played 20 men, as Lawton missed the first train, therefore honours were even.
GOALKEEPING
Not only before the arrival of the eleventh man, but after his debut, Everton played capital football the clean kicking of the back division keeping the forwards busy, and they in turn shot well, and often, to put it mildly, there were high shots, low shots, cross shot, in fact, all sorts of difficult things in the way of testing a goalkeeper’s ingenuity in meeting the attacks, and through this ordeal Rowley sailed out with flying colours. His praise has been sounded in my care very frequently lately and I was delighted to see him tested, and equally pleased with his exhibition, which was also highly appreciated by the spectators, who gave him a hearty cheer on charging ends.
THE PLAYERS
Clare was very safe at back, and put in excellent work until he got lamed. Underwood was a bit wild in his kicking. The veteran Smith was in capital form, and did some very clever things. The forwards at times passed prettily, but their shooting was not at all equal to their general play. The shot by Edge which beat Joliffe was about the only dangerous one sent in. On the other side Dobson was too rash in getting so far up the field, and consequently he was trickled time after time by Edge and Milarvie, this causing Ross may runs across from his own wing. Weir played well. Farmer was not as good as usual; Holt was nearly always where he was wanted most; Angus and Chadwick seemed to get on better; Milward was not so good as the previous week. Watson is improving, and Davies passes better, but still sticks to the ball too long. It is no use sprinting two-thirds of the field, only to be rolled over by an opposing back, when there are four other forwards running in line. Are we going to have a change in the luck at home today? I hope we shall have a fine day, and if so there will be a stiff fight.
REGRET
It was with sincere regret that I received the announcement after the match that Mr. Wm. Marriott had retired from the post of treasure. During his long tensure of office in that honorable position he has been most self-denying in his efforts to promote the welfare of the Everton club. He pleased hard at the annual meeting to be relieved of the duty on account of the great amount of time which the work required to carry it out successfully, clashing very much with his business engagements. He was, however, much against his will prevailed on to continue in office, therefore it is all the more regrettable that he has not been able to stick to it to the end of the season, which has been so fortunate from a financial point up to the present.
PRESTON NORTH END V. EVERTON
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 19 January 1889
The return League match between the North End and Everton at Anfield-road created as much interest as the encounter with Bootle and at least 15,000 spectators were present. The ground was somewhat heavy. The teams faced each other as follow;-
Everton; Joliffe, goal, Ross (Captain), and Dobson, backs; Farmer, Holt, and Kelso, half-backs; Angus, Chadwick, Milward, Watson, and Davies, forwards. North End;- Trainer, goal; Howarth and Holmes, backs; Robertson, Russell, and Graham, half-backs; Gordon, Drummond, Goodall, Thomson, and Ross, forwards. Everton won the toss, and Goodall started the game. Everton came up, Holmes just repelling. Chadwick then shot in, Trainer saving marvelously amidst great excitement. After a nice pass by Holt, Chadwick shot wide. Ross, junr., and Thomson got down the left, but Dobson interposed. Chadwick and Angus raced back, but Howarth tackled well and stopped them. Ross, senr, next spoiled an effort by Thomson. From a free kick Angus lost a golden chance. Trainer saved twice and then Preston got their first corner. The “demon” now shot hard, but Kelso saved. The North End worked down gradually, and a second corner accrued. From a shot by Ross, junr., Dobson cleared, and Davies made tracks. Graham returned the ball, and Everton had a narrow squeak, the ball striking the post and rebounding into play. Ross cleared and Chadwick shot hard.
Half-time Result;- Preston North End 0 Everton 0
Milward restarted, when Gordon raced up and shot across, but Kelso cleared. Everton replied with a run and Kelso shot, following by Everton gaining an unproductive corner. Good passing by Everton brought the ball down and then Dobson missed his kicked, and Ross junior scored after fifteen minutes’ play. Holt was now conspicuous for brilliant play. Russell was penalized for tripping, and Trainor had to hit out a good shot. Gordon next shot in, and Drummond tried to improve the pass, but Jollffe saved. Play became somewhat tamer now, the Prestonians having the best of the game. Dobson failed to stop Goodall, who fairly dribbled the ball through the Everton goal. Everton now worked along the left, but Chadwick’s shot was wide. Holt was hurt, but struggled gamely on. Chadwick and Angus made a good run, but Howarth spoiled them. Milward was not a success, and Davies was also off form.
Final result; Everton 0, Preston North End 2
SPECIAL
The Anfield ground presented a splendid appearance today, with every stand packed, and both teams had a grand reception as they made their appearance, for though the crowd was mostly Evertonians, it soon became evident that there were thousands of unbiased onlookers. There was a tremendous burst of excitement just after the start when Chadwick made Trainer exhibit some of his smartest goalkeeping right under the bar. It was evident the home lads had been well prepared for they commenced to play with considerable dash, but slowly and surely the North Enders persisted in their correct passing game, though the Everton backs time after time repelled them. To sum up the first half, it may be said that the play was first-class on both sides, but the North End had most chance. It was perceptible soon after the re-start that the Evertonians were falling off. Their forwards were very weak in combination and though their defence continued good Ross and Goodall each after a good dribble shot splendid goals, the home team fell off considerably after this, and had to submit to the first League defeat at home, though they died game. Ross, Kelso, the Scotch International, Holt and Farmer, were the pick of the home team backs, Watson, Davies and Chadwick being the best of the forwards. Drummond was the weakest man on the North End side. All the remainder played a splendid game, and fully deserved the victory. The ground was in good condition.
NUGGETS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 19 January 1889
LIVERPOOL AND DISTRICT COMMENTS
Athletic News - Monday 21 January 1889
By The Loiterer
THE “CHAMPIONS “ AT ANFIELD
A beautiful day favoured the return League fixture, Everton v. North End, and the Anfield- road ground presented an animated spectacle when the home team came bounding into the enclosure. The Everton Committee are a progressive body, and their latest improvement is an entrance, about the middle of the covered stand, for the players. From a spectator's point of view, I think the enclosure could not be improved, but unfortunately the verdant appearance of the ground has vanished. Still, the executive make the best they can of it, and on Saturday it was in very fair going condition. When the visitors came on every place of vantage was secured, and much speculation was indulged in as to the destination of young Ross. On taking up his position, it was found that he had been transferred over to the left, and Thompson partnered Gordon on the right. Whatever motive prompted this decision, it was, perhaps, as well that the two brothers should meet as little as possible in the match, for, undoubtedly, even in football, blood is thicker than water. From the start, and throughout the first half, play was very fast and exciting, and Trainer early on gave us a touch of brilliant goal-keeping. Ross was then prominent in stopping two raids by Gordon and Thompson, and his forwards considerably harassed Howorth and Holmes. Chadwick, however, shot wide from a favourable position for scoring. Gordon was fed admirably, and just now play was in home quarters. Joliffe throwing out a shot by Ross, jun., which rebounded dead off Goodall —a near squeak. The home forwards by dint of hard work carried play to the other end, and indifferent kicking by Holmes let in Angus, but he missed his kids, and a rare chance as well. Howorth and Holmes were playing rather weak, and Trainer had again to save. Play for a little while was in midfield, but Ross missing his kick compelled Farmer to concede a corner. This was cleared, but the home goal was again in danger, and Kelso cleared from a scrummage. Again the home teams were aggressive, and won a corner, which was placed behind. Kelso was prominent, but after some give-and-take play the visitors attacked fiercely, Ross, jun., hit the bar. The backs on each side now treated us to some tall kicking and then Trainer give a corner, which, like the proceeding ones, was behind, and at half-time not a speck was on the score sheet,. Although there had been one or two " very nears” for each side. Play slowed down considerably on resuming, but the Preston men had rather the best of somewhat tame proceedings. A sudden spurt, however, by the home left caused Holmes to concede a corner, and the game smartened up perceptibly. Play was in the visitors' half, but ere long Ross, Jun. came away, and, eluding Dobson, scored the first goal with a rather long shot. From the kick off the home team attacked, and about this time Holt was very successful in his dealing with Goodall and Thompson. Trainer again saved well, and then play was once more of an interesting character, though carried on in the home half, where first Russell and then Gordon were unsuccessful in their shots. However, after this lull in the game, Goodall darted off in his old style, and although hampered by several opposing backs he wriggled through and shot a splendid goal. After a brief visit to the visitors' end, Kelso nicely pulled up Goodall when he was getting dangerous, and play for some time was in the centre, the defence of both sides being grand, and up to the call of time no further Impression could be made, Everton retiring defeated by two goals to nil. Many of the Everton supporters had cherished the hope that their team would lower the colours of the proud Prestonians. I need hardly say that I did not share this hope. Before this feat can be accomplished three, or perhaps four, new forwards will have to don the Everton colours. Anyone who watched events on Saturday could not but be impressed with the fact that our forwards are not class enough. There is no doubt about it. Their efforts were disjointed throughout, and the only pair that shaped well were Angus and Chadwick. The others were simply not in it. Bobby Watson played a hard game, and had he been between two men of equal merit, he would have shone in this match, but giving the ball to Davies was like throwing pearls to swine. I was led to believe that I should see something extra in Davies, but his play in some half-dozen matches that I have seen convinces me that he is about the biggest of the numerous white elephants that have visited Everton this season. Milward's play was weak, but it must be remembered that he had a model half-back to face, and several polite attentions that he gave Russell did not improve his play. The halved were all good, Holt and Kelso comparing very favorably with their opponents, and if Farmer was not so successful as his companions it was due more to the metal he had to face than anything else. The backs were very good, and I was pleased to see that Dobson kept his place. He wandered on one or two occasions, but on the whole played a fairly good game. Joliffe kept out some good shots, but he ought to have stopped the first goal. The shot, however, surprised him, as he evidently expected Ross to get nearer before taking aim; and the second, though a well-got goal was certainly negotiable. For the North End, Trainer never made a mistake. He had as much to do as Joliffe, and it was done in his own finished manner. At the onset both Howorth and Holmes kicked very weak, but they improved, and their play left nothing to be desired at the close. Robertson was not as good as Russell or Graham, but in Angus and Chadwick he had more powerful opponents than either of the latter had to face. Graham, perhaps, shone the most, Davies's play suiting him to a “T." On the other hand, Russell was all right as regards Milward, but in Holt he found that Jack was about as good as his master. The forwards were not so smart as I have seen them, Drummond especially being weak, and Gordon seemed to miss Ross. This was apparent in the early part of the game, as Thompson failed to take several passes Intended for him, and Gordon's looks were not very complimentary to his partner. Still, Thompson did very well so long as he played the passing game, but in his tussles with Holt he did not shine. Goodall, in centre, did any amount of work, and his effort which resulted in the scoring of the second point was really splendid. Roes, Jun., did not appear to like the change, and the left wing was weak compared with the right. I am quite satisfied with the result, as it fully demonstrates our weakness in attack and our strength in defence. The Everton defence is as good as any in the country, but the forwards are weak.
NOTES FROM NEWCASTLE
Athletic News - Monday 21 January 1889
Robert Kelso
It was stated at the meeting that a rumour had got afloat to the effect that West End would not meet their opponents of Christmas Day owing to Kelso having been asked to Everton to play for that club on Saturday. This, it was explained, was incorrect and, to show how absurd the rumour was, it was agreed that when the return game should be played Kelso should be left off the team. I am afraid this is making a virtue of necessity, for there is a strong probability that the connection Kelso formed at Everton on Saturday will last. If the Scotch International really stays at Everton we shall experience a great loss, for he is an exceedingly clever half-back, and his place will be difficult to fill. The explanation as to Kelso, however, was not the only piece of importance business at Friday’s meeting, for power was unanimously given to the committee to register professionals.
EVERTON 0 PRESTON NORTH END 2 (game 18)
January 21 1889. The Liverpool Courier
In glorious football weather this important return fixture took place on the Everton enclosure. For a long time previous to the start the roads leading to the ground were lined with ardent supporters of the home side. At the time of commencing hostilities there would be fully 15,000 spectators present. The champion League team were strongly represented the only absentee being Fred Dewhurst the Preston captain. The home organisation was minus Weir and Smalley their places being filled by Joliffe of the Reserves and Kelso of Newcastle West End. At 2-45 the teams put in an appearance the visitors receiving a very cordial reception. Ross having won the toss Goodall kicked off down the hill, and immediately Thompson raced down Farmer relieved and passing to Angus, he passed to Watson who shot in Trainor saved in a marvellous manner two minutes from the start Everton having hard lines in not scoring. Ross and Drummond broke away down to left, Dobson heading clear. From a throw in by Kelso, milward raced down the centre. Howarth kicked clear. Hands against Dobson gave North End a chance Joliffe fisting out a warm one from Gordon. Preston now took a corner Graham heading over the bar. The home right removed the play to the other end, Angus missing a good chance in the goal mouth. The Everton right forced Holmes to kick out. Kelso threw in, Trainor again saving a good shot from Davies. From midfield the Preston van raced down, Farmer relieving Gordon of a dangerous moment. From a corner kick the Preston men showed some neat passing in front of the home upright, Russell kicking over. Again Preston came dangerously near, a shot from Thompson going outside. The game was stopped for a few minutes owing to an injury to Farmer. From the goal kick the visiting forwards caused the Everton backs some trouble. Ross clearing with a long punt. A grand run by Davies forced Holmes to concede a corner, Trainor fisting out in grand style. Jimmy Ross was now conspicuous with a spendid run Dobson robbing him on the touch line. Kelso now placed his wing in position, Davies put in a superb run, Russell taking clear. The Preston left removed the venue, Ross striking the Everton crossbar with a terrific shot. Gordon ran down the right Farmer robbing him, and passing to Chadwick he shot in, Trainor giving a corner which proved abortive. Russell took a free kick for a foul against Holt. Half-time Everton 0, Preston North End 0.
After the usual rest Milward put the ball in motion, and after even play in midfield Gordon ran up, and passing to Drummond he shot behind. Again Preston came to the front, Kelso saving in the nick of time. The Everton patrons were now treated to a fine bit of passing by Kelso Watson, and Davies which caused Graham to concede another corner which proved abortive. Again the Preston forwards with good passing brought the ball up the field and from a pass by Goodall, immediately Jimmy Ross scored with a low shot. The Everton forwards broke away in line, and looked like scoring until Russell tripped Milward for which he was penalised, from the free kick , Trainor stooped two shots from Kelso and Chadwick. Goodall removed the danger with a fine run, and, passing to Drummond, he had a grand opening Joliffe kicking clear. Holmes with a long kick put Gordon in possession, who shot behind. Angus and Chadwick came away with a fine passing run, Howarth with an excellent bit of kicking removed the danger. Goodall again rushed up the centre and after passing his opponents he lowered the home citadel a second time. Dobson being at fault from the restart, Milward pressed, Russell proving a stumbling block. The Everton left were now prominently, a shot from Chadwick going outside. Holt was now cheered for a fine defence, his pass to Davies going over the line. Kelso throw in, and again Gordon was first. Ross kicking over, Robertson threw in Farmer again holding the Preston right in check. Hands against Preston looked dangerous, Kelso again cleared, Milward made off, Howarth kicking clear. Again Chadwick broke away, and passing to Davies he lost a good opportunity by being to slow on the ball, Robertson kicking clear. Short passing put the Preston forwards on the aggressive Ross finishing a spendid movement with a fine shot which the home custodian cleared. The offical whistle sounded leaving the North End victors by 2 goals to nil. Teams Preston North End, Trainor, goal, Holmes,and Howarth backs, Robinson, Russell, and Graham, half-backs, Gordon Drummond, Goodall, Ross (Jimmy) and Thompson, forwards. Everton:- Joliffe goal, Dobson and Ross (captain), Kelso, Holt, and Farmer half-backs, Davies Watson Milward, Chadwcik, and Angus, forwards.
PRESTON NORTH END RESERVES 4 EVERTON RESERVES 0
January 21 1889. The Liverpool Courier
No details
EVERTON V PRESTON NORTH END
January 23, 1889. The Lancaster Gazette
Played on Saturday at Everton, before 14,000 spectators. After a little even play, Trainer saved well, and at the other end Ross stopped a couple of breaks away of Gordon. Everton came up again, but Chadwick shot wide. Long ex-changes by the backs were now the rule, and Trainer gave a corner, but half time arrived with no score. Play slowed down considerably on resuming, but North End had the best of some rather tame play. Ross, jun., by a quick movement, eluded Dobson and shot a goal, on resuming the home team attacked, Holt successfully tackling, and Trainer, saving well. Play again was tame in home half, but after indifferent hooting by Russell and Gordon, Goodall came away in his old style, although hampered scored a second goal. A splendid effort. Play was generally in favour of the visitors, but the grand defence could not again be broken. Score Preston 2, Everton 0
EXTENSION OF THE FOOTBALL LEAGUE
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 26 January 1889
Despite the fact that the comprehensive scheme of extension now under the consideration of the Football League may undergo material alterations, there can be no doubt that if adopted the League will become a power that will need reckoning with. We have already seen what can be affected by twelve of our foremost clubs combining for their own benefit, and if the number is doubled very few clubs of any moment will to left outside the magic circle. No one can deny that the establishment of the League gave just the fillip to the interest in football that was very much wanted. It had become a common occurrence to hear the pessimistic cry that football was dying and people cared no longer for the good old sport. Now, however, interest in the game is just as keen as ever, and gates of ten and twelve thousand are weekly recorded. Much of this is owing to the League, which has been the means of bringing the cream of our players together on successive Saturdays, and a week-end has passed without a fixture of first importance in our big towns. With these good results to work on the League are setting their house in order, and are so extending their operations that they will most likely wipe the lifeless Combination out of existence altogether. From what we hear these are to be two classes, each to consist of 12 clubs. There will be first and second-class championships, the last four clubs in each to retire, but to be eligible for re-election. The League are to have power to order any of the retiring clubs or the first four of the second class to compete in order to decide the question of superiority. No member of a League club will be allowed to play for another organization unless by special permit, this being a very sensible precaution. Several of the alterations are on purely business matters, and not of interest to the general public, such as the infringement of the rules by the clubs, the sum to be deposited for appeal, &c., but it will be rather a relief to spectators generally to know that it is proposed to appoint umpires for all matches as well as referees, for there can be no doubt that the twelfth man is often particularly prominent, and it would be better for players and spectators alike if all officials were entirely independent. A match is to be played each season between teams selected by the management committee of the League, the proceeds of which shall be devoted to the funds. The match for the present season will probably take place after the final for the English Cup between teams selected from the Midlands and Lancashire, and, as there are six clubs in ach district, the very pick of English football will probably be seen. Taken on the whole, the future of the League is full of promise, and one would like to ascertain the candid opinion of the F.A. on the “opposition show.”
LIVERPUDLIANA; BY RICHARD SAMUEL
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 26 January 1889
AT LAST!
These are the halcyon days of Everton football. Fourteen thousand spectators turned out last week, for the League fixture of Everton’s season. And yet there were many who went away unable to gain admission, or unwilling to face the enormous crush at the pay gates, at each of which excited crowds struggled to get in, whilst the more adventurous, if less scrupulous, sought an entrance by scaling the high barriers. How they manage this would puzzle one to imagine when recollecting the height, but that they did I can attest from personal observation. Yes, they were excited over last Saturday’s fixture. Did you meet an Evertonian who did not cherish the hope of victory? Have you met one since who wonders why? And there was warrant for such joyous anticipations when one comes to examine the question. Unbeaten at home, Everton, by their surprising varieties of form, have been a puzzle right through the season. They rarely create a favourable impression abroad; at home they accomplish startling things. Even Aston Villa succumbed at Anfield. 'Why, then, should not Preston North End. Hope once more told a flattering tale, delusive mayhap, but hugged and fondled by the enthusiasts to the last. The reaction was correspondingly depressing, and as the crowd slowly dispersed after the game, blank and apathetic looks bad taken the place of bright and eager anticipation. It was not that the defeat was overwhelming; there are few clubs who get off so easily against North End as Everton did last week. But the sense of overwhelming superiority could not be got rid of even by the most stubborn of beaten club’s supporters. Yet I have been told that Everton “had just as much of the game as their opponents. “I don’t think so; do you?
STRICT TRAINING
The home players had left nothing undone in the way of preparation, and with what a burst they went off! I can only characterize Trainer’s saving of North End goal at the first impetuous onset as wonderful. The ball was shot at him from a distance of certainly not more than two yards, and with great force, bringing the king of goalkeepers to his knees, whilst Everton forwards dashed furiously upon him. But no; he was not beaten, although badly shaken by Milward, whose attentions he claimed to be unfair. For a time Mr. Sudell and the crowd of very aggressive Prestonians on the stand most have had an anxious time of It, for both Howarth and Holmes were kicking badly. Their tackling was faultless, however, and it was not the Everton forwards, of the past they had to face; and the Preston attacking party were getting into motion, none too eagerly, but unmistakably. Gradually the ball manifested a tendency to the goal defended by Joliffe, and the home forwards commenced to display a lamentable state of helplessness. But for Ross and Holt and Kelso the trials of Holmes and Howarth must have been few and not alarming. Millward was in a hopeless state of constancy, and “bashed” and blundered about like a flat in a storm. Watson kept assiduously feeding Johnny Graham, whilst Davies lay “waiting for something to turn up” mostly, and when it did come, in the form of a pass from Kelso, he wanted 20 yards of clear open space before he could get away. Augus and Chadwick made most progress, but not much. Meanwhile, behind this organized line, some brilliant play was going on. Holt stuck to Goodall like a leach; Kelso was quite equal to the task of staying Drummond and young Ross, although the latter’s wonderful resource made Joliffe’s pulse quicken very frequently. Jack Ross kicked magnificently and tackled with unfailing accuracy, and if Dobson was a trifle rash he was very determined about it. So half-time came and Everton’s hopes were dashed. It was quite evident that the home forwards were done, and Ross and his companions in defence girded up their loins and made ready. It was needed. The visitors had not turned a hair. They commenced to come in beautiful formation, with the regularity and order of waves. For time the Everton backs held out, but bet Jimmy Rose made for the centre with the ball at his toe. Dobson set out to meet him—bore down upon him like a three-decker —missed the mark, and Joliffe's heart was in his mouth at once. A simple long shot went through the goal at the end where he was not, whilst the custodian was waiting for the clever forward to bang the ball straight at him, which is the recognised thing under such circumstances. A flukey goal? Oh, dear, no. A simple one? Decidedly and therein the merit lies. Not long afterwards Goodall came tearing along the centre of the field, threading his way amongst the defenders of Everton’s goal. His was tackled both by Dobson and Ross, but even while hammed shot most unexpectedly, and again at the end where Joliffe was not. Another simple goal! Another brilliant effort! Beyond some wonderful tackling by Holt, these were the only incidents of note in the last half, and the game ended a win for North End by two to nil.
NOTE ON THE GAME
The display did not come up to expectation. There were more weak spots in the North End team than I have ever noted, whilst Everton attack was never more feeble, I had almost said in the club’s history. Watson’s clumsiness, Milward’s unrestrained and unreasonable impetuosity, and Davies’ incapacity, were deplorable; whilst Chadwick and Angus have done better. I firmly believe that Everton would have won the game with last year’s forwards, for the backs all played a grand game. The North End forwards were all awry. With Jimmy Ross on the left Gordon seemed lost, and Sam Thomson evidently does not , understand the methods of the “streak.” Goodall was, all there, but I don’t think Drummond was; he is evidently done, as a forward at least Robertson was not so safe as Graham and Russell, and the backs were rather wild in their kicking at times, although towards the finish their form was perfect There was a commendable absence of roughness, though Millward and Russell got across each other very frequently. The referee, Mr. Jope, gave some curious decisions, and it would seem is not quite such an infallible judge as was imagined. Once there was an unmistakable case of off-side charging for Milward was harassing Trainer in the rear of both backs. Mr. Sudell claimed persistently, but in vain. Another time, Mr. Berry, the Everton umpire, gave a throw in for both sides, a rather singular thing, but instead of throwing the ball up, the referee, who was not in a position to judge, gave a decision in favour of Everton. Perhaps he was afraid of being considered partial to North End, after his Blackburn experiences.
“MICKEY FREE” ON THE BIG EVENT
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 26 January 1889
THE CRUSH
Any one fond of a tight squeeze had only to go to the entrance gates of the Everton ground on Saturday, and if' they were not satisfied in five minutes they must be gluttons. I paused outside for a few minutes to take stock and upon my conscience it was awful. The crowd swaying and surging whilst the weaker members enlivened affairs by a yell or two, and at intervals some could be seen struggling out in a fainting condition. I blessed my stars mat there was a side door through which I could quietly slide, but at the same time I could not help thinking that much of the crush might have been avoided had there been a place appointed for the sale of tickets, and ticket holders could have gone through in a stream instead of waiting on the slow process of the turnstiles. The gate was a big one—£215 —still the club lost money, as hundreds clambered over the enclosure at the Anfield-road end, the commissionaire on duty at that part of the ground being perfectly helpless to stem the living torrent. For an hour before the match streams of men were seen coming from all quarters, and I couldn't help thinking that a bird’s-eye view of the approaches would have presented a remarkable spectacle.
THE GAME
After the usual preliminaries had been got through, the teams faced up, there being an absentee in the North End, i.e., Drummond, but it was only for few minutes. The ball was set going, and my word the pace became a hot 'un. Everton had the benefit of a light breeze, and it appeared to me that they had made up their minds to score, if possible, in this half, and nothing but bad luck prevented it. Four minutes had scarcely elapsed when by a capital bit of play the ball was brought up, passed to the left, and Angus met I, but being over anxious to get the ball through before Trainer could get across from the other side of the goal, he mulled a certain point by kicking right over the top of the ball without disturbing it, and I need hardly say that he didn’t get time to repair the error. Chadwick was the next to have a chance: he shot like a marksman, and it was really wonderful how Trainer saved, but he did. The game waxed warmer, and there was Just a little too much play in which Russell was pre-eminent, and his opponent (Milward) fell into the error of attempting to play Davies at his own game. It was a mistake for a young man like him to go rushing at an old warrior like Russell, and the sequel was that in the second half Milward was completely done up. The Evertonians were delighted to think that half-time was reached without a score, and visions of a draw were, no doubt, fitting before their mind’s eye. However this might be, it soon became apparent that with the wind behind them, and several of the Evertonians hanging out signals of distress, the North End were going to make it warm for them. But the defence was so good that it took them twenty minutes to find an opening, and then it was certainly not creditable to Joliffe to allow such a soft thing to go through. It was a long shot by Jimmy Ross, but it ought to have been stopped. Furthermore, the home forwards, with the exception of the left wing, appeared to forget that there was such a thing as passing in the game, whilst their opponents were passing in their best form. To mend matters Dobson took to rushing up to meet the men with the ball, as he did the previous week against Stoke invariably missed both. On two occasions Kelso met the difficulty with commendable judgement by dropping back in the nick of time and clearing the shot. But this could not continue, and Goodall twisted in and out like an eel, finishing up by beating Joliffe a second time. To Charley’s credit be it said that the most difficult shot of the match from the toe of the same player was well stopped, and so the great game ended in Everton’s first league defeat on their own ground. I certainly did not anticipate a win, but with Smalley in goal I felt confident of a draw.
THE PLAYERS
Trainer showed that is all there when required. Holmes was in good form. Graham was safe, so was Robertson, whilst Russell was, as usual everywhere. Drummond did not shine, but the other forwards played well, Thompson being the hardest worker of the lot. Of the home team Ross was in his usual trim. Dobson ditto. Farmer looked out of condition for man in training. Holt was a marvel in tackling, and successfully robbed his opponents the ball. Kelso played a finished game, showing great judgment in all his actions, and for Us throws in, well I need only say that Jud” Howarth is not in it with him, and if the Everton forwards and as for his throws in, well I need only say that “Jud” Howarth is not in it with him, and if the Everton forwards had utilized the tremendous advantage gained in this way by crowding into goal there is no saying what might have happened.
AFTER
When at length Mr.Jope sounded the “cease fire” a select party, several of them being well-known supporters of the North End, were observed wending their way towards the hospitable dwelling of the Everton president, piloted by Mr. Houlding himself. Running off on my way to send my last teles I was hailed by that gentleman and received an invitation in his usual hearty style to accompany them. Alas, stern duty called me elsewhere, and I was obliged to forego the pleasure. I cannot, therefore, say what took place, but feel safe in guaranteeing that the recollections carried away by the visitors would be pleasant ones.
WOLVERHAMPTON WANDERERS V. EVERTON
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 26 January 1889
This fixture was played at Wolverhampton in fine weather, between three and four thousand spectators. Teams;- Wolverhampton Wanderers; Rose, goal; Braugh and Mason, backs; Flecther, Allen, and Lowder, half-backs; Hunter, Wykes, Brodie, Wood, and Knight, forwards. Everton; Smalley, goal; Dobson and Ross (captain), backs; Stephenson, Holt, and Farmer, half-backs; Davies, Watson, Milward, Chadwick, and Angus, forwards. The Wanderers in the first half played down hill and immediately began an aggressive game. Ross twice returned shots, and Smalley did the same with a grand shot by throwing out. Several scrimmages ensued and the Wanderers scored five minutes from the star. The Wolves resumed aggressive tactics and Wood, from a pass by Brodie notched a second point. A claim of offside was disallowed. The Wolves again got to close quarters, and Dobson and Ross for Everton both became busy. The visitors next made a dangerous run, passing the backs but being checked by Allen. A shot through the posts by Knight was disallowed on the ground of off-side. Brodie then got possession and tried to score, but Smalley saved. Directly, however, a third goal came to the Wolves from a low shot on the left, and five minutes later Brodie registered a forth. Nothing further occurred up to the interval, when the Wanderers led by four to none. The Wanderers were evidently too strong for their opponents, who played pluckily, but had to combat superior strength and the excellent combination tactics of the home team. After crossing over Everton obtained two corners but they proved fruitless. The Wanderers throughout maintained the aggressive and played fast and judiciously. Another corner to Everton availed them nothing, and Wood eventually after the leather had been worked up the field, notched the fifth point for his side. This was the last goal scored, but the Wanderers throughout held the upper hand. Final Result; Wolverhampton Wanderers 5, Everton 0
NUGGETS
Cricket and Football Field - Saturday 26 January 1889
Oh, vesio, thous wicked man,
From thy Dog Latin may nought sever us;
But surely ‘t’was” in toto’ wrong.
To call a Bobby “toxilbeverous.”
P.S- To stop any bother, or worry, or parley
The dog above named’s not related to Charley.
WOLVERHAMPTON WANDERERS 5 EVERTON 0 (game 19)
JANUARY 28 1889. THE Liverpool Courier
The Everton team journeyed to Wolverhampton on Saturday to play the first League fixture with the Wanderers. Smalley was in the team for the first time for some weeks. There was a good attendance between 200 and 3000. Milward kicked off, and Ross was called upon to clear a foul by Farmer which gave the Wanderers a chance, but Holt headed the ball away,, and White kicked behind the posts. Baugh was cheered for a fine return and a warm scrimmage took place in front of the Everton goal, and the Wanderers rushed the leather past Smalley. White and Hunter raced past Ross, but Holt was in the way and pulled them up finely. The Everton forwards had not yet found their feet, and the home team were having the best of it. Lowder kicked outside, when Angus had a chance, and from the throw in Baugh give the leather to the forwards, and Wood shot the leather past Smalley for the second time. Baugh, a grand back, was in good form, and gave his forwards lots of work which they did in first class style. Angus and Chadwick broke away but could not but pass the home backs, the peculiar formation of the ground telling against them. Milward initiated a fine passing movement taken up by Chadwick, and Angus. The strong wind told against their efforts and the ‘‘Wolves'' was in the visitors half, an off-side goal being scored. The Everton forwards broke away in line, and Davies tested Rose for the first time and found him all there. The referee give an unfair decision against Everton, and spoiled what shaped to be a dangerous move. Brodie made a fine dribble down the centre, and tried a daisy cutter, but Smalley cleared in grand style, only to see Knight return with a high shot out of his reach. Again the home forwards, aided by the hill, were too good, and after Smalley had quickly thrown out several times, Wood shot it pass him for the fourth time. Ross now gave the first corner, which was futile and half-time arrived with the score- Wanderers 4 goals Everton nil.
In the second half, the Wanderers kicked off, and Everton now having the wind and hill showed very different play to the last half, and Ross was quickly called upon to save. Stevenson over ran the leather but soon recovered possession and Everton gained their first corner which was abortive. The Wanderers retaliated, and Smalley had to fist out. Milward tried a long shot, and Rose just kept it out, but keeping up the pressure, Everton gained a corner, but the sphere was kicked behind. The Wolves changed the venue, and after a scrimmage Brodie scored the fifth goal,. Everton forwards took up the attack and after pretty passing Watson tried a long shot, which went wide. Brodie initiated a pretty movement, and the Wolves had hard lines, the ball just going outside. The crowd were evidently delighted with the show of the Wolves. The visitors tried hard to retrieve the fortunes of the day without success. Hunter raced up the right, and tried a shot which just missed its mark. Again the home right wing were running up in grand style, But George Dobson who was throughout had played a grand game robbed them. Brodie ran and passed in spendid form. Ross proved a stumbling block, and Holt gave the leather to Davies, who was spoiled by Lowder. Again the Wolves were swarming in front, but shot behind. The game continued to be in favour of the home team, the visitors forwards being weak. Lowder and Allen being too many for them. Dobson was tried at half, Holt going back, but the charge did not make very much difference final score Wolvers 5 goals; Everton nil.
Teams Wolverhampton Wanderers:- Rose, goals, Baugh, and Flectcher, backs, Allen, Lowder, and Hunter, half-backs, White, Brodie, Wood, Knight,and Wykes forwards. Everton:- Smalley goal Dobson (g) and Ross (captain) backs, Stevenson (g), Holt, and Farmer, half-backs, Davies (j), Watson, Milward, Chadwick, and Angus, forwards.
EVERTON RESERVES 6 NORTHWICH VICTORIA 0
January 28 1889. The Liverpool Courier.
Fully 3,000 spectators welcomed the reserves forces of Northwich and Everton, who tried conclusion on the Anfield enclosure on Saturday. The home reserves were well represented, Bobby Jones receiving a very cordial reception on coming on the field. At 3-5 the teams faced each other, and Pollock being successful in the spin of the coin,, Beaman kicked off against the wind. The opening incidents were in favour of the Cheshire men, until Chadwick cleared his lines with a good punt. The brothers Brown broke away and forced a corner, which was well, placed, by Weir, the ball dropping nicely between the posts. Briscoe headed through five minutes from the start. This early reverse roused the visiting team, who broke down the left, and from a pass by Upton, Joliffe was called upon to save from Bowyer. From a throw in by Fayer, Keys dribbled up the right and passing to Taylor he in turn gave to Brown who headed through. A claim of off-side was raised but the referee decided in favour of the home club. Todd passing on the Northwich left brought the play into the Everton quarters, where a couple of corners were taken, nothing tangible resulting. From midfield Taylor put in a spendid run and again W .Brown got possession of the sphere, and from the touch line he put in a capital screw across the goal mouth, Briscoe increasing the lead with another fine header. Rowbottom and Hubbard raced down the right,, Pollock kicking clear; and again the Home left was busy. Winstanley gave a foul for ‘'hands'' the free kick passing between untouched. Everton still pressed, and after some fine passing in the Northwich goal mouth, Harper was again defeated by Briscoe but a claim for offside was sustained. Another good run by Rowbottom caused Pollock some trouble, the ball going outside. Williams threw in to Beaman who tried a shot that went wide. Weir brought relief, and again Harper was called upon to clear. Sand give his wing men a grand opening, which was spoilt by erractic shooting on the part of Hubbard. Chadwicl robbed the Cheshire left, and passing to Taylor he ran up and scored with a rattling shot, the ball passing over Harper' s hands. Score at half-time Everton Reserves 4 goals Northwich Victoria nil.
After the usual rest the teams changed ends. Taylor put the ball in motion. After a brief visit to the lower goal the visitors left rushed down, Chadwick and Pollock clearing in grand style. Everton raised the siege, and after a grand struggle another goal was scored out of a scrimmage. From the centre Northwich assumed the aggressive. Joliffe conceded another, which was kicked behind. Bob Brown removed the venue with a spendid run. Everton obtained a free kick for''hands'' Harper saving a good shot from Taylor. Play was now confined to the home quarters, a shot from Rowbottom going outside. Taylor and Brown removed the play to the other end, where another corner was taken Brown's final effort just missing the mark. A faulty kick by Fryre let in Beaman who forced Joliffe to clear. Keys and Briscoe pressed on the right and from a pass by Taylor Brown shot through a plea for off side was again sustained. The Everton forwards again came to the front from Keys going over, a good passing run by the Northwich van looked like scoring Chadwick kicked clear. The Everton forwards came again in line, Briscoe spoiling a good opening by rather selfish play. Bowyer and Upton got the better of Pollock a low shot from Hubbard going outside. Williams took a free kick, Upton missing a spendid opening by kicking over. Sands threw in Fryre kicking clear at a dangerous moment. From the kick out R.Brown dribbled down the centre Harper saving from Briscoe. Everton would not be denied, Harper fisting out from Brown and Taylor. A long kick Fryre enabled Keys to pass to R.Brown, who scored a very fine goal. The Northwich men made a good attempt at the other end and but could not break through the fine defense of Chadwick and Joliffe. Final Result, Everton 6 goals Northwich Victoria nil. Teams Northwich Victoria swifts, Harper goal, Molyneus,, and Dugs backs, Wilhams, Winstansley and Sands, half-backs, Rowbottom, Hubbard, Bowyer, Upton, and Beaman forwards. Everton Reserves:- Joilffe goal, Pollock (captain), and Chadwick (a) backs, Weir (c), Jones (r),, and Fayer, half-backs, Brown (w) Brown (r), Briscoe (w), Keys (j), and Taylor (a), forwards.
LIVERPOOL AND DISTRICT COMMENTS.
Athletic News - Monday 28 January 1889
By the Loiterer
WITH THE RESERVES TEAM
Whilst our senior teams were being slaughtered at Wolverhampton and Newton Heath, the reserve teams were achieving creditable victories at Everton and Bootle. At Everton some 3,000 spectators turned up to see the match with Northwich Victoria Reserve, and the home team won by six goals to nil. The Cheshire men were the first to attack, but from a corner Briscoe headed the first goal for Everton. Joliffe had then to handle, but the home right made off; and Brown scored a second goal. The Northwich left were again prominent, but only a couple of abortive corners resulted. W. Brown finished a capital run by a splendid screw across the goal, and Briscoe headed a third goal. Play was generally in favour of the home team, though Rowbottom played a smart game, and Everton ran out easy winners.
WOLVERHAMPTON NOTE
Athletic News - Monday 28 January 1889
THE WANDERERS AGAIN THIRD ON THE LIST
Saturday’s match being the first visit of Everton to Wolverhampton, considerable interest was taken in it, and the weather being very favourable a good gate turned up to witness the game. Both teams were well represented, the following players facing each other at a few minutes after three. The teams were: - Everton; Smalley, goal; Dobson and N.J. Ross, bacs; Stephenson, Holt and Famer, half-backs; Davies, Watson, Milward, Chadwick and Angus, forwards.
Wanderers;- Rose, goal; Baugh and Mason, backs; Fletcher, Allen, and Lowder, half-backs; Hunter, Wykes, Brodie, Wood, and Knight, forwards.
The Wanderers won the toss and elected to play downhill and with the wind. The game for the first few minutes was of a rather give and-take character, but the home team soon warmed to their work, and Lowder scored out of a scrummage. The Wanderers continued to have the best of it, and Wood speedily obtained another goal. This point the visitors appealed against, on the plea of off-side, but the referee allowed it. The play up to now had been remarkably fast, but it afterwards slowed down somewhat. A foul, close in, gave the visitor; a chance: but the defence of Baugh and Mason was too good, and the pressure was soon relieved, and from a combined run the home team again scored by the aid of Wood. This point was again hotly disputed by Ross and his men, but the referee promptly allowed the goal. The visitors upon this held a consultation on the field, and talked of retiring, but better counsels prevailed. The Wanderers succeeded in putting the ball through twice more before half-time, but the referee disallowed one point. With the slope and wind in their favour, it was expected the visitors would now show to much better advantage. This they did, but the home team more than held their own. The shooting of the Everton forwards was very defective, Rose having no difficulty in stopping the shots they made. On the other hand, the home team beat Smalley on two occasions, one of which was disallowed for offside, the Wanderers ultimately winning by five goals to nothing. The game throughout was of a very unpleasant character, the visitors appealing and protesting against five out of the seven goals kicked by the Wanderers, and because the referee did not give way to them in every case they behaved in the most reprehensible manner. Ross, who evidently lost his temper in the first five minutes of the game, was especially to blame, and some of the appeals made by him, bearing in mind his long experience, were simply childish, and at the same astonishing. I am confident the referee, who has had plenty of experience in that capacity, was perfectly correct in his decisions. If he male any mistake whatever it was in disallowing the fourth goal, scored by Knight, many good judges on the field being of opinion that the player referred to was not offside. The secret of the matter is Everton were beaten at all points of the game, and they allowed their chagrin and temper to get the better of their Judgment. But it is very regrettable that teams of the standing of Everton cannot take a defeat in a better spirit. I hope when the teams meet again at Everton the game will prove a much more pleasant one. As regards the players, Ross was much the best man on the visitors' side, and proved all through a tower of strength. Both he and Dobson, however, played rather roughly at times, but this was probably owing to the cause above referred to. In spite of the score against him, Smalley played well. I did not think much of the half-back play, while the forwards sadly lacked combination. Of the home players it is scarcely necessary to individualize; they all played well, as the score sufficiently testifies. Among the forwards, Wykes, who for the first time took inside right, played capitally, especially in the second half, when he succeeded several times in getting the best of the redoubtable Ross, and was loudly cheered by the spectators. Brodie, who has not been well for several days, played fairly under the circumstances, and did a lot of work. All the backs were in capital form, while Rose, in goal, did all required of him is a cool and safe manner.